Thursday, November 19, 2026

Drums, Drums, and more Drums (sutra)


The Buddha taught three things. One might say he taught only two things. We ourselves say he taught only one thing. But the three things he taught are divided into three distinct "collections": discourses (sutra), monastic discipline (vinaya), and higher-doctrine (abhidhamma or the "Dharma in ultimate terms"). He himself said, he only teaches two things, suffering and the end of suffering, that is dukkha and the end of all suffering (nirvana). We think this amounts to only one thing, the practice for the realization of nirvana (magga).

Who are the 20 best rock drummers?

For this reason, the whole of Buddhism is sometimes encapsulated in the shorthand called the Four Ennobling Truths, that which by understanding (not memorizing, believing, repeating, or chanting) one would become enlightened ("ennobled," a "noble one," Aryan).

To this end, the Buddha gives an incredible amount to instruction to nuns and monks, the dedicated disciples putting personal practice at the head of their lives. But what about the rest of us, the vast majority of practitioners who are not monastics?


It is counterintuitive but true on close inspection that MOST people who have ever awakened (become enlightened, attained bodhi) since the time of the historical Buddha have lay practitioners, not monastics. This sounds impossible but it is speaking in total numbers and refers not to full enlightenment (arahantship) but to any of the stages preceding full enlightenment:
  • of which there are four main ones, seven detailed ones (because of there being three kinds of stream winners as detailed in The Path of Freedom), and two additional ones (the saddhānusārī and dhammānusārī, the "confidence devotee" and "wisdom devotee," who it is said will not pass away before gaining stream entry in this life. Goodness knows if this all true, there might be other gradients or permutations, strange details or what to make of the body-witness, vision-attainer, and so on?
Of course, the proportion of human individuals who realize the stages of enlightenment in this very life will be much higher among monastics, novices, and anagarikas (white clad renunciates). But in total numbers across the sutras, it's ordinary people and devas who approach a teacher of the Dhamma, who come to hear the Buddha or his accomplished elder disciples (theris and theras) who "gain the Eye of the Dhamma" (stream winning). So this leaves one burning question: What did the Buddha teach them?


Monastics have volumes of patimokkha ("path-to-moksha") literature called vinaya (the Monastic Disciplinary Rules, both for monks and separately for nuns, the Bhikkhu Vinaya and the Bhikkhuni Vinaya). What do we laypeople have? We have sutras, word of mouth teachers (like Pa Auk Sayadaw, Ajahn Chah, Beth Upton, Shaila Catherine, Nagasena, Madihe Pannaseeha Thero, Bhaddha Kaccana, Khema Theri, Uppalavanna Theri, Ayya Khema, Nagarjuna, Bodhidharma, Jack Kornfield, Joseph Goldstein, Dipa Ma, Sharon Salzberg, Sayalay Susila, Sayalay Dipankara, U Ba Khin, Thich Nhat Hanh, Dōgen, and many others), and retreats, plus a boatload of stored up good karma (merit) to hear the Dhamma in this life and have the circumstances and opportunity to put it into actual practice.

(William Wei) Best drummer ever [HD], proving one doesn't even need drums to play drums. Gordo Drummer lives in Sydney, Australia, or did circa 2013. Does he know he has 223,463,067+ views?

Drums, drums, we need MORE drums!
It doesn't work by magic. It works by application. And in the regard, there is a "Layperson's Vinaya" called the Sigalovada Sutta, the Buddha's Enlightened Advice to Young Sigala. In that lengthy discourse, which is clearly cobbled together into one amalgam from different related suttas, there is the mention of drums.

It is said in reference to the attraction we humans and devas wandering through the "Sphere of Sensuality" (kama-loka, the grouping of realms where craving for sex and other sense pleasures predominate, the lower heavenly planes, the human plane, the subhuman planes) have to partying. We love parties, we love to party, and we love the hedonistic distraction suggested by even hearing a party.
  • 10. "There are the six dangers inherent in habitual partying: One constantly seeks to know, 'Where's the dancing? Where's the singing? Where's the music? Where's the storytelling? Where's the applause? Where's the drumming?" Sigalovada Sutta (DN 31)
  • Why drums? In answer to that, I can only think of a show on Pacifica Free Speech Radio, Los Angeles (kpfk.org), maybe it was Rhapsody in Black . A commercial got played for it, asking the thought-provoking question that went something like, "Kids with their jazz and rock music, if you ask them why they like it so much, their answer is always the same: 'the beat, the beat, the beat'!" Drums are sensual, sensorial, basic, like a beating heart, often full of rhythm and umph, as being charge forward through samsara.

