Bodhidharma gave the same answer to two opposing lifestyles | Zen Wisdom
I should draw Zen cartoons on my altar
(ECHOES OF LOST KNOWLEDGE) Can a butcher become a buddha? Can someone who lives with sensual desire, worldly attachments, and harmful habits still attain enlightenment?
In the Bloodstream Sermon, traditionally attributed to the First Patriarch of Zen Buddhism Bodhidharma, we encounter a remarkable answer:
Whether the question concerns a married man or a butcher who kills and slaughters animals, Bodhidharma appears to point toward the same essential truth: seeing our own nature is what matters [and what is more important].
But does this mean that enlightenment makes someone free from karma? Can realizing Buddha Nature place a person beyond the consequences of their actions? And can spiritual awakening ever become an excuse for avoiding moral responsibility?
In this exploration of Bodhidharma's teachings, we examine one of the most challenging passages in the Bloodstream Sermon and investigate the relationship between Buddha Nature, karma, desire (craving), and moral responsibility.
MESSAGE: This Japanese scroll calligraphy drawing of Bodhidharma reads, "Zen points directly to the human heart, see into your nature and become Buddha." It was created by Hakuin Ekaku (1686-1769).
We also explore the famous story of Baizhang and the wild fox from The Gateless Barrier, where a single mistaken answer about cause and effect leads to 50 ["many"] lifetimes of suffering.
Through these two Zen teachings, we examine a crucial distinction: freedom from attachment does not necessarily mean freedom from cause and effect.
[EDITORIAL NOTE: The Buddha and the noble ones, even the fully enlightened disciples, all still face the results (vipaka) of their previous deeds (karma). An fully awakened being (arhat, be that person a buddha or an enlightened disciple] no longer generates karma. So such a person's new intentional actions are called kriya ("simple actions") not karma. These being, called the "noble ones," are no longer subject karma except for residual karma. This is called "nirvana with remainder." With the passing away of an arhat, there is "nirvana without remainder." In that sense, one has escaped all further karma and all the consequences that might have come had one stayed in samsara.]
Perhaps seeing our true nature does not mean escaping responsibility. Perhaps it means finally becoming willing to see our actions without hiding behind the image of who we believe ourselves to be.
Buddha Nature and the relationship between desire and awakening
Does enlightenment free us from karma?
The difference between liberation and moral irresponsibility
Baizhang's story of the wild fox and cause and effect
Zen Buddhism, non-attachment, and personal responsibility
KEY TEACHING
The person who sees does not need to deny cause and effect [karma].
True understanding should not become an excuse to avoid looking at what our actions have done.
If we are interested in Zen Buddhism, Bodhidharma, Buddha Nature, Buddhist philosophy, karma, and the deeper meaning of enlightenment, this exploration invites us to look beyond conventional spiritual assumptions.
#Bodhidharma #ZenBuddhism #BuddhaNature
(Ambrose Discovery and 5 more) Nov. 5, 2026:
High in the Himalayas, a Buddhist monk near Mt. Everest drinks melted ice and sits for hours in the snow, and he is only the start.
This video follows some of the strangest monks on record, from the nomad boy recognized as the 17th Karmapa to a 1,000-year-old master found inside a Buddha statue, a Mongolian monk still sitting in the lotus position, and the naturally mummified monk of Gue in the Spiti Valley.
See what scientists actually measured about tummo inner heat practice and how a jawbone picked up by a monk in a Tibetan cave connects these mountains to people who lived there through the last Ice Age.
Kathina is a major Buddhist festival that comes at the end of the Rains Retreat or Vassa, the annual three-month rainy season retreat for Theravada Buddhists in Buddhist countries, such as:
America (USA)
Bangladesh (where it is known as Kaṭhina Cībar Dān)
The season during which a Buddhist monastery may hold Kathina is a month long, beginning after the full moon of the eleventh month in the lunar calendar (usually October).
Kathina is a time of giving and for lay Buddhists to express gratitude to Buddhist monastics (bhikkhus and bhikkhunis) [3, 4].
Lay Buddhists bring donations to temples, especially new robes for monastics. The gift of the Eight Requisites [5] (aṭṭha parikkhārā or Atapirikara in Sri Lanka) is also part of the offerings [1, 3, 4].
As the legend goes, 30 monks were once journeying with the intention of spending the Rains Retreat with the Buddha [1]. However, the seasonal heavy rains began before they reached their destination.
They had to stop at Saketa (the ancient name for the holy city of Ayodhya, India [1, 7], site of intense Diwali celebrations).
According to the Buddha's rules and guidelines for observance of the Rains Retreat, mendicant monastics should refrain from travel during the rainy season because by walking and wandering they may unintentionally harm crops and insects during their journeys [8]. That is why the 30 monks had to stop [1, 7].
. They passed their time together without conflict, practicing Dhamma (Teachings). Therefore, afterwards, the Buddha rewarded them by demonstrating a way to practice sharing and generosity (dana).
A lay Buddhist disciple had previously donated pieces of cloth to the Buddha, so the Buddha gave those pieces of cloth to the group of monastics and told them to make stitch them into a patchwork robe and offer it as a gift to one among them.
The frame, called a kathina, was used to hold the pieces of cloth to stitch into a robe [1, 7]. The Buddha informed lay disciples that the offering of this kind of robe, following the intensive practice of monastics for the previous season, results in the highest merits for them.
[Presumably, this would be because of the greater likelihood that one or more practicing monastics will have attained distinction in meditation, either the absorptions or the stages of enlightenment, and things given to such people are immensely and exponentially more meritorious for the giver to provide.]
The Kathina (kaṭina, from the Sanskrit krsta) is the greatest opportunity for giving throughout the Buddhist calendar year. As for the monastics, they determine who practiced with the most vigilantly and assiduously and the robe is awarded to the practitioner. More
The Gnostic (direct experiential knowledge) tradition existed before the "official" church, which came to prominence by saying the real teachings of personal purification of view were "heresy." Fortunately, the sacred texts the priestly class attempted to outlaw and burn survived in very rare cases, such as the Nag Hammadi library, Dead Sea Scrolls, and sporadic recovered lost gospels. These gospels do not differ from the official versions we all know, they precede them. Our sanitized versions are the ones that differ from the true word of the great rabbi Issa, Isa, Y'shua, Yeshua, Ioesus, Joshua ben Yusef ("Josh, Son of Joe")...
Free copies of Grand Theft Auto VI for Californians?
What to know about Kick sweepstakes
The horror, the horror, Ariana is so skinny now!
The most anticipated video game of all time comes out in a week, and if consumers haven’t already pre-ordered it –– or don’t want to fork over $100 for the Ultimate Edition –– there’s a chance to snag it for FREE.
That’s because live-streaming platform Kick is giving away thousands of copies of Grand Theft Auto VI all throughout California.
Oh, ship! This is going to be overboard epic.
Kick (kick.com) said in a press release Thursday (Nov. 12) that it unveiled a “giant, truck-sized version” of one of their loot cases – which are special, timed events where viewers can earn digital rewards, in-game perks, or sweepstakes entries, such as the GTA VI one, which is called the Sunset Reward Case.
Who would be dumb enough to pay?
Loot cases are always virtual –– but not this time around.
All that’s required to enter the GTA VI sweepstakes is to scan the QR code on the truck if a consumer can catch it:
It will be traversing the streets of Los Angeles, driven by a woman cosplaying at GTA VI’s protagonist Lucia (Lucia Caminos | Fandom), before “exploring wider California” ahead of the release of the latest installment of the popular video game series. More:
I [Krodha] was asked to be his personal chauffeur. His Holiness expressed a desire to meet with the Hopi Indiansin Arizona. We set about making the necessary arrangements even renting a brand new, gold colored Cadillac as the official vehicle for the journey.
We finally left for Arizona trailed by a caravan of cars containing His Holiness's retinue of attendant monks and lamas, a Tibetan translator named Achi, and around 25 American Buddhist practitioners from Karma Dzong [now called the Boulder Shambhala Center] in Boulder. Transfixed by the presence of his Holiness, I did my best to drive mindfully.
Early in the afternoon of the following day, we arrived at a place called Second Mesa, a high plateau on the Hopi Reservation [Nation]. It looked like an old chocolate cake. I nosed the Cadillac onto the dirt road that spiraled up around it, and we slowly made our way to the top.
Even though it was October, the temperature was well over 100 degrees. The place looked dusty, desolate, and poor.
Is this Great Chief finally returning to us?
A man who looked to be about 80 years old, wearing a plaid shirt, jeans, and tennis shoes approached and greeted His Holiness. His name, he said, was Chief Ned. There was a sweet, loving, and gentle air about him.
Through Achi the translator, His Holiness asked: "How goes it? How are things with your people?"
"Not too good," replied Chief Ned. "We haven't had rain in 73 days."
His Holiness listened with an expression of deep compassion on his face.
"I will do something for you," he said.
Then Chief Ned invited us to go down with him into a kiva [ceremonial room] to see some sacred relics. There was a small hole at the top of it with a rickety ladder poking out. When he motioned for us to go down it, His Holiness politely declined.
He [the Karmapa] was a rather large and portly man, and there was no way he could possibly fit through that hole.
He asked that the rest of us go down while he remained up above. Down in the cool darkness, Chief Ned showed us an eagle feather and other sacred relics. When we climbed back up into the sunlight, His Holiness abruptly ended the visit.
"Let's go," he said, and that was that. We got into the cars and headed back down the dusty road and out across the desert to the Hopi Cultural Center and Motel, where we were scheduled to spend the night.
As we drove, His Holiness, sitting right across from me in the passenger seat, began chanting a puja and making sacred mudra gestures with his hands.
The desert baked and shimmered in the intense heat. I looked out at the sky and noticed a tiny, sheeplike, fleecy little ball of a cloud, all by itself way out there on the horizon. I didn't give it much thought.
I kept on driving, and the Karmapa kept on chanting, and 10 or 15 minutes went by like that before I glanced up again.
Much to my surprise, little puffballs of cloud now polka-dotted the sky from horizon to horizon. The next time I looked, the clouds had congealed into a solid gray mass. This was getting interesting. By the time we reached the Hopi Cultural Center and Motel, the sky had darkened to an ominous and foreboding black not just black, but a classic Cecil-B-DeMille-Moses-and-the-Ten-Commandments black!
We rolled into the motel parking lot. One of the attendants opened the door for His Holiness. He got out and walked to his motel room where another attendant stood ready to open the door. I watched his back as he disappeared into the room.
At the very instant that the door clicked shut behind him, there was an eruption of thunder and lightning like I've never seen before in my life. Crash! Boom! The most dramatic display you could imagine! And then the rain started coming down hard. Buckets of it. Sheets and torrents of it. It went on and on like that, splashing down on the roof of the Cadillac with the power and intensity of a waterfall.
By that evening, word had gotten out to all the surrounding villages that this "Indian King" had made rain.
Pretty soon a crowd had gathered around the motel. In every [Indian] face there was a look of awe and wonder towards his Holiness, who at the moment was conducting an Avalokiteshvara(compassion) empowerment for the assembled crowd.
We Western practitioners felt very much like outsiders at this event. The amazing facial resemblancebetweenthe Tibetans and the Hopi suggested an ancient bond between the two peoples. To me, it felt like a reunion. (m.youtube.com)
(mykhathasnotail) • 11y ago. I'm assuming this is about the 16th Karmapa?
(krodha) • 11y ago. Yeah, 16th Karmapa.
1 more reply [deleted] • 11y ago. WOW!
What parallels are to be seen?
What parallels do you see with Native American [shamanistic, animistic, pantheistic] spiritual teachings and Buddhist teachings?
QUESTION: I'm fascinated by the history, culture, and spirituality of the Indigenous people of the America, which is a continent not a country. I've always been somewhat interested, but that interest has always taken a back seat to Buddhism and Vedanta[Vedic Hinduism], the culture of my ancestors.
One very easy answer to this derives from the fact that when Tibetan Buddhist teachers first arrived in the USA and California, the first place they went was the Southwest (Arizona, New Mexico, etc.) and immediately had a deep sense of recognition. Wisdom Quarterly has covered this extensively. They did not recognize in one another superficial or coincidental similarities. From the time of the ancient lost civilization in the Grand Canyon uncovered by Kincaid and re-hidden by the Smithsonian, those points of similarity were direct remnants. Buddhism arrived in California/Mexico long before Christianity.
What contact did the Native Americans ever have with ancient Buddhism?
(ringer54673
• 2015) I don't know if all Native American beliefs are the same. [Of course, they are not, but they can be said to have threads of similarity running through them, like shamanism, animism, and pantheism running through them.] But there is a huge contradiction between [at least] one and Buddhism. The Buddha did not teach [ultimate] "oneness" or [Hindu] non-duality.
