Showing posts with label devadatta. Show all posts
Showing posts with label devadatta. Show all posts

Sunday, May 17, 2026

Buddhism and Dalai Lama on meat eating


Can Buddhists eat meat?
  • What have we said time and again? Buddhists can do whatever they want. However, killing (or violating any of the other precepts) is not keeping in line with what the Buddha taught.
  • "Pig's Delight" (sukaramaddava): truffles, but in the case of the final meal offering, inadvertently poisonous/toxic mushrooms picked in error thinking them truffles, which pigs love
  • Rule: A Buddhist monastic is not allowed to eat three kinds of "meat" (slaughtered flesh) -- that of a living being that is seen, heard, or suspected of having been killed for one's sake
Did the Buddha pass away from eating meat or mushrooms or by choice?

The precise contents of the Buddha's final meal are not clear, due to variant scriptural traditions and ambiguity over the translation of certain significant terms like sukara-maddava.

The Theravada tradition generally believes that the Buddha was offered "pig's delight" (sukaramaddava) which could be slaughtered pork or some kind of mushroom/food pigs delight in that was offered by the blacksmith Cunda, while the Mahayana tradition believes that the Buddha consumed a truffle or other mushroom [mistaken to be edible].

These differing translations may reflect the different traditional views on Buddhist vegetarianism and the precepts for monastics (monks and nuns) [265] as well as laypersons.

Modern scholars disagree on this topic, arguing both for pig's delight, pig's flesh, or some kind of plant or mushroom that pigs delight in eating [z].

Whatever the case, none of the sources that mention the last meal attribute the Buddha's sickness to the meal itself [266]. But it is widely thought that he suffered severe illness from being unable to safely digest to toxic food, which he directed Cunda to dig a hole and bury rather than offering to any other monastic present at the meal.

As per the "Great Final Nirvana Discourse" (Mahaparinibbana Sutta), after the meal with Cunda the blacksmith, the Buddha and his monastic companions continued to walk until he was too weak to continue.

They stopped at Kushinagar (near modern Gorakphur, India), where Ānanda was directed by the Buddha to prepare a resting place of folded robes between two sala trees in a delightful grove [267, 268].

After announcing to the Monastic Sangha (spiritual community) that he would soon be passing away, reclining into final nirvana, the Buddha personally ordained one last novice into the Monastic Order. His name was Subhadda [267].

He then repeated his final exhortations to the Sangha, which was that when he was no longer present to guide them, the Dhamma and Vinaya (Doctrine and Discipline, Teaching and Training) was to be their guide.

Then he asked if anyone had any doubts about the Teachings, but nobody did [269]. The Buddha waited, satisfied that anyone who would have like to speak or ask any final question had the opportunity to do so.

His final words are reported to have been: "All formations (saṅkhāras, fabrications) are hurtling towards destruction. Strive for the goal with diligence (appamāda)." In Pali this is, "vayadhammā saṅkhārā appamādena sampādethā" [270, 271].

He then entered the eight jhanas as his final meditation forward and then reversing, as verified by a psychic monk near him, reaching what is known as parinirvana ("final nirvana"). He did not "die," for if he had, he would be reborn as all ordinary being are reborn in accordance with their karma.

Rather than being reborn, "the Five Aggregates of physical and mental phenomena clung to as self that constitute a being cease to occur" [272] just as a fire, having exhausted its substrate of fuel goes out. But what is it that really goes out, a being? No, what goes out completely is ignorance.

The Mahaparinibbana Sutta reports that as his final act, the Buddha performed a final meditation of entering the first four material meditative absorptions (jhanas) consecutively, then the four immaterial absorptions, and finally a meditative dwelling known as "the extinction of feeling and perception" (nirodha-samāpatti), which should not be thought of as a permanent "extinction" since many Buddhist meditation practitioners are able to reach this attainment even now throughout life. It is said that only noble ones (those who have attained the stages of enlightenment) are able to reach it and can do so as often as they like as many times as they like. If it were a permanent extinction, no one would be able to do it a second, third, or thousandth time.

Before returning to the fourth absorption (jhana) right at the moment of passing into final nirvana without remainder [273, 268].

Having traveled and taught, the Buddha took his last meal, a sincere offering from a blacksmith named Cunda. But having eaten it, he fell violently ill. Not wishing that Cunda have remorse or misgivings about his offering, the Buddha instructed his personal attendant Ānanda to tell Cunda something.