Sadly, to this end, whoever cobbled this sutra together over centuries of teaching laypeople didn't do a great job of it -- in that there are clearly pieces missing or added in later. Any scholar or careful reader will know this because the pattern is for the Buddha to explain something to the hearer (Sigala) then summarize it in verse before carrying onto the next subject. How could it be that things pop up in the summary that were never covered in the instruction phase?

"The Drum Discourse" (Ani Sutta)
A supremely awakened teacher (samma0sam0buddha) is extremely rare in the universe.

Historical drum with ropes and pegs
(SN 20.7) Thus have I heard. At one time the Buddha was staying in Savatthi, where he said: "Meditators, there was once a time when the Dasarahas had a large drum called the 'Summoner.'

"Whenever the Summoner was dull, the Dasarahas inserted another peg [under its straps], until the time came when the Summoner's original wooden shell had disappeared and only a mass of pegs remained.
  • [The Commentary to this sutra notes that the Summoner drum could originally be heard for 12 yojanas (leagues), but in its final condition could not be heard even from behind a curtain.]
  • [What is a drum? In ancient times, it was an elastic head held tight around a resonant base with a strap system and pegs placed under them to pull it tighter. A djembe is a rope-tuned, skin-covered goblet drum. According to the Bambara people in Mali, Africa, the name comes from the saying, Anke djé, anke bé, "everyone gather together in peace," defining the drum's purpose. Djé is the verb for "gather"; similarly, the drum here is the "Summoner." To apply more tension, wooden pegs are wedged between shell and lacing could be used to increase tension still further [55]. More
"In the same way, in the course of the future there will be meditators who no longer listen when sutras (discourses) that are words of the Tathagata [the Buddha, Wayfarer, Thus Come One, Well Gone One] — profound, full of depth of meaning, transcendent, regarding emptiness — are being recited. (CONTINUED BELOW)
  • What's the Heart Sutra, Avalokita?
    [The Heart Sutra, most famous discourse in Buddhism, is not the historical Buddha speaking nor is it even about the Buddha. It is about making the point that there are certain "perfections" (paramitas) to be mastered, one of which is wisdom (prajna). What is the mastery of wisdom? It is the culminating realization that ALL things are empty: Form (this body) is emptiness, and emptiness is form (meaning one implies the other, cannot not exist without the other, yin and yang, this and its opposite, front and back, up and down...). The Prajna Paramita is the "Perfection of Wisdom," a body of literature in at least 100,000 lines to bring one who studies it to this direct realization. But the "heart" sutra is the core, the culmination, the pith of that body of literature. Casual chanters, reciters, or students of it seem to think the mantra or the summary is the teaching, when in fact it is the culmination of all that literature. That's why it has confusing parts in it like the ayatanas, which no one who has not gone through the Buddha's ancient teachings in detail seems to understand. The eye, ear, nose and those exhaustive lists are mentioned, so it must be pointed out that each is without self (an identity for itself or an overall "self" of which each is a component). Because there are components (which are constantly changing, disappointing, and impersonal), there is no "self" no matter how the five heaps of factors cling to the illusion that there is a "self" there.]

We shall summon everyone with this beat!
"They will not lend ear, will not set their hearts on learning them, will not regard this Dhamma, these Teachings as worth grasping or mastering.

"However, they will listen when literary works, the works of poets — elegant in sound, elegant in rhetorical devices, the works of outsiders [non-Buddhists], words of disciples — are recited.

"They will lend ear and set their hearts on learning them. They will regard those teachings as worth grasping and mastering.

"In this way the sutras that are the words of the Tathagata [the historical Buddha] — profound, full of depth of meaning, transcendent, regarding emptiness — will disappear.

"Thus, train yourselves: 'We will listen when discourses that are words of the Tathagata — profound, full of depth of meaning, transcendent, regarding emptiness — are being recited.

"'We will lend ear, will set our hearts on learning them, will regard these Teachings as worth grasping and mastering.' Train yourselves thus."
What does the Buddha call "emptiness"?
Ven. Nyanatiloka, Buddhist Dictionary suñña entry edited by Dhr. Seven, Wisdom Quarterly

S
uññatā or shunyata (noun): "emptiness." In Theravada Buddhism, this is a reference to the doctrine of anattā ("not self"), the fact that all [psycho-physical] phenomena are impersonal [insubstantial, composite, without a core].

So it is said, suññam attena vā attaniyena vā. "Empty is the world...because the world is devoid of a self and anything belonging to a self" (S. XXXV, 85).

The enso or 'Zen zero' calligraphy
This is also said, in the same text, of the Five Aggregates clung to as SELF. Those five "heaps, groups, piles, or aggregations" (khandha) are the phenomena of which form [the four elements, the physical], feelings, perceptions, formations, and consciousnesses [four categories of mental formations, the psychological] are composed.

See also MN 43, MN 106. In the Cula Niddesa (CNidd), quoted in The Path of Purification (Vis.M. XXI, 55), it is said:

"Eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, mind, visual objects...mind-objects, visual consciousness...mind-consciousness, corporeality...consciousness, and so on are ALL empty (devoid) of a self and anything belonging to a self.

"They are devoid of permanence and of anything that is lasting, eternal, or immutable.

"They are coreless (insubstantial): without a core of permanence or core of fulfillment [satisfaction, lasting happiness, sukha], or a core of self."

In MN 121, the voiding (clearing) of the mind/heart of the taints [asavas, influxes, cankers, mental defilements], through the attainment of full enlightenment (complete awakening, arahantship), is regarded as the "fully purified and incomparably highest [concept of] emptiness.

See Sn.v.1119; MN 121; MN 122 (BPS.lk, Wheel 87); Pts.M. II: Suñña-kathā; The Path of Purification (Vis.M. XXI, 53ff.) Source

More words on "emptiness"
Here is a symbol of the all (enso)
In Mahayana Buddhism, there seems to be an added dimension to this "emptiness," which is also understood in Theravada Buddhism but not emphasized. That is the simple fact that ALL things are empty [not just impersonal but without fixed identity or suchness], not just the "self" (atta, atman, soul, ego). Why?

Everything we see around us is a composite, with no element being the thing itself. An aggregation of elements composes or comprises the thing. So there is no-thing there, just those constituent factors. But it goes even one step beyond in profundity: each of those elements is a "thing" (assemblage) composed of things (sub-elements).

So everything in the world is without an identity (a "true self," a "being-ness" the same from one moment to the next). But that this should be true of everything in the world is not that big of a deal, for what are we humans and devas most concerned with in all the universe?

We are concerned and often obsessed with ourselves, this "soul," "ego," "personality," this collection (aggregation) of form, feelings, perceptions, formations, and conscious experiences. So the historical Buddha emphasizes this general truth to the very specific truth of anatta of "no self."
  • One often hears Mahayana Buddhists, like their counterparts the Hindus and Brahmins and other theists, making the same mistake in understanding: It is said in Buddhism that there is no "separate" self. There is no independent self (soul, ego). This is very true, but what does it mean? It means that this "self" that seems to exist separately (from other selves) is utterly dependent for its seeming-existence on the factors of which it is composed. It is inseparable from the Five Aggregates clung to as self. Many foolishly, thoughtlessly (deceived by words and their common usage) say that this means "We are all one," that "no one is separate [from that One]," that there is no existing "separately" as if there is existing nonseparately. The problem? Yes, it's true, but it isn't what it sounds like. We the selves, the drops of ocean water, the beams of light scattering from One Great Source (presumably Brahminism's Brahman/GOD, the godhead, or Brahma Creator God, maybe even Buddhism's Maha Brahma or "Great Supremo" of anyone's choice in henotheism calling itself monotheism), have no separate existence apart from the constituent factors called "self." It is much easier to see with an impersonal example. This /, this \, and _ make this: triangle. It's still just those three lines, the rest being an illusion dependent on those lines.
I love Buddhism's Rumi, Bard, and other poets
Yes, there aren't things (compacts, unities) in this world of things (composites, assemblages), but what's worse -- what's far more counterintuitive -- is the fact that the "self" or "soul" (psyche) or "ego" that looks, or seems to look, out into the world is not itself real.

