Monday, November 16, 2026

Is playing GTA VI bad karma? (Pt. 2)


CONTINUED FROM PART 1
I can't wait to kill 'em all on GTA VI
There are three kinds of karma (actions). One is physical, the other verbal, the third mental. One may think a thought (form an intention in mind) then speak it (create a verbalization) then do it (carry it out). If one did, that is THREE acts, three DEEDS, not one even if they are all related. We may think one thing, say another, and do a third or exhibit integrity by aligning them.

For instance, we sincerely promise to do something and then we do it. The sincerity is mental, the pledge is verbal, and the carrying it out is physical. They are integrated, and this is called having integrity. Often, however, we say we'll do something, without really meaning it, and then we may or may not do it. The point is, they are three different things, three distinct kinds of karma, three ACTS.

The mental act is the one that concerns us here. If karma takes three forms (by way of vehicle, body, tongue, or brain), it is qualitatively different but nevertheless effective in producing some kind of results (one act, many results).
  • Could how we roleplay impact how we live outside the game? D'uh. It seems obvious it would, but is there scientific data?*
I prefer the term Sofa Spud to Couch Potato
If one feels guilty about so much as thinking of doing harm, for example, that is a kind of mental resultant. If one is joyful over thinking of doing something wonderful and helpful, that is also a mental resultant.

When the fruits of that action ripen, when those seeds we planted sprout, those results will be experienced as welcome, neutral, or unwelcome depending on the act. Any act can also be distinguished by the motivation underlying it.

So let's say I play pretend killing mofos for 23 hours straight, a new household record because I love GTA VI so much, what kind of intentions have I been forming, rehearsing, exercising for those hours? Skillful, neutral, or unskillful? Wholesome, neutral, or unwholesome? Good, neutral, or bad?

The idea or argument that because it is "just" a thought it has no result is wrong. To prove that, let us look at the Buddha's own words in this short sutra:

Before killing, what acts are warriors already doing?
We wish to ask a question of the Blessed One.
(SN 42.3) The village headman Yodhajiva (the "Warrior") went to the Buddha (the Blessed One), paid his respects, sat to one side, and asked:

"Venerable sir, I have heard it passed down through the ancient teaching lineage of warriors that, 'When a warrior strives and exerts himself in battle, if others strike him down and slay him while he is striving and exerting himself, with the breakup of the body, after death, he will be reborn in the [good] company of the devas who were slain in battle.' What does the Blessed One say about this?"

"Enough, headman, set that aside and do not ask."

But a second time and a third time, the headman Yodhajiva asked.

"Apparently, headman, I am unable to get past you by saying, 'Enough, headman, set that aside and do not ask,' so I will answer it bluntly.


What did you say, man? I'll F you up right now.
"When a warrior strives and exerts himself in battle, HIS MIND IS ALREADY SEIZED, debased, and misdirected by the thought, 'May these beings be slaughtered, struck down, destroyed, annihilated, and may they cease to exist.'

"If others strike that warrior down and slay him while he is thus engaged in striving and exerting himself, with the breakup of the body, after death, he will be reborn in a hell called the realm of those slain in battle.

This simulation is mentally real yet not corporeal
"Moreover, if he holds a view such as, 'When a warrior strives and exerts himself in battle, if others strike him down and slay him while he is thus striving and exerting himself, with the breakup of the body, after death, he will be reborn in the company of the devas slain in battle,' that is his WRONG VIEW.

"Now, there are two destinations for a person holding such a wrong view, I say, either a hell or the animal world.'

I was lied to and fooled.
When this was said, the headman Yodhajiva began to sob then burst into tears.

The Buddha then said, "That is what I could not get past you by saying, 'Enough, headman, set that aside and do not ask.'"

"Venerable sir, I am not crying because of what the Blessed One said, but rather because I have been deceived, misled, and fooled for so long by that ancient teaching lineage of warriors." — SN 42.3
The Workings of Kamma (Pa Auk)
Given that this person is striving, exerting, and mentally hunting down enemies, behaving like a would-be killer, gangster, or trained soldier already mentally engaged in violence, BUT has not yet killed anyone, what's the harm?

The Buddha points to that mental harm: The warrior's mind (heart, citta-stream) is ALREADY seized, debased, and misdirected.

The person need not do anything else yet bad karma (unskillful, unwholesome deeds) will have already accrued. The seeds with the capacity to produce results in the future will have already been planted. The gamer need not go any further (with speech or bodily action) to have already made karma.

What kind of karma was made? There are six kinds: wholesome, neutral, or unwholesome (mundane or supermundane). All of this so far is mundane. What makes a deed good or bad?