The meal offering eaten at his place had nothing to do with his passing. Moreover, such an offering was an extraordinary source of merit because it was provided as a last meal for a buddha [262] tantamount to an offering of food to a bodhisatta before his attainment of supreme awakening (buddhahood, arahantship, great-enlightenment).

Bhikkhu Mettanando and Oskar von Hinüber argue that the Buddha passed away due to mesenteric infarction, a symptom of old age, rather than mushroom food poisoning [263, 264]. More

Wednesday, January 22, 2025

Jesus in Buddhism: Buddha, Devadatta


Jesus in Buddhism: Jesus as a bodhisattva
(BuddhaVerse) Some Buddhists perceive Jesus as a bodhisattva — a being trying to become fully spiritually enlightened to "save" others by guiding them to spiritual enlightenment, as all beings at some time or other are striving for liberation from suffering and rebirth.
  • [The Ayutthaya Kingdom was in ancient Siam (modern Thailand), which resisted Christian missionaries and their Catholic (Vatican) hegemony.]
  • Where did Jesus get his famous Seamless saffron robe [Vajrayana-like Buddhist tunic smock like some swamis, such as Parahamsa Yogananda, use] of Jesus?
  • Why do swamis wear pajama robes rather than real robes? 
  • [Who is Devadatta? He was once a great monk who made the mistake of pursuing magical powers rather than liberation, squandering his great fortune to know and be close to the Buddha. Devadatta is the Judas Iscariot figure in Buddhism who, rather than practicing for awakening, grew an ego so big he tried to usurp the Buddha and take over the Sangha ("spiritual community" the Buddha had built, which may have had 80,000 or more members since many of those members were members because of their attainment of the paths-and-fruits, and the majority of them would have been devas (angelic light beings visiting or living on the human plane) rather than humans on Earth. Devadatta was the Buddha's cousin, the brother of his former wife (Bimba Devi, known as Princess Yasodhara, with a long history of envy and rivalry with the buddha-to-be or the Bodhisatta, as the Buddha referred to himself when talking about times and events before his great enlightenment). Devadatta held a grudge, and though he did much good in becoming a monk and practicing for 40 years or so, he was rotten and one of the very worst people in the history of Buddhism, almost on par with Mara Namuci. He was not the Buddha's brother, whose name was Nanda, the sibling of their sister Sundari Nanda, who became enlightened monastics like so many of the Scythians/Sakas/Shakyians did, even Devadatta's sister Ven. Yasodhara (who is obscured in Buddhism as badly as "Mary" is in Christianity, hidden by the use of many names to refer to her: Rahulamata or "Rahula's Mother"), Bhadda, Bhadda Kaccana Theri, Bhaddakacca, Bhadda Sundari, Bimba Devi, and Subhadakka, who after the Buddha's return home became a nun, a knowledgeable disciple of the Dharma, an unbeatable debater, and a respected and beloved fully enlightened elder (theri) Buddhist nun, along with the Buddha's mother and many Scythian/Saka princesses and family members, including their son Ven. Rahula, "foremost in doing quiet good."]
Some beings commit to striving not only for full awakening (arahantship) but also supreme or perfect awakening (samma-sam-buddhahood, Sanskrit samyak-sam-buddha) to be able to effectively help others gain realization or bodhi and achieve liberation or nirvana, which is the extinction of ignorance because only an illusion came into and goes out of being.
  • [One can argue that there are three types of buddhas: (1) the fully supremely enlightened, (2) the fully enlightened nonteaching or "silent" (pacceka) buddha, and (3) the fully enlightened personal buddha (arahant). All three experience the exact same awakening to the truth, but the first two have special knowledge, and the first has special abilities (the ten powers) beyond. What makes a buddha so extraordinary is that he (as there seems to be no shes because any being bent on supreme enlightenment, a bodhisatta, needs two things to succeed, at least according to Theravada Buddhism, and in doing so will repeatedly be reborn as a male, as the Dalai Lama and Vajrayana Buddhism agree with the ancient Theravada commentaries. Those two are a vow of strong determination to achieve self-awakening at a time when the Dharma no longer exists and no one is being liberated and a sure prediction of success by a current buddha. When the historical Buddha Siddhartha Gautama, aka "Shakyamuni" or the "Sage of the Scythians/Sakas," determined to become a buddha, he did so in the presence of Dipankara Buddha aeons ago, or at least many generations ago as kappa/kalpa may also refer to an ordinary human lifespan at the time, and this span is very variable, going from less than 100 years up to 80,000 years, Dipankara Buddha knew his determination and gave him a prediction of eventual success. How long it takes to eventually succeed is hard to fathom and/or calculate. If a kappa/kalpa is translated as it normally is, it can be millions or hundreds of millions or hundreds of billions of years, astronomical time, archeological time, epochs, ages, which does not make sense since in that deep past there were Vedas ("Knowledge Books") and Sanskrit  language texts and Brahmins (brahmanas) and wandering ascetics (shramanas) and things that seem like much more recent developments on the human plane, which would not seem to have existed millions and billions of years ago. But that is the official Theravada line. We prefer to think that buddhas and tirthankaras like Mahavira, the Nigantha Nataputta (aka Vardhamana), the founder of Jainism, arise much more frequently than that, something more in the range of being separated by thousands or tens of thousands of years rather than aeons. The historical Buddha Gautama named 24 or so previous buddhas and many pacceka buddhas, never suggesting to anyone they pursue those careers but constantly, daily, encouraging and helping countless human and deva beings to become arhats or fully enlightened disciples as quickly as possible. Why? Everything can wait, but our pursuit of wisdom and compassion cannot wait. The opportunity to ever hear and practice the Dharma/Dhamma is so incredibly rare that we have to seize the day and practice, learn, hear, and ask teachers NOW. There's only now.]
His selfless actions and willingness to sacrifice himself for others align with the ideals of a Buddhist bodhisattva [and his training in ancient Tibet/ now India at Hemis Buddhist Monastery in Ladakh in the Himalayas, where Vajrayana (a form of Mahayana) Buddhist lamas are taught to strive for bodhisattva careers rather than personal enlightenment and liberation.
The Dalai Lama has repeatedly expressed admiration for Jesus Christ [who is explained with shocking clarity as a mystery school leader by Ancient Greek biblical scholar Dr. Ammon Hillman], calling him a great teacher of love and compassion. He emphasizes that Christianity and [Mahayana] Buddhism can learn from each other despite doctrinal differences.