That is to say, it is NOT what it seems. What does it seem? It seems to us to be lasting, enduring, permanent. But from moment to moment, it is not that. It seems to us to be able to fulfill and satisfy us, to giving lasting satisfaction, comfort, happiness, but it can't. It seems to us to be personal, real (a thing in itself in a world of illusions where things for themselves are not themselves), a "soul" (eternal atman) in a fiery world that is burning up. It's all burning.

What did the Buddha know-and-see to awaken?
But in this world -- all this universe, multiverse, or multidimensional reality -- there is ONE element, one (for lack of a better English term) "thing" that is not a thing (composite), not subject to impermanence (or time at all), not disappointing by its very nature.

That element is what the Buddha and all the awakened and also the partially-enlightened beings (the noble ones) along the stages of full awakening called the "unconditioned element," the "deathless" (amata), the summum bonum of Buddhism: nirvana (nibbana). That is real, that is lasting, that is without constituents (unconditioned), unaffected by time and whether or not anyone realizes it.

The best drummer in the world today?
(El Estepario Siberiano) "Gangnam Style" by PSY | drum cover

This is bull, bullcr*p and a half! It's impossible and can't be done
  • Preserving the Buddha's Teachings | Gautama Buddha
  • El Estepario Siberiano, John Bonham, Nyango Star; Dhr. Seven (editing and translation), sutra based on Ven. Thanissaro (trans), definition of "emptiness" by Ven. Nyanatiloka (Buddhist Dictionary: Manual of Doctrines and Terms), Wisdom Quarterly

World Philosophy Day: Net of Views Sutra

Plato and Aristotle talk it out.
World Philosophy Day is an international day proclaimed by UNESCO to be celebrated every 3rd Thursday of November. It was first celebrated on Nov. 21, 2002.

By celebrating World Philosophy Day each year, UNESCO emphasizes the enduring value of philosophy for the development of human thought for each culture and for each individual.

UNESCO has always been closely linked to philosophy, not speculative or normative philosophy, but critical questioning which enables it to give meaning to life and action in an international context.

Irish Latino Che Guevara from County Cork
By establishing World Philosophy Day, UNESCO’s General Conference highlighted the importance of this discipline, especially for young people, underlining that "philosophy is a discipline that encourages critical and independent thought and is capable of working towards a better understanding of the world and promoting tolerance and peace."
UNESCO's General Conference was convinced that "the institutionalization of Philosophy Day at UNESCO as 'World Philosophy Day' would win recognition for and give strong impetus to philosophy and, in particular, to the teaching of philosophy in the world." More
The Buddha composed a comprehensive philosophical tome
I'm here to debate and defeat you because I'm a Brahmin. And you're nothing but a warrior!
.
Greek king asks Buddhist monks questions
The is a Buddhist sutra or discourse that somehow manages to cover ALL spiritual philosophies.

That would seem to be impossible, but ancient proto-India was rife with freethinkers questioning everything and devising doctrines and points of view to explain life, karma, fate, luck, truth, beauty, and most of all LIBERATION.

Buddhist genius Ven. Nagasena
Often seers (rishis) or scantily-clad philosophers (gymnosophists as the ancient Greeks referred to them) were hammering out theories by mere reasoning.

But other times they were being guided by post-samadhi transcendental visions, heavenly visitations from space, entheogenic drugs like ganja, gaining mystical powers (abhinnas, siddhis), remembrance of past lives, adherence to speculative views, or even adopting agnostic and uncertain positions.

This grand sutra is called The All-Embracing Net of Views or the Brahmajala Sutta:

The Net of All-Embracing Views

I'm going to found my own island and society
The Brahmajāla Sutta is the first of 34 discourses in a collection known as the "Long Discourses of the Buddha" (DN or Dīgha Nikāya), the first of the five nikāya, or "collections," in the "Collection of Discourses (Sutta Pitaka) of the Pali language canon.

The DN is one of the "Three Baskets" (Tipitaka) that compose the Pali canon of Theravada Buddhism.

The name means "Supreme" (Brahmā) "Raft" or "Net" (jāla), a conveyance made of inflatable bovine skins tied to a wooden platform used to ferry people from one shore to the other. This discourse is also called Attha-jala ("Raft of Essence"), Dhamma-jala ("Net of the Doctrines"), Ditthi-jala ("Net of Views"), and Anuttarasangama Vijaya ("Incomparable Victory in Battle").

No human being is an island unto oneself.
The discourse discusses two main topics, the elaboration of the "Lesser Precepts" (Cula-Sila) and the "Middle Precepts" (Majjhima-Sila). Cula-sila deals with the Ten Precepts practiced by Buddhists during intensive periods, while majjhima-sila gives a detailed description of the practice of the sixth, seventh, eighth, and ninth precepts, together with a further delineation of virtuous practices and abstentions.

The Supreme Net of Views

Know and see. Don't argue.
The second and third parts of the discourse discuss the 62 views or speculative beliefs (ditthis) that were clung to by ascetics at that time, just as many hold today by different names.

These are divided into 18 views or conclusions related to the past (pubbantanuditthino) and 44 beliefs or speculations about the future (aparantakappika).

Buddhist Publication Society
Many of these views are still relevant in the modern world and so the sutra provides Buddhist scholars with a great deal of information to ponder about the Buddha's own Dhamma or "Doctrine" (Teachings) as distinct from these other views. More
  • Bhikkhu Bodhi (1978). The Discourse on the All-Embracing Net of Views: The Brahmajala Sutta and its Commentarial Exegesis, Kandy, Sri Lanka, Buddhist Publication Society
  • Katz, Nathan (1981). Review: The Discourse on the All-Embracing Net of Views: The Brahmajāla Sutta and Its Commentarial Exegesis by Bhikkhu Bodhi (born Jeffrey Block), Journal of the American Academy of Religion 49 (3), 512–513 JSTOR 1462409 (subscription required)
  • Rhys Davids, T. W. & C. A., translators (1899–1921). Dialogues of the Buddha, Volume II, Pali Text Society, pp. 1–52
  • Sirkin, Alexander (1984). On the Beginning of the Sutta Pitaka (The Brahmajala Sutta).
  • In Shmuel Noah Eisenstadt, ed. Orthodoxy, Heterodoxy, and Dissent in India. Walter de Gruyter. pp. 57–71. ISBN 978-3-11-009659-0.
  • Dhr. Seven, Ashley Wells (eds.), Wisdom Quarterly Wiki edits

Finding the Epstein Files | Daily Show

We're supposed to believe wimpy actor Robert Pattinson as Agent 007? - James Bond?

The Beastie Boys to reunite?

Trump protects only one island: Epstein's
(Jimmy Kimmel Live) Country Music Awards, Trump makes saddest and most embarrassing plea yet, meets with Chinese Pres. Xi Jinping and Russian Pres. Vlad Putin and press secretary

'Buddha' plays Grand Theft Auto VI (Pt. 4)


The same is true for dosa, not intense "hatred" but the entire range of meaning under the rubric of "aversion." That, very importantly, includes fear (bhava), an expression of aversion. Whereas in English "hate" may mean the things we want to attack and wipe out, it is the same motive for what we fear, which are the things we want to turn away from, run from, and away from or put at a distance.


A mouse in the kitchen, for example, may provoke aversion that expresses itself, depending on the predominant tendency of the kitchen owner, a desire to kill the mouse or to jump on a chair until it goes away or to run away and leave the mouse far behind. We yell or we scream, motivated by the same aversion, but one moving toward to attack and the other moving us away from and disgusted.

Moha is the worst motive and the most prevalent, for it gives rise to the other two and gets us in so much trouble, life after life, aeon after aeon, if there were such things as past lives and aeons (kalpas). It means delusion, ignorance (avijja), nescience, wrong view (miccha-ditthi), confusion, not knowing or understanding, you know, that state of mind/heart we spend most of our time, the great "cloud of unknowing."


It is on account of not seeing things as they really are that we take them to be another way, often exactly the way they are not. We take the impermanent to be lasting, the disappointing to be our greatest hope of fulfillment and satisfaction, the impersonal to be "me, my-self, and mine." Because we think it (things, phenomena) is this way, not seeing it as it truly is, we want (crave) it.

