Sunday, November 15, 2026

Is playing GTA VI bad karma? (Pt. 2)


CONTINUED FROM PART 1
I can't wait to kill 'em all on GTA VI
There are three kinds of karma (actions). One is physical, the other verbal, the third mental. One may think a thought (form an intention in mind) then speak it (create a verbalization) then do it (carry it out). If one did, that is THREE acts, three DEEDS, not one even if they are all related. We may think one thing, say another, and do a third or exhibit integrity by aligning them.

For instance, we sincerely promise to do something and then we do it. The sincerity is mental, the pledge is verbal, and the carrying it out is physical. They are integrated, and this is called having integrity. Often, however, we say we'll do something, without really meaning it, and then we may or may not do it. The point is, they are three different things, three distinct kinds of karma, three ACTS.

The mental act is the one that concerns us here. If karma takes three forms (by way of vehicle, body, tongue, or brain), it is qualitatively different but nevertheless effective in producing some kind of results (one act, many results).
  • Could how we roleplay impact how we live outside the game? D'uh. It seems obvious it would, but is there scientific data?*
I prefer the term Sofa Spud to Couch Potato
If one feels guilty about so much as thinking of doing harm, for example, that is a kind of mental resultant. If one is joyful over thinking of doing something wonderful and helpful, that is also a mental resultant.

When the fruits of that action ripen, when those seeds we planted sprout, those results will be experienced as welcome, neutral, or unwelcome depending on the act. Any act can also be distinguished by the motivation underlying it.

So let's say I play pretend killing mofos for 23 hours straight, a new household record because I love GTA VI so much, what kind of intentions have I been forming, rehearsing, exercising for those hours? Skillful, neutral, or unskillful? Wholesome, neutral, or unwholesome? Good, neutral, or bad?

The idea or argument that because it is "just" a thought it has no result is wrong. To prove that, let us look at the Buddha's own words in this short sutra:

Before killing, what acts are warriors already doing?
We wish to ask a question of the Blessed One.
(SN 42.3) The village headman Yodhajiva (the "Warrior") went to the Buddha (the Blessed One), paid his respects, sat to one side, and asked:

"Venerable sir, I have heard it passed down through the ancient teaching lineage of warriors that, 'When a warrior strives and exerts himself in battle, if others strike him down and slay him while he is striving and exerting himself, with the breakup of the body, after death, he will be reborn in the [good] company of the devas who were slain in battle.' What does the Blessed One say about this?"

"Enough, headman, set that aside and do not ask."

But a second time and a third time, the headman Yodhajiva asked.

"Apparently, headman, I am unable to get past you by saying, 'Enough, headman, set that aside and do not ask,' so I will answer it directly.

What did you say, man? I'll F you up right now.
"When a warrior strives and exerts himself in battle, HIS MIND IS ALREADY SEIZED, debased, and misdirected by the thought, 'May these beings be slaughtered, struck down, destroyed, annihilated, and may they cease to exist.'

"If others strike that warrior down and slay him while he is thus engaged in striving and exerting himself, with the breakup of the body, after death, he will be reborn in a hell called the realm of those slain in battle.

This simulation is mentally real yet not corporeal
"Moreover, if he holds a view such as, 'When a warrior strives and exerts himself in battle, if others strike him down and slay him while he is thus striving and exerting himself, with the breakup of the body, after death, he will be reborn in the company of the devas slain in battle,' that is his WRONG VIEW.

"Now, there are two destinations for a person holding such a wrong view, I say, either a hell or the animal world.'

I was lied to and fooled.
When this was said, the headman Yodhajiva began to sob then burst into tears.

The Buddha then said, "That is what I could not get past you by saying, 'Enough, headman, set that aside and do not ask.'"

"Venerable sir, I am not crying because of what the Blessed One said, but rather because I have been deceived, misled, and fooled for so long by that ancient teaching lineage of warriors." — SN 42.3
The Workings of Kamma (Pa Auk)
Given that this person is striving, exerting, and mentally hunting down enemies, behaving like a would-be killer, gangster, or trained soldier already mentally engaged in violence, BUT has not yet killed anyone, what's the harm?

The Buddha points to that mental harm: The warrior's mind (heart, citta-stream) is ALREADY seized, debased, and misdirected.

The person need not do anything else yet bad karma (unskillful, unwholesome deeds) will have already accrued. The seeds with the capacity to produce results in the future will have already been planted. The gamer need not go any further (with speech or bodily action) to have already made karma.