Download new app from Google Play and get notifications, daily quotes from the Buddha, guided meditation methods, articles about Buddhist wisdom, and suttas (sutras, discourses) from the Pali language canon. Discover inner peace, cultivate mindfulness (sati), and unlock the infinite wisdom of the Buddha with this app. APP: play.google.com/store/apps...

Thanks for watching. This channel is new and needs support. On it find many videos on the history and philosophical teachings of Buddhism. Please subscribe to support the teachings of the Buddha on YouTube. Website: buddhaverse.site.
  • BuddhaVerse (video), Jan. 8, 2025; most of text and all commentary by Dhr. Seven, Amber Larson, Pat Macpherson (eds.), Wisdom Quarterly

Tuesday, February 20, 2024

Sutra: To cross the wilderness, avoid fools

Ken and Visakha Kawasaki (trans.), Apannaka Jataka (Jat 1), Jataka Tales of the Buddha, Part I edited by Dhr. Seven, Ananda (Dharma Buddhist Meditation), Wisdom Quarterly
Crossing the Wilderness
Many strange things happened in the past.
While the Buddha was staying at Jetavana Monastery near the city of Savatthi, the wealthy banker, Anathapindika ("Donor to the Needy"), one day went to pay his respects. His servants carried masses of flowers, perfume, candle butter, oil, honey, molasses, cloths, and robes.

Anathapindika bowed to the Buddha, made his offerings, and sat respectfully to one side. At that time he was accompanied by many friends who were followers of other teachers.

His friends also paid respect to the Buddha and sat close to the banker. The Buddha's face appeared like a full moon, his body surrounded by a radiant aura. Seated on the red stone seat, he was like a young lion roaring with a clear, noble voice as he taught them a beautiful discourse sweet to the ear.