ALL bad deeds have only three roots. The same is true for all good deeds. Those unwholesome roots are greed, hatred (which includes fear), and delusion. If one thinks, speaks, or does (acts) motivated by one or more of these roots, the outcome is bad (unskillful) karma. It is called "bad" karma because it will produce, when it ripens, unwelcomed, unwished for results.

Karma is NOT punishment but like-for-like
It would be "good" karma if it were rooted in nongreed (letting go, giving, unselfishness, releasing, contentment, charity, sharing, providing), nonhatred (loving kindness, compassion, sympathy, equanimity, help), and/or nondelusion (right view, wisdom, insight, understanding).

What is one nourishing while playing Grand Theft Auto VI? It must be goodwill, kindness, love, affection, sympathy... Who knows who's playing that game. When we get in the hotseat and start shooting, we as gamers are exercising the worst qualities: grand theft, mass murder, rape, psychotic violence, endangering others, and so on.

If only psychology had something to say

  • You watched what, you pervert? - It was a study!
    *When I was a graduate student in psychology at UCLA, I remember a very powerful piece of information passed down to us by our famous psychology professor. At the time, all the way down to today, it was being disputed whether or not WATCHING PORN was harmful. (Is watching online porn unskillful or "bad" karma?)
The experimental results had been inconclusive. Expose subject to violent pornography, see what happens. In all their early measures, they were the same. This would suggest, "No harm, no foul, watch as much violent porn as you want." The sex industry was overjoyed to hear it. Even science can't find any harm in watching "adult" content. Except there was one measure, and it was very suggestive.

If I were a good scientist, I would have the references at hand to back this up. But it's not necessary because many researchers followed suit, so whoever did it first hardly matters. This was a robust finding. (Smithers! Get my professor on the line to ask her for the citation ASAP.)
The design of the psychological study
Jerry, Kramer says GTA VI is coming out. Can you ask Elaine if we can watch porn at her place?
.
Elaine, will you be in our study?
What researchers did was a two-part experiment. Part 1, expose subjects to hardcore violent pornography. Part 2, have them engage in a "learning" trial. This trial consisted of a female "learner" engaged in some task or other. When observed doing the task correctly, press the green button held in the subject's hand. When observed doing the task incorrectly, press the red button to electrocute (as in the Stanley Milgram and Solomon Asch experiments) or "help teach" the learner to do it correctly.
  • SHOCKING: The Milgram experiments at Yale and Asch experiments were a series a shocking electrocution experiments in social psychology in the early 1950s and 1960s to test people's willingness to shock, punish, or even kill others if instructed by an authority figure or the majority of a group. CONCLUSION: Ordinary people will shock, punish, even kill someone if an authority figure tells them they should or to conform to a group (americasbestpics.com).
You want me to shock? (americasbestpics.com)
Experimental subjects gave the learner just as many "shocks" as those not exposed to violent pornography. BUT, unconsciously, they held the red shock button longer. They held it down for a statistically significant greater length of time = more electrocution, more shocking, more pain administration.

Shocking experiments at Yale U
When asked afterward, "Do you think you were fair in praise and blame (green button, red button administration) of the learner?" They all reported, "Yes, I was quite fair and objective." This is what most if not all of them must have thought.

However, the data revealed what they seemed to be unaware of but what researchers could clearly see: Those not exposed to violent pornography administered punishments in this proportion. Those exposed to violent pornography administered punishments disproportionately -- the same number of shocks but unconsciously held down longer.
  • Now imagine this study but exposing subjects to 15 minutes of first-person shooter roleplaying GTA 5 (to say nothing of the new better, brighter, more densely pixelated magic of GTA 6) then running the Part 2.
None of this is said so that someone will have the ammunition to say, "Porn is bad, don't watch it" or "filthy videogames are mental garbage, don't play them."
  • This is only said for the personal, private realization: "Might I be behaving differently in the real world because of what I do in the virtual one as I spend my free time immersed in a very engaging (dopamine producing) fantasy as a first-person shooter engaged in role play for hours and hours, days and days, years and years?
It's something to think about because, suddenly, we're outside the scope of this Buddhist article. All that is being said here is that some kind of mental karma is being generated by just playing a game. Now we see there is scientifically validated data and evidence that how and what we play negatively impacts how we live real life. Yikes! Who knew?

What does the state religion say about it?
  • Why get religious? By chance I was having a conversation with my very devoutly Christian mother. So I asked her:
God wants you in Rome's Army
"Mom, does that guy Jesus ever talk about distinguishing SIN into physical, verbal, and merely mental?"

