"Men are scum" and the Facebook censors

Simon Van Zuylen-Wood, Vanity Fair, 2/26/19; Ashley Wells, CC Liu (eds.), Wisdom Quarterly

I'm just a figurehead taking orders from FBI.

A group of people in a room sitting at a table.

Men are scum. You can’t say that on Facebook.

Men are pigs. You can’t say that either.

Men are trash.... Men are garbage fires. Also banned.

It’s 9:00 am on an autumn Tuesday, and I’m sitting in on a meeting about “men are scum” at Facebook’s campus in Menlo Park, California.

The trouble started a year ago, in the fall of 2017. The #MeToo Movement had recently begun. Nicole Silverberg, currently a writer on Full Frontal with Samantha Bee, had shared on her Facebook page a trove of bilious comments directed at her after she’d written a list of ways men “need to do better.”

In the comments section beneath her post, another comic, Marcia Belsky, wrote, “Men are scum.”

Facebook kicked Belsky off the platform for 30 days. This seemed absurd. First of all, the news at the time was dominated by stories of men acting scummily.

Second, Facebook had been leaving up plenty of well-documented crap. By then the company was deep into an extended cycle of bad press over the toxic, fraudulent, and/or covertly Russian content that had polluted its platform throughout the 2016 presidential campaign.

In Western Europe, the far right was using the site to vilify Middle Eastern migrants.

In Southeast Asia, authoritarian regimes were using it to dial up anger against religious minorities and political enemies.

But Facebook was taking down “men are scum”? Belsky hopped on a 500-person (Facebook) group of female comics. A bunch of them were getting banned for similar infractions, even as they reported sexist invective being hurled their way.

They decided to protest by spamming the platform. On November 24, dozens of “men are scum” posts went up. And then… More

• Dakota Johnson on Family, Sex—And the “Psychotic” Making of Fifty Shades of Grey

• The Fall of Roe and the Rise of Republican Orthodoxy at the Supreme Court

• Why John Franzese Jr. Flipped on His Father, One of History’s Most Notorious Mobsters

• January 6 Was Only the Beginning of Ashli Babbitt as Martyr in Trump’s Cult

• The 15 Best TV Shows of 2022, So Far

• “I’m Sorry for the Pain You Have Experienced”: Ghislaine Maxwell Sentenced to 20 Years

• Oops: Unearthed Footage Shows Ivanka Was All In on Her Father’s Election Scheme

• “You Know What I Say About Men Who F--- Asian Women?”

• From the Archive: How Abortion-Rights Icon “Jane Roe” Became a Pro-Life Activist

• MSN
• Death of Gabby Petito: Inside her last days with Brian Laundrie | Vanity Fair
• IN PERSON | Tantric Dating Tickets, Multiple Dates | Eventbrite