After hearing the Buddha's teaching, they gave up their other practices and took guidance from the Three Gems: the Buddha, the Dhamma, and the Sangha.
  • [Three Gems: The Teacher, the Teaching, and the successfully Taught, the noble-sangha of enlightened disciples who have reached any of the stages of awakening from stream entry to arhatship.]
After that, they returned regularly with Anathapindika to offer flowers and incense and to hear teachings. They gave liberally, kept the Five Precepts, and faithfully observed the Lunar Fasting (Uposatha) Day.
  • [1: The Uposatha is the lunar observance day or "Sabbath," based on the four phases of the moon every month, when one undertakes the Eight Precepts rather than the ordinary five, fasting after noon to the next day, staying in the temple to hear the Dhamma or Dharma and putting it into practice.]
Soon after the Buddha left Savatthi to return to Rajagaha, however, these men abandoned the Dhamma and reverted to their previous beliefs.

Seven or eight months later, the Buddha returned to Jetavana. Again, Anathapindika brought these friends to visit the Buddha. They paid their respects, but Anathapindika explained that they had forsaken the guidance of the Three Gems and had resumed their previous practices.

The Buddha asked, "Is it true that you have abandoned taking guidance from the Three Gems for guidance from other doctrines?"

The Buddha's voice was incredibly clear because throughout many aeons he had always spoken truthfully.

When these men heard it, they were unable to conceal the truth. "Yes, Blessed One," they admitted. "It is true."

"Disciples," the Buddha said "nowhere between the lowest of hells below and the highest heavens above, nowhere in all the countless worlds that stretch right and left, is there the equal, much less the superior, of a buddha.

"Incalculable is the excellence that springs from being guided by the Five Precepts and from other virtuous conduct."

Then he declared the virtues of the Three Gems: "By going for guidance to the Three Gems," he told them, "one escapes from rebirth in all states of suffering." He further explained that meditation on the Three Gems leads through the four stages of enlightenment.

"In forsaking such guides as this," he admonished them, "you have certainly strayed.

"In the past, too, men who foolishly mistook what was no guide for a real guide, met with disaster. They fell prey to ghouls (yakkhas, djinn, vicious spirits) in the wilderness and came to ruin.

In contrast, people who stuck to the truth not only survived, they prospered in that same wilderness."

Anathapindika raised clasped hands to his forehead, gave praise, and asked the Buddha to tell that story of the past (jataka or rebirth tale).

"In order to dispel the world's ignorance and to conquer all suffering," the Buddha proclaimed, "I practiced the Ten Perfections for countless aeons. Listen carefully, and I will speak."

Having their full attention, the Buddha made clear, as if he were releasing a full moon from behind clouds, what rebirth had concealed from them:

Story of the Past
Proceed with caution. MONSTER CROSSING AHEAD. Do not be swayed by strangers.
The Parks Department posts signs today, whereas ancient American Indians used pictographs.
.
Long, long ago, when Brahmadatta was reigning in Baranasi (Varanasi, ancient India), the Bodhisatta (the Buddha-to-be) was reborn into a merchant's family and grew up to be a wise trader.

At the same time, in the same city, there was another merchant, a very foolish fellow, with no common sense whatsoever.

One day it so happened that the two merchants each loaded many carts with costly wares of Baranasi and prepared to leave in the same direction at the same time.

The wise merchant thought, "If this young fool travels with me and if our many carts stay together, it will be too much for the road. Finding wood and water for the help will be difficult, and there won't be enough grass for the oxen. Either he or I must go first."

"Look," he said to the other merchant, "the two of us can't travel together. Would you rather go first or follow after me?"

The foolish trader thought, "There will be many advantages if I take the lead. I'll get a road that is not yet rutted and cut up. My oxen will have the pick of fresh grass. My help will get the choicest wild herbs for curry. The water will be undisturbed. Best of all, I'll be able to set my own price for bartering my goods." Considering all of these advantages, he said, "I will go ahead of you, friend!"

The Bodhisatta was pleased to hear this because he saw many advantages in following after. He reasoned:

"Those carts going first will level the road where it is rough, and I'll be able to travel along the road they have already smoothed. Their oxen will graze off the coarse old grass, and mine will pasture on the sweet young growth that will spring up in its place. My help will find fresh sweet herbs for curry where the old ones have been picked. Where there is no water, the first caravan will have to dig wells to supply themselves, and we'll be able to drink at the wells they have dug. Haggling over prices is tiresome work; he will do the work, and I will be able to barter my wares at prices he has already set."

"Very well, friend!" he said. "Please go first."

