Showing posts with label Catechism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Catechism. Show all posts

Sunday, April 2, 2023

Pope dividing Catholic Church? Palm Sunday

Why won't Pope Francis meet with Dalai Lama if Pope John Paul II did? China no likey.

Pope Francis celebrates Palm Sunday mass day after leaving hospital
Caesar's Messiah: Invent Jesus
(Guardian News) Palm Sunday, April 2, 2023. Pope Francis has celebrated Palm Sunday mass in Saint Peter’s Square a day after leaving hospital where he was treated for severe [Covid-like lung infections and] bronchitis.

The pope, 86, arrived in the square, in which more than 30,000 people had gathered, onboard the popemobile (as shown below).

Who does this gay-priest loving guy think He is?
The armored vehicle stopped by the ancient Egyptian obelisk in the center of the Catholic square for the pontiff’s blessing of the palms before transporting him to the altar. He opened the mass with "a weak and slightly breathless voice" [a common Covid symptom], Italian media reported.
A pope worse than Nazi (Ratzinger) Benedict and people-pleaser John Paul?

Pope Francis is dividing the Church. Here's why.
In case God won't protect him, Secret Police does
(Breaking in the Habit) Catholic apologist Young Friar Tuck (Casey Cole OFM) explains: One major criticism of Pope Francis is that he has created confusion in the Church. Here are four reasons people find him confusing and what we can do about it.
  • 0:00 Intro
  • 1:05 Poor catechesis (not enough catechism)
  • 3:15 Different style
  • 5:45 Morality isn’t black and white
  • 8:57 His enemies
  • Newsletter
  • Facebook

"This Jesus Must Die" (Jesus Christ Superstar)
(Mollie Elyse) Feb. 9, 2023 "This Jesus Must Die" from the play and movie Jesus Christ Superstar, written by Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice. Featuring Mollie Elyse (Priest #3) and other members of Enter Stage Left on Smule.

Wednesday, April 3, 2019

Buddhists go for GUIDANCE not "refuge"

Col. Henry Steel Olcott, Wijesinha Mudaliyar; Dhr. Seven, Ashley Wells, Wisdom Quarterly


Going for "Refuge"?
QUESTION: What are the "Three Guides" a Buddhist goes to?

ANSWER: They are disclosed in a formula called Ti-saraṇa* (the "Three Guides"), which is, in fact, "Buddhism" (the Buddha's Dharma):
  1. I follow the Buddha as my Guide (Buddham saranam gacchami).
  2. I follow the Dharma as my Guide (Dhammam saranam gacchami).
  3. I follow the Sangha as my Guide (Sangham saranam gacchami).
Guidance not "refuge"
Sâranam: Mr. Wijesinha Mudaliyar writes Col. Olcott: This word [sarana] has hitherto been very inappropriately and erroneously rendered "refuge" by European Pali language scholars, and thoughtlessly so accepted by native Asian Pali scholars.

Neither Pali etymology nor Buddhistic philosophy justifies this translation. 'Refuge,' in the sense of a fleeing back or a place of shelter, is quite foreign to true [original] Buddhism, which insists on all people working out their own emancipation.

The root sṛ in Sanskrit (sara in Pali) means to move, to go, so that saranam would denote a moving, or one or that which goes, before or with another — a Guide or Helper.

I construe the passage thus:
  • Gacchāmi: I go
  • Buddham: to the Buddha
  • Sâranam: as my guide.
The Awakened One (Buddha), the Path to Awakening (Dharma), the Awakened (Sangha)
.
The translation of the Ti-saraṇa as the "Three Refuges" has given rise to much misapprehension, and has been made by anti-Buddhists a fertile pretext for taunting Buddhists with the absurdity of taking "refuge" in non-entities and believing in un-realities.

The term refuge is more applicable to nirvaṇa, of which sâranam is a synonym.
 
Ven. Sumangala [a senior Buddhist monk of long standing] also calls my attention to the fact that the Pali root sara has the secondary meaning of killing, or that which destroys. 

Buddham sâranam gacchâmi might thus be rendered:
 
"I go to the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Sangha, as the destroyers [allayers] of my fears —
  1. the first by his teaching
  2. the second by its universal truth
  3. the third [the monastic order and, more importantly the noble community of enlightened individuals, many of whom are not monastics] by their various examples and precepts."

Q: What does [a Buddhist] mean when repeating this formula?

A: Buddhists mean that they regard the Buddha as an all-wise teacher, spiritual friend, and exemplar.