Asked in this way, she suddenly kicked into action with many examples. We all know sowing what we will later reap (what the Buddha and the East call "karma") is a physical act. That's easy to imagine. Can it be just verbal? Lying and uttering other harmful words is easy to realize can be sinful, can be missing the mark of how to behave in this world. But what about just thinking stuff? Apparently, in the way of Jesus' teaching, that can be a "sin," too.

It's almost as if cultivating and harboring universal love and sisterhood for all our fellow human beings would be meritorious all on its own (the way it is in the Buddha's Teaching).

I'm already guilty in my heart, Mags
It is almost, one could believe, as if Jesus Christ Born to Humans (aka a "Son of Man") had heard the Buddha's teachings from five centuries earlier.

Most people playing GTA VI, I would hazard to guess, are going to be nominal Christians. So even if they didn't believe a word any teaching on "karma," they might nevertheless remember how the Good Shepherd taught about SIN (missing the mark) and how long before it becomes an action, say adultery just to pull one out of the hats of so many sins, one by looking upon a female in that way (nudge-nudge, wink-wink) has ALREADY committed adultery in his or her heart (Matthew 5:28). Just saying. Ask Jesus or his Dad about it when you see them. ⛪

It's "adultery" just to look, but videgoame murder and theft, why would Jesus be against that?
  •  CONTINUED IN PART 3

Ajahn Chah (read by Ajahn Jayasaro)


What did Ajahn Chah actually teach?

Nature of Consciousness (Alan Watts)

Debate: Can we say the N-Word now?

I can say N, but not F?

Wassup, My Nigga: The Hidden History of a Controversial [N-] Word
I can use the word, right, Diddy? Kanye's cool with it cuz we're da Billionaire Boyz in da Hood.
.
My Nigga: History of a Word
Author Prof. Hiram L. Smith, Ph.D. has 5.0 out of 5 stars (with one review) for the history and meaning of one of the most controversial words in American English. Few words in American English are as charged as "nigga" and "n*gger."

While the racist slur "n*gger" is universally recognized as offensive, fierce debates continue over the use of the more playful "nigga"―who can say it, what it actually means, and whether it has been reclaimed as a term of endearment among Black people.

Wassup, my negus ("king")?
Are these two words or one word with two pronunciations? Do they have different meanings? Wassup, My Nigga is the first book written by an African American linguist to explore the term's origin, history, and usage.

Drawing on sources across time, from 19th-century slave narratives and ex-slave recordings to contemporary conversations on social media, the book reveals how the word's meanings vary according to context and across racial groups.

West coast rapper Tupac goes off
Blacks' most controversial opinions
  • Lady of Niger: Wm. C. Monkhouse
    Negus
    , or "The Negus" (Al-Najashi, النجاشي) in Islamic tradition [a], is a title [2]. It is the word for "king" in the Ethiopian Semitic languages, usually bestowed on a regional ruler by the Negusa Nagast, or "King of Kings" [3] [like the Buddhist term Raja-Naga or "Royal-Reptilian" associated with rulers of this world in the cosmology in Dharmic religions] in pre-1974 Ethiopia. More
  • I'm a hothead; I lost it on stage
    Orthodox Ethiopia, Africa, which emerged from the ancient Kingdom of Kush (Nubia), is an early (possibly the earliest) seat of Christianity, worshipping Black Jesus, not to be confused with the countries of Niger or Nigeria as in the childish limerick teaching white children how to correctly pronounce the name of the African country: "There was a young lady of Niger/Who smiled as she rode on a tiger;/They returned from the ride/With the lady inside,/And the smile on the face of the tiger" by Cosmo Monkhouse, not to be confused with the Jewish American racist Cosmo Kramer (Michael Richards aka "Mic Dic") from the show Seinfeld. Cosmo Monkhouse was a British poet, art critic, and civil servant.

It challenges myths about reclamation, explains why multiple pronunciations exist, and examines what the evidence really shows about how―and whether―meanings have changed over time.

By presenting the discussion within the context of African American English, Wassup, My Nigga sheds new light on one of the most controversial words in American English and what it reveals about language, race, and identity. More

"I wish a N*gga would"