"I will," said the foolish merchant, and he yoked his carts and set out. After a while he came to the outskirts of a wilderness. He filled his huge jars with water before setting out to cross the many leagues (yojanas) of desert that stretched before him.
  • [A yojana is an ancient measure of distance that is literally the length a yoked ox can walk before it needs to be unyoked and rested, which is commonly thought to be the equivalent of about 7 miles. This would have made great sense in an agrarian society.]
Throw that water away. There's more not far from here. Lighten your load and go quickly.
.
Ghouls (yakkhas)? Wild spirits called jinn.
The ghoul (yakkha) who haunted that wilderness had been watching the caravan. When it reached the middle, he used his power to conjure up a lovely carriage drawn by pure white young bulls.

With a retinue of a dozen disguised ghouls carrying swords and shields, he rode along in his carriage like a mighty lord. His wet his hair and clothes, and he wore a wreath of blue lotuses and white water-lilies around his head. His attendants also wet themselves until they dripped, and they draped themselves in similar garlands. Even the bulls' hooves and carriage wheels were muddied.

Because the wind was blowing from the front, the merchant was riding at the head of his caravan to escape the dust. The ghoul drew his carriage beside the merchant's and greeted him kindly with friendly words. The merchant returned the greetings and moved his carriage aside to allow the carts to pass while he and the ghoul in disguise chatted.

"Sir, we are on our way from Baranasi," explained the merchant. "I see that you are all wet and muddy and that you have lotuses and water lilies. Did it rain while you were on the road, or did you come across water pools with lotuses and water lilies?"

"What is it that you say?" the ghoul exclaimed. "Just over there is a dark-green streak of a jungle. Beyond that there is plenty of water. It is always raining there, and there are many lakes with lotuses and water lilies."

Then, pretending to be interested in the merchant's business, the ghoul asked, "What do you have in these carts?"

"Expensive merchandise," answered the merchant.

"What is in this cart that seems so heavily laden?" the ghoul asked as the last cart rolled by.

"That cart is full of water."

Deceptive advice
The ghoul complimented him, "You were wise to carry water with you this far," and advised him: "There is no need for it now because water is so abundant ahead. You could travel much faster if you lighten your load by emptying those heavy jars. You'd be better off breaking them and throwing the water away. Well, good day," he said suddenly, as he turned his carriage, "we must be on our way. We have stopped too long already." He rode away quickly with his carts. As soon as they were out of sight, he turned and made his way back to his city.

Youthful foolishness
The merchant was so foolish that he followed the ghoul's advice. He smashed his water jars, without saving a single cupful and ordered his crew to drive on quickly.

Of course, they never found any water, and they were soon exhausted from thirst. At sunset they drew their carts into a circle and tethered the oxen to the wheels. But there was no way to slake the weary animals' thirst and no rain.

Without water, the crew could not cook any rice either. They sank to the ground and fell asleep. As soon as darkness came, the ghouls attacked, killing everyone and all the animals.

The fiends devoured the flesh, leaving only bones, and departed. Skeletons were strewn in every direction, but the carts stood with their loads untouched. The heedless young merchant was the sole cause of the ruin and destruction of the entire caravan.

Second caravan
Allowing six weeks to pass after the foolish trader had set off, the Bodhisatta set forth with his many carts. When he reached the edge of the wilderness, he filled his water jars.

Then he assembled his crew and announced, "Let not so much as a handful of water be used without my permission. Furthermore, there are poisonous plants in this wilderness. Do not eat any leaf, flower, or fruit which you have never eaten before, without showing it to me first." Having carefully warned the crew, he led the caravan into the wilderness.

The ghoul appears
When they reached the middle of the wilderness, the same ghoul appeared on the path just as before. The merchant noticed his red eyes and fearless manner and suspected something was not quite right.

"I know there is no water in the desert," he said to himself. "Furthermore, this weird stranger casts no shadow. He must be some kind of ghoul. He probably tricked that foolish merchant, but he doesn't realize that I may know better."

"Get lost!" he shouted at the ghoul. "We are on business. We do not throw away water before we see where more is to come from!"

Without saying any more, the ghoul rode away.

As soon as the ghouls had left, the merchant's crew approached their leader and said, "Sir, they were wearing lotuses and water lilies on their heads. Their clothes and hair were dripping wet. They told us that up ahead there is a thick green forest where it is always raining.

"Let's throw away our water so we can proceed more quickly with lightened carts!"