What kind of karma was made? There are six kinds: wholesome, neutral, or unwholesome (mundane or supermundane). All of this so far is mundane. What makes a deed good or bad?


ALL bad deeds have only three roots. The same is true for all good deeds. Those unwholesome roots are greed, hatred (which includes fear), and delusion. If one thinks, speaks, or does (acts) motivated by one or more of these roots, the outcome is bad (unskillful) karma. It is called "bad" karma because it will produce, when it ripens, unwelcomed, unwished for results.

Karma is NOT punishment but like-for-like
It would be "good" karma if it were rooted in nongreed (letting go, giving, unselfishness, releasing, contentment, charity, sharing, providing), nonhatred (loving kindness, compassion, sympathy, equanimity, help), and/or nondelusion (right view, wisdom, insight, understanding).

What is one nourishing while playing Grand Theft Auto VI? It must be goodwill, kindness, love, affection, sympathy... Who knows who's playing that game. When we get in the hotseat and start shooting, we as gamers are exercising the worst qualities: grand theft, mass murder, rape, psychotic violence, endangering others, and so on.

If only psychology had something to say

  • You watched what, you pervert? - It was a study!
    *When I was a graduate student in psychology at UCLA, I remember a very powerful piece of information passed down to us by our famous psychology professor. At the time, all the way down to today, it was being disputed whether or not WATCHING PORN was harmful. (Is watching online porn unskillful or "bad" karma?)
The experimental results had been inconclusive. Expose subject to violent pornography, see what happens. In all their early measures, they were the same. This would suggest, "No harm, no foul, watch as much violent porn as you want." The sex industry was overjoyed to hear it. Even science can't find any harm in watching "adult" content. Except there was one measure, and it was very suggestive.

If I were a good scientist, I would have the references at hand to back this up. But it's not necessary because many researchers followed suit, so whoever did it first hardly matters. This was a robust finding. (Smithers! Get my professor on the line to ask her for the citation ASAP.)
The design of the psychological study
Jerry, Kramer says GTA VI is coming out. Can you ask Elaine if we can watch porn at her place?
.
Elaine, will you be in our study?
What researchers did was a two-part experiment. Part 1, expose subjects to hardcore violent pornography. Part 2, have them engage in a "learning" trial. This trial consisted of a female "learner" engaged in some task or other. When observed doing the task correctly, press the green button held in the subject's hand. When observed doing the task incorrectly, press the red button to electrocute (as in the Stanley Milgram and Solomon Asch experiments) or "help teach" the learner to do it correctly.
  • SHOCKING: The Milgram experiments at Yale and Asch experiments were a series a shocking electrocution experiments in social psychology in the early 1950s and 1960s to test people's willingness to shock, punish, or even kill others if instructed by an authority figure or the majority of a group. CONCLUSION: Ordinary people will shock, punish, even kill someone if an authority figure tells them they should or to conform to a group (americasbestpics.com).
You want me to shock? (americasbestpics.com)
Experimental subjects gave the learner just as many "shocks" as those not exposed to violent pornography. BUT, unconsciously, they held the red shock button longer. They held it down for a statistically significant greater length of time = more electrocution, more shocking, more pain administration.

Shocking experiments at Yale U
When asked afterward, "Do you think you were fair in praise and blame (green button, red button administration) of the learner?" They all reported, "Yes, I was quite fair and objective." This is what most if not all of them must have thought.

However, the data revealed what they seemed to be unaware of but what researchers could clearly see: Those not exposed to violent pornography administered punishments in this proportion. Those exposed to violent pornography administered punishments disproportionately -- the same number of shocks but unconsciously held down longer.
  • Now imagine this study but exposing subjects to 15 minutes of first-person shooter roleplaying GTA 5 (to say nothing of the new better, brighter, more densely pixelated magic of GTA 6) then running the Part 2.
None of this is said so that someone will have the ammunition to say, "Porn is bad, don't watch it" or "filthy videogames are mental garbage, don't play them."
  • This is only said for the personal, private realization: "Might I be behaving differently in the real world because of what I do in the virtual one as I spend my free time immersed in a very engaging (dopamine producing) fantasy as a first-person shooter engaged in role play for hours and hours, days and days, years and years?
It's something to think about because, suddenly, we're outside the scope of this Buddhist article. All that is being said here is that some kind of mental karma is being generated by just playing a game. Now we see there is scientifically validated data and evidence that how and what we play negatively impacts how we live real life. Yikes! Who knew?