LYRICS: "I'm Different" by 2 Chainz

Southern rapper 2 Chainz
Yeah/ Yeah/ 2 Chainz/ [YG:] Mustard on the beat, h*! [2 Chainz:] I'm different, yeah, I'm different/ Pull up to the scene with my ceiling missing/ Middle f*nger up to my competition/ I'm different, yeah, I'm different (Tru)/ Pull up to the scene with my ceiling missing/ Pull up to the scene, but my roof gone (Roof gone)/ When I leave the scene, bet your Boo gone (Boo gone)/ And I beat the p*ssy like a new song (Boom)/ 2 Chainz, but I got me a few on (Yup)/ Everything hot, skip lukewarm (Ugh)/ Tell Shawty bust it open, Uncle Luke on/ Got the present for the present and a gift wrapping/ I don't feel good, but my tr*gger happy (Bah)/ Bet the stripper happy, bet they wish they had me/ And I wish a nigga would, like a kitchen cabinet/ But me and you we cut from a different fabric/ I f*cked her so good, it's a bad habit (Damn)/ B*tch, sit down, you got a bad atti'/ Gave her the wrong number and a bad addy (Tru)/ You ain't going nowhere like a bad navi'/ A*s so big, I told her to look back at it (Whoa)/ Look back at it (Whoa), look back at it (Whoa)/ Then I put a fat rabbit on the Craftmatic/ I am so high...attic/ I am so high, like a...addict/ I'm different, yeah, I'm different/ Pull up to the scene with my ceiling missing/ Middle f*nger up to my competition/ I'm different, yeah, I'm different (Ugh)/ Pull up to the scene with my ceiling missing/ 2 Chainz, got your girl on the celly/ And when I get off the celly, I made her meet at the telly/ When she meet at the telly, I put *t straight in her belly/ When it go in the belly, it ain't sh*t you can tell me, ugh (Ugh)/ Hair long (Long), money long (Yeah)/ Me and broke niggas, we don't get along (Nah)/ Hair long (Long), money long (Yeah)/ Me and broke niggas, we don't get along (Tell 'em)/ I paid a thousand dollars for my sneakers/ 'Ye told you, a 100K for a feature/ "Ee-err, ee-err": sound of the bed (Bed)/ Beat it up, beat it up; then, I get some h*ad (H*ad)/ Well, I might get some h*ad; then, I beat it up/ I don't give a f*ck, switch it up, nigga, live it up (Up)/ Yeah, it's going down, so get up (Up)/ Might valet-park a Brinks truck (Ugh)/ [YG:] Mustard on the beat, h*!/ [2 Chainz:] I'm different, yeah, I'm different/ Pull up to the scene with my ceiling missing/ Middle finger up to my competition I'm different, yeah, I'm different/ Pull up to the scene with my ceiling missing Explicit version from azlyrics.com

How to end war now (Mandy Kahn)


Peace Class every Wednesday, 6:00 pm (PST)
Friends, Peace Class meets every Wednesday night live from Hollywood on Zoom. To join us, simply click on this link at the start time of 6:00 pm (Pacific Standard Time).
  • Note that clocks in California shifted back an hour from Pacific Daylight Time (PDT) to PST. If joining from Arizona, Hawaii, or from abroad, check to see what 6:00 pm LA time translates to from anywhere else: dateful.com/time-zone-converter.
All are welcome at Peace Class. Last week's talk, how to end war:

END VITRIOL TO END WAR

Why can't CN be more like US?
If we have vitriol for fellow human beings, we must have vitriol for ourselves. Do we send vitriol out from ourselves towards our fellow humans, believing that it leaves us and arrives at them?

It arrives right back at us often missing them altogether. It's like the habitual drinker who says, "I'm trying to drown my sorrows."

That person will eventually lament, "but no one told me sorrow could swim." When we see the violence of others and it angers us, we may carry vitriol within. It builds up and up -- more of what we don't like.

What war does to beauty in Afghanistan
When you see the violence of others but that inspires us to build a world without that violence, we are consciously choosing a thought that builds a more compassionate world. Then we have used the input of the world around us to our advantage: We have used it to build what we prefer.

When we see vitriol and do not like it, we carry opposite-facing vitriol. That is, we carry the same vitriol. And we build more of what has angered us. Trading vitriol with others becomes a cycle. That cycle can trap an individual or even trap all of humanity. But there is a way out.

I don't know why they say war is bad. It's profit
That way out is to see vitriol and say, "I see vitriol and do not like it. I don't like the world it builds. So I choose the world I am building consciously: I choose a world of peace. I build it now."

A world of peace is built with compassion. It can also be built with hope for compassion. It, however, cannot be built with vitriol -- even vitriol against vitriol.


You're rich, right, Bibi? - Damn right, Don.
Vitriol must be healed before collective peace comes into being.

The Cycle of Vitriol is chosen again and again, consciously or unconsciously. Therefore, we can also un-chose it. If we can see how vitriol leads to vitriol, we can say: "Well, I don't want that. So I'm going to take my power back and build something new. Rather than sending this vitriol-laced tennis ball back over the net to you, the game ends when I decide not to play it."

I feel so full of hot air when I play my game.
"Instead of playing vitriol tennis, I'm going to begin to build a new kind of society—the one I prefer."

When we do this, wat will happen is that some will continue to play vitriol tennis, whereas others will say, "Wait—what's that new way being built? That looks better and more interesting!" So some will leave this vitriolic tennis court to go over there and see what's happening. Some will join the better way to build a better society.

At first, it may feel lonely not playing angry tennis with the crowd. People are lobbing their vitriol-laced tennis balls over the net with such fervor, such passion, that we will feel the pull of a very engaging game, one we've often played before. Maybe our game of world-building will feel calm and quiet by comparison.

My anal leakage and adult diapers are not due to irritable bowel syndrome. I just love gas.
F.U. I got my billions. I don't need any of you!
But if we keep building, others will eventually notice. A few will withdraw their energy from vitriol contests and want to learn more about this technique of building peace. Some may be inspired by what we are doing and will begin doing something similar.

Each person who withdraws from the Cycle of Vitriol is beginning to free him or herself (or themselves), and others, too, from the strong pull of that vicious cycle of the world of the past.

"An object in motion tends to stay in motion until it is acted upon by a counteracting force." That force can be our will to change.

Enter the whirlpool. Leave anytime you like
The whirlpool of the old cycle is strong. It will continue until players withdraw their energy. We all make the choice where to put our thoughts, focus, and creative energy. Sometimes we have been doing it for so long that we forget we chose and carry on habitually, forgetting our power in the process.

However, in peaceful world-building, that whirlpool softens and softens, and it becomes easier and easier for more swimmers to pull away and swim out of it.

Those who are conscious thinkers can choose actively what they want. Others are instinctual in their habits, which have grown to feel like necessity. "There can be no other way because this is the way it's always been!" some might say.

If we want a world of peace, free of violence, let's choose it by choosing to leave vitriol behind.

Let's form an intentional community for peace.
If we want a world of peace, let's pair our opinions with the feeling of compassion-for-all.

We cannot have vitriol for others without feeling the negative effects of that vitriol ourselves. Our vitriol affects us first, not in a way that we would consciously choose. It is an undercurrent, thoughtless, a custom, a bad habit, the pull of the world negatively influencing us because of all the vitriol we see being chosen sub- or unconsciously.

Our vitriol for others makes us feel terrible. Now, of course, at first, it may feel like a pleasant relief to express some vitriol, to get it out of our system. If what we had been feeling just prior was depression or hopelessness, defeat or despair, action can be a step up in the right direction. Almost nothing feels as bad as those three: vitriol, depression, hopelessness.

War is peace (in Orwell's 1984)
They mark the low end of the spectrum of what we as humans can feel. If we want to live on the low end of the spectrum of what can be felt, choose vitriol and go down from there.

But if we want to feel better things—if we want to feel hope and build a world of hope, or feel peace and build a peaceful world, know that vitriol is moving in the wrong direct, very far from the beautiful things that are possible. Know that vitriol is suited for repeated actions because it lends itself to trapping people in cycles.

The whirlpool of vitriol is very easy to enter and hard to escape. It can take a lot of energy to get out of a vitriolic whirlpool once we've fallen in, whether by choice or thoughtlessly. Anyone is free to jump in, certainly. We have free will. We choose.

Perhaps consider whether anyone likes staying there for a long time, swirling into hopelessness. Before we may have thought, "Well, I'll just get sucked in for a minute." Many have thought that and, years later, have found they are still stuck in its swirl. Vitriol is unique in that way.

Nukes bring peace. Kill Russians!
This bears mentioning because many who are trapped in the whirlpool of vitriol will invite others in to join them. "Misery loves company." If I'm doing what everyone else is doing, how bad could doing it be?

But know that we are choosing something that will only become harder and harder to un-choose. That's why others are inviting us to join them: They are in trouble, unable to get out of that whirlpool themselves. So if they want to be near us, they need us to jump in and drown with them. They can't very well pull away to join us—or at least they feel they can't.

We are free to fall in, if we'd like, but know that it will take a lot of energy to ever get back out.

I don't want to drown in American society
Vitriol is the opposite of compassion. It is saying, "I dislike this peaceless situation, so I'm going to build more of it."

Compassion is saying, "I don't like this peaceless situation, so I'm going to change it."

Compassion-for-all is saying, "I dislike this peaceless situation, so I'm going to build a world in which nothing like this ever happens again."

Every Wednesday morning, the link for that evening's Peace Class is sent out along with the text of the previous week's peace talk. There's a mailing list. To join it, sign up here: brave-basil-514.myflodesk.com/z82hxkb6mm
In peace, Mandy Kahn