The Dharma, or "Doctrine," is the Teaching that contains the essential and immutable principles of justice and truth and the Path that leads to the realization of perfect peace of mind in this very life.

The Sangha, or Community, are living examples and teachers of the excellent Dharma taught by Buddha.

Q: But are not some of the members of this "Monastic Order" intellectually and morally inferior men?

A: Yes. But we are taught by the Buddha that only those who diligently attend to the precepts, discipline their hearts/minds, and strive to attain or have attained one of the eight stages of enlightenment and perfection constitute the Buddhist "community."
  • [The Four Stages of Enlightenment are divided into four paths and four fruits. This is explained in The Path of Purification commentarial system as only a thought-moment apart from one another. Alternatively, there is sutra evidence that the eight stages refer to those on the path (to stream-entry, once-returning, non-returning, and arhatship) and those who have consummated each of these paths.]
It is expressly stated that the Order [Sangha] referred to in the "Tisaraṇa" refers to the "Attha Ariya Puggala" — the Eight Noble Ones who have attained one of the eight stages of enlightenment.

The mere wearing of yellow robes, or even monastic ordination, does not of itself make a person pure, wise, or entitled to reverence.
 

Q: Then it is not such unworthy [Buddhist monastics, ascetics, recluses] as they, whom the true Buddhist, would take as their guides?
 
A: Certainly not.

Saturday, September 10, 2011

Going for Guidance to the Three Gems

Wisdom Quarterly edit of "Three Jewels" (en.wikipedia.org)
Buddhist nuns, monks, and lay followers all go for guidance to the Three Jewels.

The Three Jewels, also the Triple Gem, is the center of one of the major practices of mindfulness, recollection, contemplation, and reflection in Buddhism. The qualities of the three are frequently repeated in the ancient texts, where they are called the "Mirror of the Dhamma" (Dhamma Adassa). I go for guidance to the Buddha, the Greatest in the world, the Guru of devas and human beings, who gained enlightenment to teach freedom from suffering to beings. The Cambodian (Khmer) formulation, in Theravada Buddhist tradition, runs as follows.

ចង្អុលឲ្យដើរផ្លូវកណ្តាល មាគ៌ាត្រកាលអាចកំចាត់​ ទុក្ខភ័យចង្រៃអោយខ្ចាយបាត់ អាចកាត់សង្សារទុក្ខបាន។​
Guiding the right Middle Path, the way that can eliminate all suffering.
២.សាសនាព្រះអង្គនៅសព្វថ្ងៃ សត្វមាននិស្ស័យពីបុរាណ​ ប្រឹងរៀនប្រឹងស្តាប់ចេះចាំបាន កាន់តាមលំអានបានក្តីសុខ។
Such teachings now beings have through karmic-destiny accrued in the past by trying to listen, learn, and practice for happiness.
ឥតមានសុខណាស្មើក្តីស្ងប់ បញ្ចប់ត្រឹមសុខឃ្លាតចាកទុក្ខ​ តាំងពីលោកនេះតទៅមុខ ក្តីសុខនឹងមានព្រោះធម៌ស្ងប់។​
There is no happiness as genuine as one free of all suffering from this world and beyond, where happiness prevails because of Dharma.
៣.ខ្ញុំសូមបង្គំឆ្ពោះព្រះធម៌ ព្រះសង្ឃបវរទាំងសព្វគ្រប់ រួមជាត្រៃរ័ត្នគួរគោរព ជាម្លប់ត្រជាក់នៃលោកា
I go for guidance to the Dharma and the Sangha, all combined as the Three Jewels, the cool shade of the world.
ព្រះរូបព្រះធាតុនៃព្រះពុទ្ធ វិសុទ្ធតាងអង្គព្រះសាស្តា​ សូមគុណត្រៃរត័្នជួយខេមរា ឲ្យបានសុខាតរៀងទៅ ៕
May the Triple Gem guide [this country and its people] to happiness forever.

The Mirror of the Dharma
This contemplative practice (anussati) -- often replacing formal sitting meditation -- refers to reflecting on the true qualities of the teacher, teaching, and the taught -- the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha.

These qualities are called the "Mirror of the Dharma" in the Discourse on the Buddha's Last Days. They help practitioners attain a "mind like a mirror" -- a possible reference to the "mind-door" (mind-door cognitive processes) near the physical heart that reflect the contents of consciousness.

In the commentary on the Crossing the Wilderness Rebirth-Tale, the Buddha declares:

Disciples, nowhere between the lowest of the hells below or the highest heavens above, nowhere in all the countless worlds that stretch to the right and left is there the equal, much less one superior, to a buddha. Incalculable is the excellence that springs from keeping the precepts and from other virtuous conduct.
By taking refuge in the Triple Gem, one escapes from rebirth in unfortunate states of suffering. By forsaking such guidance as this, one hase certainly erred. In the past, too, humans who foolishly mistook what was no guide for a true guide met with disaster.

Amaravati Three Gems (triratna) symbols

The Buddha
"The Blessed One is an arhat, perfectly enlightened, accomplished in true knowledge and conduct, fortunate, knower of the world, unsurpassed leader of persons to be tamed, teacher of devas and humans, the Enlightened One, the Blessed One."

In early traditions the Buddha as a worthy guide is taken to refer to the historical Buddha. Later traditions expanded this to include buddhahood or "the full development of mind." In other words, the full development of one's highest potential came to mean our intrinsic buddha nature or ability to reach buddhahood, full enlightenment.

This later interpretation recognizes the possibility of completion, perfection, full development of one's own inherent qualities. Mind in Buddhism does not mean the head; it means the heart. They are one and the same, both involved in consciousness. So the metaphorical head/heart allows for the full development of wisdom and compassion in equal measure.

The Dharma
"The Dharma is well expounded by the Blessed One, directly visible, immediate [timeless], inviting one to come and see, applicable, to be personally experienced by the wise."

Going for guidance to the Dharma, in the Vajrayana tradition, includes reference not only to the words of the Buddha, but to the living experience of realization and the teachings of fully realized practitioners.

In Tibetan Buddhism, it includes both the Kangyur (the teaching of the Buddha) and the Tengyur (the commentaries written by realized practitioners). In an intangible way, it may also include the living "transmission" of those masters, which can be very inspiring.

The Sangha
"The Sangha of the Blessed One's disciples is practicing the good way, practicing the straight way, practicing the true way, practicing the proper way; that is, the four pairs of persons, the eight types of individuals: This Sangha of the Blessed One's disciples is worthy of gifts [a statement which makes it certain that we are not talking about just anyone with a shaved head wearing a saffron robe but instead those ], worthy of hospitality, worthy of offerings, worthy of reverential salutation, the unsurpassed field of merit for the world." (Bhikkhu Bodhi, 2000, The Collected Discourses of the Buddha: A New Translation of the Samyutta Nikaya, Somerville: Wisdom Publications, p. 319–321).

A more liberal definition of "Sangha" may include all practitioners actively following the Buddha's teachings to benefit themselves and others. But it is more strictly defined as the "Realized Sangha" (Arya-Sangha). In other words, it really means those practitioners and historical students of the Buddha who realized the true nature of mind.

The ordinary Sangha means practitioners and students of the Buddha who are using the same methods and working towards the goal of enlightenment and benefiting others by making the Dharma known that brings about the end of suffering (here and now and in the ultimate sense of their own attainment).

Tibetan Buddhism

Threejewels.svg

In Tibetan Buddhism there are three guidance formulations: the Outer, Inner, and Secret forms of the Three Jewels.

The outer form is the "Triple Gem" (Sanskrit, Triratna). The inner is the Three Roots. And the secret form is the "Three Bodies" (trikaya of a buddha). These alternative guide formulations are employed by those undertaking Deity Yoga and other tantric practices in the Vajrayana tradition as a means of recognizing Buddha Nature.

History

The Three Gems are so called because of their treasured value to Buddhists, as well as their indestructible and unchanging nature.

The Three Gems when used in the process of going for guidance become the Three Guides. In this form, metaphors occur very frequently in ancient Pali texts (of Theravada Buddhism). Sangha always really means those persons (ordained or not) who have reached at least the first stage of enlightenment, which is very hard to know about others. So for practical purposes most use the term to refer to the Sangha of Buddhist monks and Buddhist nuns.

I go to the Buddha for guidance and to the Dharma and to the Sangha.

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Numerical Dharmas (doctrinal lists)

U Maung (Nibbana.com)

Lists are integral to the enormous body of Buddhist Teachings (Dharma)

Buddhism was originally memorized and recited verbatim without being written down. To facilitate this oral tradition, many "lists" were developed. They are compact statements that are then unfolded and expounded on. Of course, for some it became dogmatic: there are this many; this is what the Buddha taught; this is the only right view, and all other views are wrong. In fact, the lists are flexible and only a device. The Buddha himself listed sets of things in different ways according to what he was emphasizing.