How did the Buddha's brain get so serene?
We go for what fleeting, confused that it endures. We crave and go for it because we think it can finally fulfill us and complete us and satisfy our endless craving. We crave and go for it because we think it's real, that it is what it seems to be, not seeing its empty (shunyata) and impersonal (anatta) and, most crucially, its composite nature.

It is not what it seems (a whole, a compact, a thing in itself) because it is composed of parts. But we've strayed too far afield. We have already answered the first ("karma") and second word, the "mental."

Karma (deed, intentional action, what we send around) produces results (fruit, welcome and unwelcome consequences, a comeuppance). And that karma is of three kinds (bodily, verbal, or MENTAL). And that karma is of six kinds (motivated by greed, hatred, delusion, nongreed, nonhatred, or nondelusion), making it "good" or "bad."


In the mind PROCESS, as a mind moment enacts, there is a mental formation called intention (cetana) that determines the quality of that act. We lift a hand with a knife and bring it down. Are we killing a living being or freeing a fish from a line? It's the exact same physical action, and it is the MOTIVE or volition behind it -- what we intend -- that gives it its characteristic of being unskillful or skillful.

"Good" here means "producing pleasant, welcome, wished for results now and in the future when the deed comes to fruition, is ready to harvest." Harvest? There is that old saying, biblical and prebiblical, "You reap what you sow," which is to say, "we harvest what we plant." A bitter fruit, of course, will be bitter no matter how much we wish it were otherwise; similarly bad fruit from a bad seed we planted will be bad (tasting). That's just the way it is.

The Buddha didn't make it this way. He simply pointed out the connection of the natural world, explicating which actions should be avoided by someone wishing to avoid suffering (dukkha). Good will produce good whether we want it to or not.

"Bad" here means "producing unpleasant, unwelcome, unwished for results now and in the future when the deed comes to fruition, is ready to harvest." A sweet fruit, of course, will be sweet no matter how much we wish it were otherwise; similarly good fruit from a good seed we planted will be good (tasting).


That's just the way it is. There is no "Karma God" making it so. This is a natural functioning of the world, universe, samsara, this simulation or whatever it is we are currently in. The Buddha saw through it, made it known, was released to freedom and taught others to find release and be completely free.

ANSWER: What is the motive behind practicing grand theft auto (stealing or carjacking vehicles), murder, sexual misconduct, deception, and intoxication, all of which are available on a game console near you? If "karma" refers not only to our bodily doing (which is sitting around staring at a screen and operating the controls) but also the WILLING, INTENDING, WISHING, PRACTICING and so on involved in MENTAL DOING then, obviously, playing GTA VI or any similar first-person shooter game full of mayhem and the doing of things that if done in the tangible, visible, physical world would get us into endless trouble will be unskillful, harmful, bad karma.
  • If one says, "It's just a game," which means it's NOT in the reality of the mean streets of GTA Town, one is not considering that mental acts take place in the mind and move out into the social world, the consensus reality. Whatever deed (good or bad karma) the body or mouth does, it begins in the mind. That is MENTAL karma. Never mind what one is missing -- work, family, society, nutrition, or whatever -- in the "real" world while stealing cars in the "virtual reality" of the game. Ask Dr. Robert Lustig, MD about the hacking and hijacking of our American minds for how we got addicted to a mere game we can't stop playing, being affected by, or obsessing about.
Why? I didn't make reality. The Buddha didn't make reality. Thems is the rules of the game whether we want them to be or not. So if we play, the rules will apply to us whether we know them or not, whether it's (our definition of) fair or not. It is what it is, to put a mind-numbing tautology to good use.


WHY is it that way? One could answer very philosophically and penetratingly -- or one could go back and reread or pull out the Kalama Sutta if one needs motivation from the Buddha -- but it is perhaps best to bring this session of Wisdom Quarterly's Karma Class to a conclusion with the words of a famous rock 'n roll icon, "because it is that way."

Need the Buddha to explain it better? He does in an explanation of why being a soldier is such a BAD idea. One does not become a killer soldier at the moment of killing the first victim (enemy, other soldier, opponent) but begins racking up BAD karma long before that, EVEN if no one ever gets killed. This is a powerful example of bad mental karma.