What does the state religion say about it?
  • Why get religious? By chance I was having a conversation with my very devoutly Christian mother. So I asked her:
God wants you in Rome's Army
"Mom, does that guy Jesus ever talk about distinguishing SIN into physical, verbal, and merely mental?"

Asked in this way, she suddenly kicked into action with many examples. We all know sowing what we will later reap (what the Buddha and the East call "karma") is a physical act. That's easy to imagine. Can it be just verbal? Lying and uttering other harmful words is easy to realize can be sinful, can be missing the mark of how to behave in this world. But what about just thinking stuff? Apparently, in the way of Jesus' teaching, that can be a "sin," too.

It's almost as if cultivating and harboring universal love and sisterhood for all our fellow human beings would be meritorious all on its own (the way it is in the Buddha's Teaching).

I'm already guilty in my heart, Mags
It is almost, one could believe, as if Jesus Christ Born to Humans (aka a "Son of Man") had heard the Buddha's teachings from five centuries earlier.

Most people playing GTA VI, I would hazard to guess, are going to be nominal Christians. So even if they didn't believe a word any teaching on "karma," they might nevertheless remember how the Good Shepherd taught about SIN (missing the mark) and how long before it becomes an action, say adultery just to pull one out of the hats of so many sins, one by looking upon a female in that way (nudge-nudge, wink-wink) has ALREADY committed adultery in his or her heart (Matthew 5:28). Just saying. Ask Jesus or his Dad about it when you see them. ⛪

It's "adultery" just to look, but videgoame murder and theft, why would Jesus be against that?
  •  CONTINUED IN PART 3

Nature of Consciousness (Alan Watts)

Ye Gods: Hinduism to Atheism (NPR)



Atheist to Skeptical Believer
Ye Gods! Nov. 11, 2026: Christopher Beha author of Why I Am Not an Atheist: The Confessions of a Skeptical Believer joins Ye Gods' Scott Carter to discuss his journey from cradle Catholic to atheist and back.


Om, symbol of the Sanatan (Eternal) Dharma
He tells Carter why his brother’s recovery from a life-threatening accident paradoxically pushed him away from religion. Plus, how finding love and family brought him back from the depths of despair.

Christopher Beha is the former editor of Harper’s Magazine and the author of four previous books, including The Index of Self-Destructive Acts, which was nominated for the 2020 National Book Award.

Pete Yorn: Would you change your life to pursue your passion?
‘Ye Gods with Scott Carter’ (WGCU/NPR) explores belief, doubt, and the rules that shape us
.
American JewBu (E. Sigalow)
The week of Nov. 4, 2026, on Ye Gods: Singer-songwriter Pete Yorn celebrates the 25th anniversary of his album Music for the Morning After and the spiritual journey that informed his latest album All the Beauty.

He and Carter talk about his spiritual journey from rediscovering Judaism to practicing Buddhism, maturing as an artist, and why his daughter is such an influence on his music. Plus, how Yorn went from a law student in New Jersey to pursuing music in Los Angeles.
  • Pete Yorn (Alchetron, Free Social Encyclopedia)
  • Jews and Buddhism
    Ye Gods: Scott Carter's Journey from Comedy to Spiritual Exploration Rev. Paul Brandeis Raushenbush and Scott Carter explore intersections of belief, doubt, and the moral codes in The Power of Intentional Curiosity: a transformative journey following a near-death experience and an epiphany that led to a profound commitment to engage openly with discussions about religion and spirituality without sarcasm or dismissal. His intentional curiosity opened doors to understanding diverse beliefs and perspectives, showing that being open-hearted can lead to deeper connections and insights.
ABOUT: Ye Gods with Scott Carter from WGCU (npr.org): Host Scott Carter, an award-winning executive producer and writer, known for his work on Real Time with Bill Maher and Politically Incorrect with Bill Maher, explores codes of religious, cultural, and secular conduct. Among Carter's diverse celebrity guests are Martin Short, Bob Costas, Ken Burns, Patricia Heaton, Killer Mike, Buddhist Sam Harris, Rabbi Sharon Brous, Larry Wilmore, Moon Zappa, Rainn Wilson, Yvonne Orji, Rabbi Steve Leder, and Tim Gunn: Ye Gods With Scott Carter: NPR

Ajahn Chah (read by Ajahn Jayasaro)


What did Ajahn Chah actually teach?