What did the historical Buddha teach?
What the Buddha Taught
Indeed, the Buddha did not teach Advaita Vedanta the way the Vedas, ancient Brahmins, modern Hindus, and subsequently Brahmanism-influenced Mahayana Buddhists teach and emphasize or take for granted that he must have. It's true that we are all interrelated and interdependent; we are "One" in that sense and in other ways, all connected, all going through much of the same thing, at risk in the same way and in need of each other's compassion and tolerance.
More important than this question of what it feels like when the ego-sense drops away and we feel connected to everyone and everything, the Buddha taught something far more important and more shocking to the Brahmin priests' way of viewing reality, the universe, and the Vedas, something can still not begin to accept or come around to seeing for themselves.
The Buddha dared to suggest that -- ultimately speaking -- there is NO SELF (not "soul," not atman, atta, personality, ego, essence behind things), that phenomena is in fact impersonal and that the real source of problems in life (samsara) is ignorance, not the lack of merging the Atman (specific consciousness) with the Brahman (universal consciousness), the Drop with the Ocean, the Ray of light with the Source of light, the Illusion of separation with the Reality behind all illusions, as modern Hindus might conceive of ancient Vedic (pre-Hindu) teachings.
The Buddha dared to go one step beyond that to SHOW how things are impersonal and that this is the key to moksha, spiritual liberation. But to a world that is hardly willing to let go of the sensual and material and recognize a supersensual and spiritual, what use is there talking about such highfalutin things?
The Buddha did not teach "beliefs"; he taught a path-of-practice to direct knowing-and-seeing of reality.
When you yourself know-and-see, it will not matter who said what, who taught what, who claimed what. You will not be dependent on a teacher or text for knowledge because like the ancient Gnostics, you will come to know it directly for yourself and be liberated of the need for any teacher or -ism. This is the great promise of Buddhism, which in translation the Dharma Editor for Wisdom Quarterly Dhr. Seven renders "Awakenism" (budh-ism).
The Four Ennobling (Enlightening) Truth, the Ennobling Eightfold Path, the 37 Requisites of Enlightenment, whatever this "-ism" is conceived or summarized as being, it is not the veneration of the historical Teacher, Teaching, and Taught, the Three Jewels of Buddha, Dhamma, and Sangha. It is the personal recognition of buddhahood (as arhantship, pacceka-buddhahood, or samma-sam-buddhahood), self-realization, knowing-and-seeing beyond all doubt for oneself in this very life.
Of course, nowhere does the historical Buddha tell anyone to pursue supreme buddhahood in private (pacceka) or as a teacher (sammasam), as those taught to pursue the bodhisattva ideal are taught to believe, disparaging what the historical Buddha actually taught, which was for all humans and devas to practice for the realization of arhantship (awakening as a disciple of a supremely enlightened teacher).
The Path he rediscovered (as all buddhas before him did and after will) is what the Buddha taught, not a "religion," not words to repeat in faith and "try" to believe in.
Of course, people treat the Dharma, this Doctrine, as suits them best at this stage of their growth and understanding. And in this sphere of existence (called the kama-loka or "sensual sphere"), that will be the easiest or come as the most natural entrance. That can be very helpful. But one cannot remain there and think that the work, the kammatthana, is done. For just as a child naturally outgrows dependence on a good parent, so we as "hearers," as devoted (dayakas) disciples (savakas) of this path-of-practice will one day grow to the point of personal realization.
Only then will we have done as the Buddha bid his listeners to do for 45 years of his dispensation (sasana) up until his last sentence to human beings, perhaps still having a little more to say to the devas of some of the 31 Planes of Existence as he ascended and descended through the meditative absorptions or jhanas as his last act before final quenching, parinibbana (Sanskrit parinirvana), "final nirvana" without remainder, completely free of rebirth and all remaining traces of suffering whatsoever. What was his last admonition, echoing what he had been saying daily for the previous 45 years?
The Buddha therefore taught his disciples: "Go, meditators, and seek secluded [quiet, peaceful, undisturbed] places. Be steadfast and resolute there. This is the way to have constant audience with the Tathagata (the Buddha, the Wayfarer). There is no need to come here to gather around the Tathagata. That is not the way. But rather, whoever has mindfulness and is diligent in all postures of the body [lying down, sitting up, standing, moving] immediately gives reverence and has audience with the Tathagata. Nonchalantly [carelessly, mindlessly, inattentively] sitting around is not the way to meet, nor to see, nor to have audience with the Tathagata. The Tathagata does not regard coming here and going away as having an audience with or taking leave of the Tathagata. The Tathagata considers diligence of the practice to eradicate defilements from the heart (mind), whether little or much, as steadily gaining audience with the Tathagata."
Black Elk: The first peace, which is the most important, is that which comes within the souls of people when they realize their relationship, their oneness, with the universe and all its powers, and when they realize that at the center of the universe dwells Wakan-Tanka, and that this center is really everywhere. It is within each of us. ncu9nc.blogspot.com/2015/03/realizing-ultimate
Dhamma and Non-duality by Bhikkhu Bodhi
Rev. MLK Jr. and Thich Nhat Hanh (aka Thay)
"The teaching of the Buddha as found in the Pali canon does not endorse a philosophy ofnon-dualism of any variety, nor, I would add, can a non-dualistic perspective be found lying implicit within the Buddha's discourses." accesstoinsight.org/lib/authors/bodhi/bps-essay_27
Zen Buddhist and Vietnam Era peace activist Ven. Thich Nhat Hanh sure seems to advocate for the Hindu-Mahayana Buddhist position by positing an "interbeing" philosophy
Perfect Interpenetration: Thay, the prominent Vietnamese Zen Buddhist teacher, coined the term "interbeing" (French Interêtre, Vietnamese Tiếp Hiện) to explain Buddhist interpenetration metaphysics to modern people and help them develop some insight into the Mahyana Buddhist/Brahminical/Hindu view of reality [53, 54]. Though he was deeply versed in the complex doctrines of Huayan and Yogacara, his presentation of "interbeing" is noted for elegant simplicity that focuses on natural explanations and ethics [55], relying on stories and simple metaphors to convey the notion that all things exist in a state of interconnected being, a state of being [or becoming, bhava] interwoven and mutually dependent [53]. In his book Understanding Our Mind, he cites the apocryphal Mahayana Avatamsaka Sutra and the teachings of Huayan Master Fazang as the sources for his teaching of interbeing. More
(krodha)
•
11y ago. Dhamma and Non-duality by Bhikkhu Bodhi. "The teaching of the Buddha as found in the Pali canon does not endorse a philosophy of non-dualism of any variety, nor, I would add, can a non-dualistic perspective be found lying implicit within the Buddha's discourses."
Bhikkhu Bodhi is incorrect. Śākyamuni's teaching on the meaning of "non-dual" in Buddhism is found in the Kaccayanagotta Sutta.
(mad_bad_dangerous) •
11y ago. I believe interdependence and oneness are the same teaching.
Story of HH Gyalwa Karmapa, Oct. 1974 (moved to top)
[deleted]
•
11y ago. Not directly answering your question, but just pointing you to something that you may be interested since you are asking this question. Robert and Rachel Olds are a couple who studied both with Tibetan Buddhist lamas and Native American teachers. They have written about their own experiences, which you may find interesting. They have also written about Buddhism, but it may be important to recognize that they are not Buddhist teachers themselves.
(numbersev) •
11y ago. The differences outweigh any similarities. Most similarities exist because we are bound within the same world and its properties such as impermanence, emptiness, and causation. Also keep in mind that native traditions are fragmented and can believe many different things where as Buddhism can be traced back to one buddha of our time with one set of teachings, following one ancient tradition that all buddhas teach.
Now I am at a stage in life where I am synthesizing all my interests and beliefs into a singular way of life.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perennial_philosophy
All materials on this site are submitted by editors and readers. All images, unless otherwise noted, were taken from the Internet and are assumed to be in the public domain.
In the event that there is still a problem, issue, or error with copyrighted material, the break of the copyright is unintentional and noncommercial, and the material will be removed immediately upon presented proof.
Contact us by submitting a comment marked "private."
Do not follow this journal if you are under vinaya or parental restrictions. Secure protection by Sucuri.
Wisdom Quarterly: American Buddhist Journal is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 United States License. Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at creativecommons.org/about/licenses.