For example, in one sutra (Satipatthana) the Four Noble Truths are left out, and in another version they are included (Mahasatipatthana). No one doubts that these central teachings are crucial. But according to circumstances they are not mentioned in one context yet mentioned in another. The Noble Eightfold Path can easily be expanded to ten without changing anything but the way things are labelled. (This happens with the Ten Precepts becoming Eight Precepts by reshuffling; see sikkhapada).

All of this is taken to the extreme in lists and lists of Buddhist lists. The point is not to become attached to lists or to the belief that there's something magical in the number of things enumerated. Any list is simply a handy way of teaching and remembering the Dharma, which is a vast body of information. With that in mind, here are some traditional formulations:

UNIQUE

There is only one unique situation where suffering (dukkha) is eliminated. It is nirvana, which is without geographical location. It is there that the four primary elements find no footing whatsoever.

TWOFOLD

  • Two chief male disciples: Thera Sariputta and Thera Moggallana
  • Two chief female disciples: Theri Khema and Theri Uppalavanna
  • Two seven-year-old arhats (enlightened ones) were the novices (samaneras) Sumana and Pandita (Dhammapada V. 382 & V.80)
  • Two kinds of happiness (sukha) are bodily (kaya) and mental (citta).
  • Two foremost teachers are mother and father.
  • Two kinds of personality-view (sakkaya-ditthi) are (1) taking delight in individuality (sakkaya-bhirata) and (2) striving towards cessation of mental and material phenomena (nirvana- bhirata).
  • Two kinds of individuals (bhirata) with distorted perception are those who hold either to eternalism (sassata) or annihilationism (uccheda).
  • Two persons whom one can never pay back the debt of gratitude in full are mother and father who raised one.
  • Two principles guarding the world (lokapala dhamma) are conscience (hiri) about harming and dread (ottapa) of consequences about doing harm.

THREEFOLD

  • Tipitaka (Three Baskets) of Buddhism: Discourses (sutras), Disciplinary Code (Vinaya), and Higher Teachings (Abhidharma)
  • Three kinds of bodhisattva (those destined to become a buddha): (1) Intellectual, those fulfilling the Ten Perfections (parami) for four incalculable periods (asankheyyas) and 1,000 aeons (pannadhika-bodhisatta); (2) Devotional, fufilling the perfections with conviction (saddha) for eight incalculable periods and 100,000 aeons (saddhadhika-bodhisatta; (3) Energetic, fulfilling the perfections with endeavour predominating for 16 incalculable periods 100,000 aeons (viriyadhika-bodhisatta).
  • Three kinds of Dispensation (sasana): (1) learning the Buddha's Teaching (Pariyatti Sasana); (2) practical application of the Buddha's Teaching (Patipatti Sasana); (3) the realization of the Buddha's Teaching (i.e., attainment of jhanas, paths, fruitions, and nirvana (Pativedha Sasana).
  • Three types of Essence: generosity (dana), virtue (sila), and insight (vipassana).
  • Three characteristic marks or signs inherent in all sentient existence: impermanence (anicca), unsatisfactoriness (dukkha), and impersonal [uncontrollable] nature (anatta) of things.
  • Three kinds of attachment to existence (raga): in the sensuous sphere; in the fine-material sphere, and in the immaterial sphere.
  • Three categories of monastics: Elders (thera), those who have spent ten or more years in the Order; those of middle standing (majjhima), who have been in the Order from five to nine years; newly ordained ones (nava), who have been in the Order for less than five years.
  • Three kinds of craving (tanha): attachment to sense pleasures (kama-tanha); attachment to continued existence (bhava-tanha); attachment to views that karma entails neither rebirth nor future existence (vibhava-tanha).
  • Three Disasters (kappas): by famine, weapons, or epidemic.
  • Three Worlds (lokas): conditioned world (sankhara-loka), corporeal world (satta-loka), inanimate world (okasa-loka).
  • Three Supermundane Dharmas: paths (magga) and fruitions (phala) [entering the path to the four stages of enlightenment -- stream-winning, once-returning, non-returning, and arhatship -- and attaining each stage]; nirvana (nibbana) [the ninth supermundane Dharma or Ultimate Truth as distinct from mundane states of consciousness].
  • Three kinds of Training (sikkha): in virtue or morality (sila), concentration or collectedness (samadhi), wisdom or understanding (panna).

FOURFOLD

  • Four Netherworlds (apayas): the realms of intense continuous suffering (hells, niraya); animal realms (tiracchana); hungry ghost realms (peta); realm of miserable beings (asurakaya).
  • Four Analytical Insights (patisambhidas): insight into the true meaning and consequence of things (atthapati-sambhida); insight into the nature of the Dharma (dhamma-patisambhida); insight into the meaning, grammar, and syntax of the language (nirutti-patisambhida); insight into the nature of these three knowledges (patibhana-patisambhida).
  • Four Intoxicants (stains, cankers, corruptions, or asavas): (1) attachment to sensual pleasures (kamasava); (2) attachment to material and immaterial meditative states and their corresponding states of existence (bhavasava); (3) holding [62 kinds of] false views (ditthasava); (4) ignorance with regard to the Four Noble Truths, past and future lives, and the Law of Dependent Orignation (avijjasava).
  • Four Attributes of Nirvana: it is expounded by a fully enlightened buddha (sammasambuddha desitam); free of sorrow (asokam), free of corruptions (virajam); peaceful (khemam).
  • Four Sublime Abidings (Brahma Viharas): loving kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy, equanimity. More>>

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

Going for Refuge? (Sarana)


The Awakened One (Buddha), Path to Awakening (Dharma), the Awakened (Sangha)

"Going for Refuge?"
Henry Steel Olcott

QUESTION: What are the "Three Guides" (Note) a Buddhist goes to?

ANSWER: They are disclosed in a formula called Ti-saraṇa* (the "Three Guides"), which is, in fact, "Buddhism" (the Buddha-Dharma):
  1. I follow the Buddha as my Guide (Buddham saranam gacchami).
  2. I follow the Dharma as my Guide (Dhammam saranam gacchami).
  3. I follow the Sangha as my Guide (Sangham saranam gacchami).

*Sâranam. Wijesinha Mudaliyar writes me: "This word [sarana] has been hitherto very inappropriately and erroneously rendered Refuge, by European Pâlî scholars, and thoughtlessly so accepted by native Pâlî scholars.

Neither Pâlî etymology nor Buddhistic philosophy justifies the translation. Refuge, in the sense of a fleeing back or a place of shelter, is quite foreign to true Buddhism, which insists on every man working out his own emancipation. The root Sṛ in Sanskrit (Sara in Pâlî) means to move, to go; so that Saranam would denote a moving, or he or that which goes, before or with another — a Guide or Helper.

I construe the passage thus:

  • Gacchāmi, I go,
  • Buddham, to Buddha,
  • Sâranam, as my Guide.

The translation of the Tisaraṇa as the "Three Refuges," has given rise to much misapprehension, and has been made by anti-Buddhists a fertile pretext for taunting Buddhists with the absurdity of taking refuge in nonentities and believing in unrealities.

The term Refuge is more applicable to Nirvâṇa, of which Sâranam is a synonym.

The [Elder] Sumangala also calls my attention to the fact that the Pâlî root Sara has the secondary meaning of killing, or that which destroys. Buddham sâranam gacchâmi might thus be rendered:

"I go to Buddha, the [Dharma], and the Order, as the destroyers of my fears —
  1. the first by his preaching
  2. the second by its axiomatic truth
  3. the third by their various examples and precepts."

Q: What does [a Buddhist] mean when repeating this formula?

A: He means that he regards the Buddha as his all-wise Teacher, Friend, and Exemplar; the [Dharma], or Doctrine, as containing the essential and immutable principles of Justice and Truth and the path that leads to the realization of perfect peace of mind on earth; and the Order [Sangha] as the teachers and exemplars of that excellent [Dharma] taught by Buddha.

Q: But are not some of the members of this "Order" men intellectually and morally inferior?

A: Yes; but we are taught by the Buddha that only those who diligently attend to the Precepts, discipline their minds, and strive to attain or have attained one of the eight stages of holiness and perfection [Four Stages of Enlightenment divided into paths and fruits, which is explained in the Path of Purification commentarial system as only a thought-moment apart from one another; alternatively, there is sutra evidence that the eight refers to those on the path (to stream-entry, once-returning, non-returning, and arhatship) and those who have consummated their meditative attainment)], constitute his "Order."

It is expressly stated that the Order [Sangha] referred to in the "Tisaraṇa" refers to the "Attha Ariya Puggala" — the Noble Ones who have attained one of the eight stages of perfection. The mere wearing of yellow robes, or even ordination, does not of itself make a man pure, wise, or entitled to reverence.



Q: Then it is not such unworthy bhikkhus (Buddhist monks, ascetics, recluses) as they, whom the true Buddhist would take as his guides?

A: Certainly not.