Friday, November 13, 2026

The Zen wisdom of Bodhidharma


Bodhidharma gave the same answer to two opposing lifestyles | Zen Wisdom
I should draw Zen cartoons on my altar
(ECHOES OF LOST KNOWLEDGE) Can a butcher become a buddha? Can someone who lives with sensual desire, worldly attachments, and harmful habits still attain enlightenment?

In the Bloodstream Sermon, traditionally attributed to the First Patriarch of Zen Buddhism Bodhidharma, we encounter a remarkable answer:

"I only talk about seeing your nature."

Bodhidharma's message
Whether the question concerns a married man or a butcher who kills and slaughters animals, Bodhidharma appears to point toward the same essential truth: seeing our own nature is what matters [and what is more important].

But does this mean that enlightenment makes someone free from karma? Can realizing Buddha Nature place a person beyond the consequences of their actions? And can spiritual awakening ever become an excuse for avoiding moral responsibility?

In this exploration of Bodhidharma's teachings, we examine one of the most challenging passages in the Bloodstream Sermon and investigate the relationship between Buddha Nature, karma, desire (craving), and moral responsibility.
  • MESSAGE: This Japanese scroll calligraphy drawing of Bodhidharma reads, "Zen points directly to the human heart, see into your nature and become Buddha." It was created by Hakuin Ekaku (1686-1769).
The Gateless Gate: Zen Koans
We also explore the famous story of Baizhang and the wild fox from The Gateless Barrier, where a single mistaken answer about cause and effect leads to 50 ["many"] lifetimes of suffering.

Through these two Zen teachings, we examine a crucial distinction: freedom from attachment does not necessarily mean freedom from cause and effect.
  • [EDITORIAL NOTE: The Buddha and the noble ones, even the fully enlightened disciples, all still face the results (vipaka) of their previous deeds (karma). An fully awakened being (arhat, be that person a buddha or an enlightened disciple] no longer generates karma. So such a person's new intentional actions are called kriya ("simple actions") not karma. These being, called the "noble ones," are no longer subject karma except for residual karma. This is called "nirvana with remainder." With the passing away of an arhat, there is "nirvana without remainder." In that sense, one has escaped all further karma and all the consequences that might have come had one stayed in samsara.]
Perhaps seeing our true nature does not mean escaping responsibility. Perhaps it means finally becoming willing to see our actions without hiding behind the image of who we believe ourselves to be.

IN THIS VIDEO
Bodhidharma (Himeji-jo)
  • Bodhidharma's teaching on seeing our own nature
  • The Bloodstream Sermon and its meaning
  • Can a butcher attain enlightenment?
  • Buddha Nature and the relationship between desire and awakening
  • Does enlightenment free us from karma?
  • The difference between liberation and moral irresponsibility
  • Baizhang's story of the wild fox and cause and effect Zen Buddhism, non-attachment, and personal responsibility
KEY TEACHING
The person who sees does not need to deny cause and effect [karma]. True understanding should not become an excuse to avoid looking at what our actions have done.

If we are interested in Zen Buddhism, Bodhidharma, Buddha Nature, Buddhist philosophy, karma, and the deeper meaning of enlightenment, this exploration invites us to look beyond conventional spiritual assumptions. #Bodhidharma #ZenBuddhism #BuddhaNature

Strange Buddhist monks found


Strange Buddhist monks discovered in the Himalayas — and they've been living since the last Ice Age
Tummo yoga practice
(Ambrose Discovery and 5 more) Nov. 5, 2026: High in the Himalayas, a Buddhist monk near Mt. Everest drinks melted ice and sits for hours in the snow, and he is only the start.

This video follows some of the strangest monks on record, from the nomad boy recognized as the 17th Karmapa to a 1,000-year-old master found inside a Buddha statue, a Mongolian monk still sitting in the lotus position, and the naturally mummified monk of Gue in the Spiti Valley.

See what scientists actually measured about tummo inner heat practice and how a jawbone picked up by a monk in a Tibetan cave connects these mountains to people who lived there through the last Ice Age.