The merchant ordered a halt and summoned all the entire crew. He asked them, "Has anyone among you ever heard before today that there is a lake or a pool in this wilderness?"

"No, sir," they answered. "In fact, it's known as the 'Waterless Desert.'"

"We have just been told by some shady strangers that it is raining in the forest just ahead. How far does a rain-wind carry?"

"Seven miles (one yojana), sir."

"Has anyone here seen the top of even a single storm cloud?"

"No, sir!"

"How far off can a person see a flash of lightning?"

"Four or five leagues (yojanas), sir."

"Has anyone here seen a flash of lightning?"

"No, sir."

"How far off can one hear the peal of thunder?"

"Two or three leagues, sir."

"Has anyone here heard a peal of thunder?"

"No, sir."

"Those were not humans but ghouls," the wise merchant told the crew. "They are hoping that we would throw away our water. Then, weak and faint and unable to defend ourselves, they plan to return to devour us.

"Since the young merchant who went ahead of us was not a man of good sense, most likely he was fooled by them. We may expect to find his carts standing just as they were first loaded. We will probably come across them today. Press on in full speed, without throwing away a single drop of water!"

Just as the merchant predicted, his caravan soon came across the carts with the skeletons of men and oxen strewn in every direction. He ordered the crew to arrange the carts in a fortified circle, to take care of the oxen, and to prepare an early supper [of rice and curry] for themselves. After the animals and crew had all safely bedded down, the merchant and a coterie of guards with swords in hand stood watch through the night.

At daybreak the merchant replaced weak carts for stronger ones from those abandoned and exchanged his own common goods for the costliest of the merchandise left behind by the foolish trader.

When he arrived at his destination, he was able to barter his stock of wares at two or three times their value. He returned to his city without losing a single member out of his crew.

Meanwhile, back in the present
This story of the past ended, the Buddha said, "Thus it was, lay disciples, that in times past, the foolish came to utter ruin and destruction, while those who stuck to the truth evaded the cruel hands of ghouls, reached their destination safely, and were able to return to their homes again.

"Sticking to the truth endows happiness even up to rebirth in the World of Brahma.
  • [3: The World of Brahma (brahmaloka0 is a celestial world beyond the Sensual Sphere, in what is called the Fine-Material Sphere. It surpasses the sensual heavens and is superior to them in pleasure and length of lifespan.]
Moreover, it also leads ultimately to full enlightenment (arahantship). Following untruth entails rebirth either in the four states of downfall or in the worst conditions of the human world."

After the Buddha expounded the Four Ennobling (Enlightening) Truths, those many lay disciples were established in the fruit of the first path, reaching the first stage of enlightenment (stream entry).

The Buddha concluded this lesson by identifying the rebirth as follows: "The foolish young merchant at that time was Devadatta [4] and his crew were Devadatta's followers. The wise merchant's crew were the followers of the Buddha, and I myself was that wise merchant."

Saturday, August 29, 2020

Do some monks really eat meat?

Ven. Ariyesako (The Bhikkhus' Rules: A Guide for Laypeople compiled and explained by Bhikkhu Ariyesako, Meat Eating); Dhr. Seven, Ananda (DBM), Ashley Wells (eds.), Wisdom Quarterly
Hey, let's prepare vegan food and offer it with our own hands to the monks and nunsa. - Yes.
.
Don't kill, and don't pay butchers to kill (TNH).
In Western countries compassionate and environmental vegetarianism is increasing in popularity, and this has led to questions about Buddhist monastics and meat eating.

The question of monks and nuns' eating meat is an old one, which was once explicitly raised by the "renegade monk" Ven. Devadatta (Buddhism's Judas figure, who was the brother of Prince Siddhartha's wife and his cousin, who was a monk for a long time practicing to develop psychic powers rather than wisdom or compassion).

He asked the Buddha to prohibit wandering ascetics from eating fish and flesh of all kinds in a ploy to usurp the Buddha and take over the leadership of the Monastic Community (Sangha).

It was Devadatta's "stricter ascetic" tactic, suggesting he would be a better leader with purer standards. The Buddha had already established a strict rule for both monastics and laypeople about not taking life (see Killing), so he disagreed with Devadatta's ploy.

The Buddha allowed monastics to eat meat and fish [88] except under the following circumstances:

If a monastic sees, hears, or so much as suspects that it has been killed for one, that monastic is forbidden to eat it [89] (M.I,369).

A modern Theravada monk on alms round in England (Ajahn Manapo/Forest Monastery).
.
If a monastic is given meat on alms round and has no knowledge about how the animal was murdered [90], that monastic has to "receive it with attentiveness." To receive it does not necessarily mean to eat it. (See the Sekhiya Trainings.)

One should be grateful and recollect that food one is given is what enables one to continue to live the monastic, wandering ascetic, mendicant life, and as a mendicant one is not in a position to choose what one is given.

If one later comes to know the family and they ask about the Dharma, one will be able to explain the precept about not killing. This may cause them to reflect on their attitude toward meat eating.

An individual layperson can choose whether to be a vegan, vegetarian, or whatever. Problems usually arise only when vegetarians try to impose their choice on others. As meal times are normally a family or shared affair, this can create tensions and misunderstandings.

An individual monastic who lives on alms food cannot make such choices. Often the donors are unknown — perhaps not even Buddhist, or just starting to find out about Dharma — and to refuse their generosity may so offend them that they never have anything to do with Dharma again.

Karma: Wish I'd donated pure vegan food!
Finally it comes down to the laypeople who go to the market to buy food to give to monastics [who commit a kind of killing by paying others to kill when buying slaughtered and butchered animals, being complicit in that killing by paying for it].

If they are vegetarian themselves or like to give pure food, then the monastic should receive that food with "appreciation" — especially if it means that fewer animals are being tormented and slaughtered.

Nevertheless, it should not become a political issue where other people are attacked for their behavior. Source

COMMENTARY: Note the strong bias of meat eating monks and scholars who present the Buddhist view on this subject. For it is easier to change anyone's religion than his or her diet. Ask a vegan and get a whole different reading of what the Buddhist Monastic Code says, as one can point to many back stories and examples where vegetarianism was the norm for wandering ascetics, yogis, shamans, Brahmins, and spiritual seekers in the East. Few people, who themselves rarely ate meat, would ever think to give it to renunciants. For there was a time when everyone knew, which is to say it was common knowledge, that flesh does not conduce to dispassion, letting go, and purity. But it is not by diet alone that one would ever gain these three things, which is what Buddhism contributed to ancient Indian spirituality. Diet is a component of a spiritual life, not a be all end all. Practice compassion and wisdom.

Thursday, May 25, 2017

Banned from the Bible: deleted stories (video)




Raphael Stories that were deleted from biblical history: BANNED FROM THE BIBLE reveals some alternative tales and examines why they were "too hot for Christianity."

Gospel of Judas: What does it really say?


ReligionForBreakfast
R.F.B.
The Gospel of Judas caused a huge stir when National Geographic published it back in 2006. But to this day, misconceptions about this text abound. Who wrote this text? And what does it really say?

"The Gospel of Judas"
National Geographic, May 5, 2014

 

Thursday, December 24, 2015

The Elephant (Dhammapada verses)

Amber Larson, Crystal Quintero, Dhr. Seven (eds.), Wisdom Quarterly; Acharya Buddharakkhita (trans.), Nagavagga, "The Elephant" (Dhp XXIII, Dhp. 320-333); G.P. Malalasekera
Theravada Buddhist monk meditating in the jungle with elephant (Santi foto/flickr.com)
.
Burmese monks (S. Ranieri)
320. As an elephant in the battlefield withstands arrows shot from bows all around, even so shall I endure abuse. There are many, indeed, who lack virtue.
 
321. A tamed elephant is led into a crowd, and the ruler mounts a tamed elephant. Best among humans is the subdued one who endures abuse.
 
322. Excellent are well-trained mules, thoroughbred Sindhu horses, and noble tusker elephants. But better still is the person who has subdued him or herself.
323. Not by these mounts, however, would one go to the Untrodden Land (nirvana), as one who is self-tamed goes by one's own tamed and well-controlled mind (heart).

The American Buddhist nun Ayya Tathaaloka giving the gift of the Dharma (bhikkhuni.net).
.
Novice nun, Burma (Huggy's pics)
324. Musty during rut, the tusker-elephant named Dhanapalaka* is uncontrollable. Held in captivity, the tusker does not touch a morsel of food, but only longingly calls to mind the elephant forest.
 
325. When a person is sluggish and gluttonous, sleeping and rolling around in bed like a fat domestic pig, that sluggard undergoes rebirth again and again.
 
Elephant perahera (flickr.com)
326. Formerly this mind (heart) wandered about as it liked, where it wished and according to its pleasure, but now I shall thoroughly master it with wisdom as a mahout controls with ankus an elephant in rut.
 
327. Delight in heedfulness! Guard well your thoughts! Draw yourself out of this bog of harm, even as an elephant draws itself out of the mud.
328. If for company you find a wise and prudent friend who leads a good life, you should, overcoming all impediments, keep that person's company joyfully and mindfully.
 
Mahout bathes elephant (Cyrille Gibot)
329. If for company you cannot find a wise and prudent friend who leads a good life, then, like a king who leaves behind a conquered kingdom, or like a lone elephant in the elephant forest, go your way alone.
 
330. Better it is to live alone; there is no keeping fellowship with a fool. Live alone and do no harm; be carefree like an elephant in the elephant forest.
331. Good are friends when need arises; good is contentment with just what one has; good is merit when life is at an end; and good is the abandoning of all suffering (through enlightenment).
 
Pārileyya elephant and the Buddha (ES)
332. In this world, good it is to serve one's mother, good it is to serve one's father, good it is to serve monastics, and good it is to serve the enlightened persons.
 
333. Good is virtue until life's end, good is confidence that is steadfast, good is the acquisition of wisdom, and good is the avoidance of harmful karma.
*The Elephant Nalagiri
G.P. Malalasekera (Dictionary of Pali Proper Names, PTS) edited by Wisdom Quarterly
Drunk Nalagiri charges the Buddha who responds with loving-kindness taming the beast.
 
Nalagiri (Takht-i-bahi Museum)
Nālāgiri was an elephant who lived in the royal stalls at Rājagaha. Ven. Devadatta, after several vain attempts to kill the Buddha, obtained Prince Ajātasattu's consent to use Nālagiri as a means of bringing about the Buddha's death.

The elephant, he said, knows nothing of the Buddha's virtues. He will have no hesitation in destroying him. Nālagiri was indeed a fierce animal, but in order to increase his fierceness, Devadatta instructed his keeper (mahout) to give him twice his usual amount of alcoholic toddy.

A proclamation was then made with the beating of drums that the streets of the city should be cleared as Nālāgiri would be let loose upon them.

The people ran, but Ananda stepped in to save the Buddha. The Buddha saved himself and the royal elephant Nalagiri, who was soothed with waves of loving-kindness (metta).
 
In Parileyyaka forest
The Buddha was informed of this and warned against going into the city for alms. He ignored the warning and went into Rājagaha with monastics from the city's 18 monasteries.

At the sight of the tusker elephant Nālāgiri, the people fled in terror. Ven. Ananda, on seeing the elephant advancing towards the Buddha, went in spite of the Buddha's orders to the contrary: he stood in front of the Buddha, who had to make use of his supernatural power to move him.

Just then a woman carrying a child saw the elephant coming and fled. In her terror she dropped the child at the Buddha's feet. As the elephant was about to attack the child, the Buddha spoke to him, suffusing him with loving kindness and, stretching out his right hand, he stroked the animal's forehead.

Thrilled with joy at the touch, Nālāgiri sank on his knees before the Buddha, and the Buddha taught him the Dharma.
 
Taming Nalagiri (ariyamagga.net)
It is said that had the elephant not been a wild beast, he would have become a stream enterer. Marveling at the sight, the assembled people threw all of their ornaments on the elephant's body covering it. And henceforth the elephant was known as Dhanapāla (Dhanapālaka).

The Buddha returned to Bamboo Grove and later that day recounted the Cullahamsa Rebirth Tale (Jātaka) in praise of Ananda's loyalty (Vin.ii.194f.: J.v.333ff.; Avedānas i. 177). 
 
Nalagiri (huntingtonarchive.osu.edu)
It is said (Mil. 349) that 900 hundred million living beings who witnessed the miracle realized the truth.
 
The Bodhisattva [the Buddha before enlightenment] in a past life was once riding an elephant when he saw a non-teaching buddha. Intoxicated by his own glory, he made the elephant charge at him. It was as a result of this action (karma) that the Buddha, in this rebirth, was charged by Nālāgiri (UdA.265; Ap.i.300). Compare at Donamukha.