#Monks #Himalayas #Tibet #Buddhism #IceAge #Mummy strange monks, Himalayan monks, monks living since the ice age, Tibetan monks, Rongbuk Monastery, tummo meditation, inner heat meditation, 17th Karmapa, Ogyen Trinley Dorje, Liuquan mummy, Buddha statue mummy, self-mummification, Luang Pho Daeng, Mongolian mummy monk, Tukdam, Sangha Tenzin, Gue mummy, Bodhidharma, Milarepa, Xu Yun, Denisovan jawbone, EPAS1 gene, Tibetan plateau, Ice Age, mysterious monks documentary

Kathina Ceremony, NoHo (Nov. 13-14)

Sri Lankan devotees offer prayers in kathina puja, Mahabodhi Temple – Bodhgaya, India
.
North Hollywood, LA ceremony
Sarathchandra Buddhist Center | NoHo, Los Angeles, CA

Kathina is a major Buddhist festival that comes at the end of the Rains Retreat or Vassa, the annual three-month rainy season retreat for Theravada Buddhists in Buddhist countries, such as:
  • America (USA)
  • Bangladesh (where it is known as Kaṭhina Cībar Dān)
  • Burma (Myanmar)
  • Cambodia (Khmer)
  • India
  • Laos
  • Malaysia
  • Singapore
  • Sri Lanka (Ceylon)
  • Thailand (Siam)
  • Vietnam [1, 2].
Lunar calendar shows 13 full moons a year
The season during which a Buddhist monastery may hold Kathina is a month long, beginning after the full moon of the eleventh month in the lunar calendar (usually October).

Kathina is a time of giving and for lay Buddhists to express gratitude to Buddhist monastics (bhikkhus and bhikkhunis) [3, 4].

Lay Buddhists bring donations to temples, especially new robes for monastics. The gift of the Eight Requisites [5] (aṭṭha parikkhārā or Atapirikara in Sri Lanka) is also part of the offerings [1, 3, 4].
Why, what is it?

Theravada Buddhist College
As the legend goes, 30 monks were once journeying with the intention of spending the Rains Retreat with the Buddha [1]. However, the seasonal heavy rains began before they reached their destination.

They had to stop at Saketa (the ancient name for the holy city of Ayodhya, India [1, 7], site of intense Diwali celebrations).

According to the Buddha's rules and guidelines for observance of the Rains Retreat, mendicant monastics should refrain from travel during the rainy season because by walking and wandering they may unintentionally harm crops and insects during their journeys [8]. That is why the 30 monks had to stop [1, 7].

Karma: Why do good people suffer? A Buddhist view on fortune, misfortune, and injustice
.
They passed their time together without conflict, practicing Dhamma (Teachings). Therefore, afterwards, the Buddha rewarded them by demonstrating a way to practice sharing and generosity (dana).

A lay Buddhist disciple had previously donated pieces of cloth to the Buddha, so the Buddha gave those pieces of cloth to the group of monastics and told them to make stitch them into a patchwork robe and offer it as a gift to one among them.

The frame, called a kathina, was used to hold the pieces of cloth to stitch into a robe [1, 7]. The Buddha informed lay disciples that the offering of this kind of robe, following the intensive practice of monastics for the previous season, results in the highest merits for them.
  • [Presumably, this would be because of the greater likelihood that one or more practicing monastics will have attained distinction in meditation, either the absorptions or the stages of enlightenment, and things given to such people are immensely and exponentially more meritorious for the giver to provide.]
The Kathina (kaṭina, from the Sanskrit krsta) is the greatest opportunity for giving throughout the Buddhist calendar year. As for the monastics, they determine who practiced with the most vigilantly and assiduously and the robe is awarded to the practitioner. More

What Jesus taught was not religion


Thursday, November 12, 2026

FREE Grand Theft Auto VI for Californians


Free copies of Grand Theft Auto VI for Californians?
What to know about Kick sweepstakes

The horror, the horror, Ariana is so skinny now!
The most anticipated video game of all time comes out in a week, and if consumers haven’t already pre-ordered it –– or don’t want to fork over $100 for the Ultimate Edition –– there’s a chance to snag it for FREE.

That’s because live-streaming platform Kick is giving away thousands of copies of Grand Theft Auto VI all throughout California.

Oh, ship! This is going to be overboard epic.
Kick (kick.com) said in a press release Thursday (Nov. 12) that it unveiled a “giant, truck-sized version” of one of their loot cases – which are special, timed events where viewers can earn digital rewards, in-game perks, or sweepstakes entries, such as the GTA VI one, which is called the Sunset Reward Case.

Who would be dumb enough to pay?
Loot cases are always virtual –– but not this time around. All that’s required to enter the GTA VI sweepstakes is to scan the QR code on the truck if a consumer can catch it:

It will be traversing the streets of Los Angeles, driven by a woman cosplaying at GTA VI’s protagonist Lucia (Lucia Caminos | Fandom), before “exploring wider California” ahead of the release of the latest installment of the popular video game series. More: