Showing posts with label religious similarities. Show all posts
Showing posts with label religious similarities. Show all posts

Sunday, November 9, 2025

The Christ vs. The Buddha: similarities

Sid (the Buddha), Kris (Krishna), Mo, Josh (Jesus), Aquaman, Lao Tzu, Joe (Joseph Smith)

JESUS vs. the BUDDHA: Love vs. Non-Attachment
The Buddha and the Christ: friends
(Buddha's Wisdom) šŸ”JESUS vs. BUDDHA: LOVE vs. DETACHMENT: TWO PATHS, ONE TRUTH. What happens when Jesus’s fearless [yogic] love [called agape in Greek] meets the Buddha’s wisdom of [boundless love called metta and] letting go*?
  • *“Attachment says, ‘Be mine,’ whereas love says, ‘Be well.’”
This video explores how two of history’s greatest spiritual teachers [the Buddha preceding Christ by at least 500 years], born five centuries and continents apart, answered the same human question: *How do we love without suffering*?
  • *Suffering: dukkha, disappointment, pain, unsatisfactoriness, misery, ill, woe, not getting what we want and getting what we don't want.
From Galilee to the Ganges, discover how their paths converge in a timeless lesson for the modern heart.

šŸ“æ DISCOVER:
  • The radical love of Jesus that defied tribal and political boundaries
  • The Buddha’s teaching on non-attachment and the end of desperate grasping and clinging
  • The hidden parallels between early Christian and Buddhist thought
  • The mystery of whether the Christ and the Buddha’s teachings ever crossed paths [in ancient India, Tibet, and Central Asia]
  • How to practice “love with open hands” in relationships today
šŸ™ Subscribe for more East-meets-West wisdom: Every week, we explore the meeting point of philosophy, history, and spirituality, from Buddhist cosmology to hidden wisdom in Western thought.

⏱️ TIMESTAMPS:0
  • 00:00 The grip in our chest
  • 01:14 The love paradox
  • 02:44 The dangerous love of Jesus
  • 07:24 The freedom love of Siddhartha the Buddha
  • 11:19 When two truths collide
  • 15:35 Love without the leash
  • 21:21 The third path
  • 24:50 Love fearlessly, LET GO freely
šŸ“š SOURCES AND FURTHER READING:
  • The Metta Sutta (Sutta Nipata 1.8) – Teachings on Loving-Kindness
  • Sallatha Sutta (SN 36.6) – The Parable of the Second Arrow
  • The Gospel of Luke 10.25-37 – The Parable of the Good Samaritan
  • The Gospel of Matthew 5.44 – “Love thy enemies”
  • Comparative studies on Greco-Buddhist exchanges along the Silk Road
  • Historical scholarship on early Christian monasticism and Buddhist influence
šŸ“± Join community: Instagram: buddhaswizdom. Facebook: buddhaswizdom. ☕ Support the channel: buymeacoffee.com/buddhaswisdom
  • * Love fearlessly. Love freely. Stay curious. Stay wise.
#Jesus, #Buddha, #Love, #Detachment, #NonAttachment, #Spirituality, #Mindfulness, #Buddhism, #Christianity, #Philosophy, #EastMeetsWest, #Wisdom, #Enlightenment
  • Buddha's Wisdom, Nov. 8, 2025; Pat Macpherson, Dhr. Seven (eds.), Wisdom Quarterly

Wednesday, August 16, 2023

Bhikkhu Bodhi: Reconciling Theravada-Mahayana

Bhikkhu Bodhi, Clear Mountain Monastery, 8/13/23; Dhr. Seven (ed.), Wisdom Quarterly


Reconciliation and Liberation: Theravāda-Mahāyāna; Gradual or Sudden Awakening; Early Buddhist Texts
(Clear Mountain Monastery) Aug. 13, 2023: Clear Mountain Monastery Podcast In this session, Ajahn Kovilo and Ajahn Nisabho Q&A interview with Venerable Bodhi.

Topics touched upon include Theravāda Buddhism and Early Buddhist texts; the drawbacks of attaching to either; reconciling Theravāda and Mahāyāna traditions; practicing with Noble Beings; and more.

Timestamps
  • 0:00 - Intro
  • 0:22 - Bio of Bhikkhu Bodhi
  • 1:20 - Learnings and insights from the Commentaries
  • 8:25 - The Early Buddhist Text movement, and what it might lose in the absence of the Commentaries
  • 11:42 - Bhikkhu Sujato’s checklist of differences between the EBT and Theravada, specifically the spirit of enquiry in EBT
  • 15:27 - Bhikkhu Bodhi’s definition of the EBT
  • 19:00 - Benefits and risks of EBT labeling, and risks of EBT “conceit”
  • 20:38 - The “layering” of Mahayana, and Bhikkhu Bodhi’s view of these two schools of thought
  • 26:00 - The two models of the Bodhisattva path - deferring enlightenment vs. achieving a state that transcends samsara
  • 33:19 - How to reconcile the seeming differences between Orthodox Theravada and Orthodox Mahayana
  • 40:54 - Translating the “Don’t Know” mind into Pāḷi
  • 41:30 - Living and teaching in a Mahayana monastery
  • 43:16 - Interactions with beings who have influenced Bhikkhu Bodhi the most, and the one quality that keeps monastics in robes
  • 52:43 - An anecdote about Western scholar Nyanaponika Thera
  • 53:00 - Advice to young monastics
  • 56:21 - The Gradual Path vs. Instantaneous Awakening, and does Theravada support more than the first?
  • 1:01:11 - The importance of meeting and studying with a noble one (ariya-puggala)
  • 1:03:45 - Gratitude and thanks
  • 1:04:20 - Outro
To join via Zoom on Saturdays, visit Clear Mountain Monastery's website and click on the link for the Saturday Morning Meditation, Teaching, and DeCaf Social (clearmountainmonastery.or...)

To participate in the Saturday chanting, use this PDF (cdn.amaravati.org/wp-content...).

Tune in with fellow practitioners every Wednesday evening from 6:00-6:45 pm or Saturday morning from 9:30 am - 11:00 am for a Dhamma Talk and Q&A with Ajahn Kovilo or Ajahn Nisabho. Saturday mornings begin with a 30-minute meditation.

Wednesday evening Q&A's are followed by a discussion on Zoom from 6:45 pm-7:30 pm. See clearmountainmonastery.org or visit linktr.ee/clear_mountain_monastery... for details. Welcome!

Saturday, March 4, 2023

Native Americans and Tibetans are too similar

Regular contributor Hendon Harris (Chinese Discover America, 2/13/23); Dalai Lama; Marcia Keegan, Tibetans and Native Americans; Dhr. Seven, Xochitl (eds.), March 4th, Wisdom Quarterly
Meeting Hopi tribal elders in Calgary, Dalai Lama (thegreatgathering.org)



Were Anasazi Native Americans Buddhists
Buddhism arrived in America before Columbus
Q: If two different societies thousands of miles apart and separated by the vast Pacific Ocean have an irregular surplus number of similar beliefs and customs, one must at some point at least admit that these two groups of people -- even though far apart -- certainly appear to have had an ancient connection, right?

A: Right. Unless it's all a coincidence.

Q: True, one similarity could be a coincidence, but could all of these?

A: Not likely. There must be an underlying connection.
  • [EDITOR'S NOTE: In modern Ladakh/old Tibet, near Hemis Gompa, I saw unbelievable black-and-white photographs of Native Americans or indigenous Mexicans -- with characteristic features of our American Indians: dark skin, Asiatic features, turquoise jewelry, bolo ties, braided black shiny hair, sunbeaten and weathered faces, white cotton clothes, cowboy hats... What were these doing here? How could Natives be known in faraway Asia? These were no Americans but Tibetan cowboys and "Indians" dressed as cowpokes. The similarities were shocking and painfully striking. I had seen the girls at Boudhanath (Eyes of Buddha) Temple in Kathmandu, Nepal, nearly riot around a wandering salesman. I went over on my motorcycle. As the crowd separated and gave way to the bike, to my great disbelief and dismay I saw the cause of the commotion -- Madonna posters, yes, that Desperately Seeking Susan star dressed like a virgin. Any Western token, the Himalayans wanted in! So that they would have been into old Western photographs of cowboys and Injuns would not have been out of the questions. But these were parallel peoples of the Southwest, living in Pueblos like the great Potala Palace and revolving their lives around buffalo, hairy cows and bulls of the plateau and Plains, genetic bison. Above, the 14th Dalai Lama dons a cowboy hat, which looks ridiculous to us, all part of his charming humor, but would not be at all out of place in rural Tibet.]


Tibetans and Native Americans: From the Roof of the World to the Land of Enchantment
Neutered Kokopelli
A book by Marcia Keegan (author and illustrator), Valerie Shepherd (editor), Debra Snyderman (editor), and Carol O'Shea (editor) points to a strong Tibetan connection.

Here is a short list of connections, each of which would require a lifetime of work by anthropologists. Even then, few have made the connection and tied these customs together:
Buddhist missionaries visited America.
[Indian historian Dr. Ranajit Pal made the connection between the Buddha and modern Afghanistan, ancient Scythia/Shakya Land or Kapilavastu, more likely Kabul and Bamiyan and Mes Aynak, because young Prince Siddhartha who would become the Buddha was raised in three seasonal capitals, the Buddha's birthplace. So Buddhist missionary monks coming from Afghanistan and neighboring China to America before Christopher Columbus, born Cristoforo Colombo, is not as odd as it may first sound.]

History of Buddhism in America (Rick Fields)
If a picture is worth a thousand words, then Marcia Keegan's latest book is a chronicle of the similarities between two ancient cultures -- Buddhist and Native American -- that have sustained the human legacy through epochs of change.

While our current worldview has been shaped by the Renaissance in Europe and the Industrial Revolution there and here, the Native American and Tibetan cultures were thriving in a world of isolation from modernity, maintaining their own traditions handed down through their elders.

Kokopelli is a very phallic figure.
Native American stories of emergence, world cycles, and ceremonies are as alive today as they were in prehistoric times.

Tibetan Buddhist (and pre-Buddhist Bon) rituals date back to a root culture called the Shang Shung (Zhangzhung), pre-dating 10,000 years ago. It is the indigenous culture of the Tibetan Plateau in what the Chinese now call China (which amounts to half the landmass of Beijing's conquered empire/occupied territory).

"Tibet" is a massive part of "China," and the ruling Han Chinese know it (John Oliver/HBO).
.
Both cultures have co-evolved without any recorded contact between each other until 1979, during the 14th Dalai Lama's first historic visit to North America.

Marcia Keegan was there to arrange the initial meeting between a Hopi elder and the Dalai Lama's delegation.

The Hopi greeting of the Dalai Lama, welcoming home, signified the fulfillment of one of their great prophecies.

In response, the Dalai Lama asked, Where did you get your turquoise [jewelry]? This question signified a recognition of their shared values and aesthetic.

The subsequent dialog between the two leaders explored many commonalities, which revealed their basic human and cultural values that have sustained the spiritual, economic, and governance of the two cultures through centuries of change in the world.

 H.H. Tenzin Gyatso is one of us.
These have been codified in cosmologies that respect the dignity of the individual, the sacredness of nature, and the importance of ceremony as a condition of living.

Although their ceremonies and detailed spiritual beliefs differ, the core human values are the same. They are defined by their land [great plains full of bison/yaks], Puebloan architecture, decorations, cultural practices, customs, mountains, valleys, spirits, mandalas, sand paintings, ritual dances, petroglyphs (rock carvings and art), creation myths, prophecies, and gatherings.

This book, rich in images, captivates readers and offers them a rare glimpse of the heritage of their common human legacies.

Author Marcia Keegan, through her insightful text and photographs, allows us to draw our own conclusions as to what is important, questioning our values in relationship to two ancient and dynamic cultures that have contributed to humankind in metaphysical (non-material) ways.

The conclusions we draw are our own. The choices we make have their own results for the world we live in. Enjoy this book, ponder the comparison of similarities not only of two ancient cultures but also of the world you live in. It is never finite and always subject to change. From the roof of the world to the land of enchantment

Monday, May 27, 2019

Seven Types of People in the World (sutra)

Udakupama Sutra: "The Water Simile" (AN 7.15), Ven. Thanissaro/Geoffrey DeGraff (orig. trans.); Dhr. Seven, Sayalay Aloka, Bhante (eds.), Wisdom Quarterly
Seven friends are like these seven special types (dreamstime.com)
 
The Buddha taught: "Meditators, there are seven types of individuals found existing in the world. What are these seven?

"In one case, an individual sinks down once and stays sunk. In a second case, an individual, on coming to the surface, sinks down again. In a third case, an individual, on coming to the surface, stays on the surface. In a fourth case, an individual, on coming to the surface, opens one's eyes and looks around. In a fifth case, an individual, on coming to the surface, heads across. In a sixth case, an individual, on coming to the surface, gains a foothold. In a seventh case, an individual, on coming to the surface, crosses over, reaches the further shore, stands on high ground, a Brahmin.

1. "And how does one sink down once and stay sunk? In this case an individual is endowed with exclusively dark, unskillful characteristics. That is how an individual sinks down once and stays sunk.
 
2. "And how does one, on coming to the surface, sink down again? In this case an individual comes to the surface, [seeing,] 'Confidence ["faith"] in skillful qualities is beneficial, conscientiousness is beneficial, concern is beneficial, persistence is beneficial, wisdom (insight) with regard to skillful qualities is beneficial.'

"But one's confidence neither persists nor grows; it simply wanes away. One conscientiousness, concern, persistence, wisdom neither persist nor grow; they simply wane away. That's how an individual, on coming to the surface, sinks down again.

3. "And how does one, on coming to the surface, stay there? In this case an individual comes to the surface, [seeing,] 'Confidence in skillful qualities is beneficial, conscientiousness is beneficial, concern [ottappa, concern over the results of karma/actions willed, carried out, and accrued] is beneficial, persistence is beneficial, wisdom with regard to skillful qualities is beneficial.'

"One's confidence does not wane; instead, it develops and persists. One's conscientiousness, concern, persistence, wisdom do not wane; instead, they develop and persist. That is how an individual, on coming to the surface, stays on the surface.


4. "And how does one, on coming to the surface, open one's eyes and look around? In this case an individual comes to the surface, [seeing,] 'Confidence in skillful qualities is beneficial, conscientiousness is beneficial, concern is beneficial, persistence is beneficial, wisdom with regard to skillful qualities is beneficial.'
 
"With the eradication of [the first] three fetters [in the list of ten], one becomes a stream-winner [the first stage of enlightenment], steadfast, no longer liable to being reborn in any of the [four] woeful states, now destined for enlightenment. That is how an individual, on coming to the surface, opens one's eyes and looks around.

5. "And how does one, on coming to the surface, head across? In this case an individual comes to the surface, [seeing,] 'Confidence in skillful qualities is beneficial, conscientiousness is beneficial, concern is beneficial, persistence is beneficial, wisdom with regard to skillful qualities is beneficial.'

"With the total eradication of [the first] three fetters, and with the weakening of [the first three cankers] passion, aversion, and delusion [or greed, hatred, and ignorance], one becomes a once-returner,* who -- on returning [being reborn] only once more in this world -- will make an end of all suffering [i.e., gain full enlightenment and attain nirvana]. That is how an individual, on coming to the surface, heads across.
  • [*The various stages of enlightenment, listed as four distinct attainments (divided into four paths and four fruits) in most places, but actually consisting of seven stages, as explained in the Path to Freedom or Vimutti Magga, a commentarial text thought to have been written by Buddhaghosa as he composed his magnum opus the Path of Purification or Visuddhi Magga.]
6. "And how does one, on coming to the surface, gain a foothold? In this case an individual comes to the surface, [seeing,] 'Confidence in skillful qualities is beneficial, conscientiousness is beneficial, concern is beneficial, persistence is beneficial, wisdom with regard to skillful qualities is beneficial.'

"With the total eradication of the five lower fetters, one is due to be reborn [in the Pure Abodes], there to experience full enlightenment and nirvana, never again to return from that world. That is how an individual, on coming to the surface, gains a foothold.

7. "And how does one, on coming to the surface, cross over, reach the further shore [nirvana], stand on high ground, a Brahmin? In this case an individual comes to the surface, [seeing,] 'Confidence in skillful qualities is beneficial, conscientiousness is beneficial, concern is beneficial, persistence is beneficial, wisdom with regard to skillful qualities is beneficial.'

"With the eradication of the mental defilements, one enters and remains in the defilement-free liberation born of wisdom, having directly known and seen them for oneself here and now. That is how an individual, on coming to the surface, crosses over, reaches the further shore, stands on high ground, a Brahmin.

"These are the seven types of individuals found existing in the world."

Friday, September 14, 2012

The trouble in Libya Egypt, Yemen...

Pat Macpherson, Ashley Wells, CC Liu, Wisdom Quarterly
A minor pharaoh famed for not having his tomb robbed (ancient-egypt.com)
  
Spring, Egypt's Tahrir Square and the MIC (AFP)
A non-event, some video that had been up on YouTube for months, is suddenly seized on as a cause to protest and riot? Doubtful. 
  
It is difficult to say what is really going on, but this is clearly a pretext fanned by FOX News and presidential candidates in the US.
Should anyone be upset that the Prophet Mohammed is mocked? Yes. Our modernity means we have few if any sacred cows. That's fantastic and liberating for us. And eventually other spiritual people will devolve/evolve to that state. But until then respect is needed all the way around.
  
Buddhism is more peaceful and peace-inspiring than most people imagine. According to the Buddha, if a person hits another person and that hit-person hits back, that second-hitter is worse than the first. Jesus (Issa) would be proud to align himself with a nonviolent tradition like that.

Hi, I'm Republican Jesus
How far from that are our Judeo-European ways. Here we're encouraged to hit first and keep hitting.
  
(Growing up in Boston if I were to come home crying that I had gotten beaten up by someone, my father -- or my older brother in hi place -- would ask me, "Did you hit him first?" If the answer were no, I'd get a second beating. It's the Irish/Italian way. It's the east coast way. It's probably a holdover of surviving in a lower socioeconomic bracket. It's probably what any CHAV would do in Britain or gavone in New York).
  
Jesus is reputed to have said, "Turn the other cheek." If one is backhanded disrespectfully, turn the face to be hit honorably, openhandedly on the opposing cheek. In neither case is one to get mad, but we rarely follow that. At least we espouse it. At least we carried out crusades to spread Jesus's message of love to "barbaric" Muslims. (Did we teach them to cut off the hands of thieves, extract eyes for eyes, and not suffer children disrespecting parents under penalty of death, all things the Bible enjoins us to do?) We are the barbarians, and we can't bear to see ourselves that way.
  
"We aren't; they are!" we say. Or maybe everyone is. It's like Elizabeth Kubler Ross said, "I'm not okay, you're not okay, and that's okay."
  
So, hey Americans, stop insulting Islam! And, hey Military-Industrial Complex (MIC), stop invading, corrupting, installing, and deposing dictators friendly to the West.
  
Why?
Peace in the Middle East? (richardsilverstein.com)
If anyone believes the geopolitical Middle East is setting fire to embassies, schools, and effigy flags because of a YouTube video, they must not have been paying attention to events over the past few decades. It is analogous to the gratuitous Rodney King beating and attempted murder by the LAPD. Los Angeles did not erupt into rioting after criminal police were acquitted because of that acquittal. These are merely excuses, triggers, detonators to a tinder box of long held resentments.
  
It is because these abuses -- in this case abuse by the long arm of the US military under the control of our overt and covert government and the much shorter arm of the MIC's main ally Israel -- have been mounting for decades. They do not stir themselves up but are organized and antagonized by "our" PsyOp forces. So why do we keep falling for our mainstream media's slanted coverage which seems bent on instigating Armageddon scenarios wherever it can.

Monday, February 8, 2010

(D1975) If the Buddha and Jesus were to meet, they might recognize one another as fellow teachers of the good. They taught similar truths and experienced similar hardships. For example, both stayed in the wilderness and were tempted by Mara. Originally, Jesus's teachings promoted peace and turning the other cheek, passive resistance rather over armed insurrection.

Marcus Borg, a Christian scholar, focuses on Christian basics by selecting a range of quotations from the Gospels and pairing them with parallel sayings by the Buddha. Whereas Jesus said, "Blessed are the poor, for yours is the kingdom of God," the Buddha said, "Let us live most happily, possessing nothing; let us feed on joy, like the radiant devas."

It is surprising to readers familiar only with the Bible how similar the words of the two religious leaders actually are. When two ancient spiritual traditions like Buddhism and Christianity are compared, a striking similarity is revealed between the narratives of their founders. In the case of Christianity, Jesus is more bodhisattva than "god."

In the case of Buddhism, the Buddha is portrayed as almost omniscient like God. The essence of the Buddha's message is embodied in the Four Noble Truths: unhappiness, its origin, its cessation, and the truth of the path leading to its cessation. These truths are exemplified in the life of the Buddha himself. Similarly, if one looks at the life of Jesus, one sees the essential practices and teachings of Christianity in it. In both, it is only through hardship, dedication, and commitment, by standing firm on one's principles, that one grows spiritually and attains liberation from suffering.

Sunday, August 23, 2009

Buddhism is very different from Hinduism


Hindu saddhus in Durbar Square, Kathmandu, Nepal


Reply to Changi 1: Buddhism is very different from Hinduism
Daniel Hopkinson (Examiner.com, Aug. 22, 2009)
Buddhism is very different from Hinduism in several respects:
  • In Buddha's teaching there is no concept of gods such as in other theistic religions.
  • In Hinduism the God Shiva manifests itself in many forms.

WQ: The Buddha borrowed the prevalent concept of gods and Gods (devas and brahmas) and added to it. The concept is a far less complex pantheon, but there are many, many gods. The concept of what a deity is, indeed, is quite different. Buddhism is a non-theistic (not atheistic) tradition; it does not rely on gods but it does believe in them. The various kinds of gods in this and other worlds are subject to karma, rebirth, to downfall, and vary between one another. They are not able to grant liberation from Samsara. Often virtuous, they are not always wise. Sometimes powerful, they are oftentimes dealing with the same issues of vanity, ego, delusion, anger, and greed that humans are wrestling with.

  • Another fundamental difference is that while Hinduism condones the caste system Buddhism does not.
  • All human beings, in Buddhist beliefs, are equal. One station in life is in the hands of oneself. Karmic law ensures that.

WQ: Indeed, the Buddha did not support the traditional caste system. He regarded one's actions in this life, not one's rebirth into a particular station in life, as the more important thing. One is or is not a "brahmin" by one's actions now. However, one was not accidentally born into one's caste or circumstances. The Buddha pointed out inherent differences between beings. They are all equal in potential but not equal in karma (deeds), wisdom, access to knowledge, habits, and so on. The entire discussion is squashed whenever someone says the Buddha was a Hindu. He was not a Hindu. (There was not even such a thing as "Hindu" at that time).

The Buddha was a wandering ascetic who defied the dominant tradition (Brahmanism) and its Vedic authority. The Buddha rebelled against this authority and found a path to direct realization without the intermediary of priests (such as Protestantism in its utter rejection of Catholic Church orthodoxy and power) or authoritative and unquestionable texts no one but the priestly class even had a chance to handle and study much less interpret.

Reply to Changi 1: Buddhism is very different from Hinduism. Welcome to our discussions. It seems that we have a similar problem with Buddhism and Hinduism as we do in Christianity between Catholics and Protestants, at least in some respects:

  • Differences in belief: Some, like you [Changi], have asserted that they are very different, while others assert they are rather similar. It sounds as if we need more discussion and input from anyone who can provide us with some documentation. Thanks for your comments. Join the discussion!

WQ: Documentation (references to sutras, ancient commentaries, and modern scholarship) is abundant. The two traditions are not very different to the casual observer, no more different than Judaism and Christianity. And in that sense they are very different. People cannot tolerate the contrasts between Catholicism and Protestantism, and yet these are the same religion. Buddhism, like Christianity, is a new religion emerging out of Hinduism. The similarities are striking. But the comparisons between Christianity and Judaism are even stronger.

Whether Hinduism and Buddhism are more similar than different has more to do with what one regards as significant. On many significant points, they could not be more different. They sought the same thing (moksha or "liberation") but pointed out different means to achieve and different definitions for what constitutes deliverance. With the veneer of details removed, Hinduism is far closer to Christian beliefs than to Buddhism. But Hinduism and Buddhism share a common cultural background that links them.

Tuesday, June 30, 2009

Buddhism and Hinduism


Contrasting temple styles, elegant Buddhist pagoda and the intricate complexity of a Hindu temple replete with gods and mythological themes (malaysia.com).

Sohoni Das (SF Hindu Examiner 6/29/09; WQ editing)

Buddhism was founded by Siddhartha Gautama, the historical Buddha, who was [allegedly] born in Nepal, and lived and taught in the northeastern region of the Indian subcontinent. The Buddha's teaching, Buddhism, originated in what is now Bihar, India during the reign of Maurya Empire.

Since Buddhism and Hinduism originated in ancient India, they share many similarities. Buddhism, however, became a world religion, whereas Hinduism has largely stayed on the subcontinent. The Buddha is mentioned in several of the Puranas (ancient Hindu religious texts), and some Buddhist teachings appear to have been formulated responding to ideas contained in the early Upanishads.

It came to be taught in Hinduism, in many Puranas, that the Buddha must be an incarnation of Vishnu (a Hindu god) with the purpose of deluding demons (yakkhas) or mankind about the true Vedic Dharma.

Some striking similarities between the two religions are given below:
  • Ahimsa: a Sanskrit word meaning "non-violence" (non-harming) and respect for all life.

Buddha’s dialog of ahimsa in the Lesser Exposition on Karma Discourse (Culakammavibhanga Sutta) was a definitive move against the traditional [cruel animal] sacrificial Vedic rituals of Hindu culture. However, the Upanishadic literature in Hinduism was often critical of the Vedic ritual and emphasized the internal meaning and symbolism of the sacrifice rather than its literal enactment. Ahimsa doctrine was later developed in the Hindu Yajurveda under the Brahmanical culture.

  • Karma: meaning one's deeds or actions or activity, which is a central theme of Buddhist teachings.

It is believed that this idea is derived from Hinduism. However, there are apparent inconsistencies regarding this. The Buddhist doctrine of karma is based on the Buddha's direct mystical observations, rather than literary derivations. Hindu seers had their interpretations, which the Buddha seems to have expanded on, clarified, and added to.

  • Dharma: this term means "religious or ethical duty"

Both Buddhism and Hinduism believe that beings that live in harmony with dharma precede on towards moksha or nirvana (liberation).

Despite the similarities between the two religions, the major differences are:

  • God: The Buddha set an important trend of non-theism [different from atheism] by denying the notion of an omnipotent God.

According to Buddhism, there are gods but a higher reality, but not an ultimate creator God beyond the law of karma or rebirth. Mankind's need for protection and agency [not to mention Buddhist devas or Greek-style demigods], which are psychologically deep-rooted, prompts a need for this belief. However, Hinduism strongly believes in the existence of an ultimate creator God [Brahman] and also believes that gods are reborn as humans to save the earth (avatars or "messiahs").

  • Vedas: these Holy Scriptures are followed in Hinduism to acquire the divine Three-Knowledges of life.

Unlike Hinduism, Buddhists believe that Three-Knowledges should be achieved through the process of enlightenment, which the Buddha achieved in the three watches of the night on the night of his Great Enlightenment (mahabodhi). The Three-Knowledges are memory of past lives, seeing the rebirth of others according to their karma, and complete intuitive penetration of the Four Noble Truths and the destruction of spiritual defilements, which fester in the mind/heart (citta) and keep it obscured, defiled, and unenlightened. (This third knowledge is a composite one).

The Four Noble Truths are deep and profound. Understanding them fully (particularly the fourth) is the essence of Buddhist enlightenment. This understanding is not intellectual, however, but rather thorough-going, psychological, and even mystical.

  1. PROBLEM: All planes of existence are ultimately bound up with uneasiness (dukkha) in one way or another.
  2. CAUSE: This uneasiness is caused by cravings and attachments of all kinds.
  3. SOLUTION: This uneasiness ends when craving ends, when one is free of craving, which is achieved by knowledge-and-vision of nirvana, which means reaching the ultimate liberated state of enlightenment (bodhi).
  4. PATH: Reaching this liberated state is achieved by following the Path rediscovered and laid out by the Buddha.

It is apparent that later Indian religious thought was in turn influenced by Buddhism's new interpretations and novel ideas. The new religion gained prominence on the Indian subcontinent at one time eclipsing all other traditions in India before Hinduism assimilated many of its ideas and teachings and became the de facto state religion (with considerable Islamic and other minorities but almost no Buddhists independent of Hinduism).

Buddhism was eclipsed by a Hindu renaissance and Islam onslaughts in the 13th Century. It then flourished beyond India -- Theravada in Sri Lanka, Burma, Thailand, and other Southeast Asian nations; Vajrayana/Lamaism in the Himalayas (Nepal, Tibet, Bhutan, etc.); and Mahayana in East Asia (China, Japan, Korea, etc.).

Hinduism and Buddhism now coexist harmoniously in the world and are followed, at least in name, by hundreds of millions of adherents. Buddhism in India survived and is still practiced -- particularly in the Himalayan region such as Ladakh, Arunachal Pradesh, Sikkim, and in the east in what is now Muslim dominated Bangladesh.

Monday, September 22, 2008

Last Jews of India

Ancient Hindu symbol/Star of David, Janardhana Temple, India.

To the extent that Jews gave birth to Christianity, Judaism seems to have borrowed a great deal from ancient Hinduism and more recently continues to borrow from Vajrayana Buddhism, just as Jesus Christ and St. John seem to have. The lines of evidence are obscured by history and obfuscated by vested interests. Nevertheless, Jews not only owe significant portions of their spiritual heritage to ancient Vedic lore and the subcontinent, their presence is ongoing.
.
(Interestingly, even the Sri Yantra or Star of David, symbol of the Jewish faith, is pulled from esoteric Hindu teachings symbolizing the union of higher and lower chakras merging at the heart center; likewise the swastika and other Nazi symbolism was appropriated from esoteric Theosophical and Buddhist references to Aryans and the "setting in motion the Wheel of Dharma" by a "world monarch").

Dutch palace wall painting replete wtih ancient esoteric symbolism including star.
.
Last Jews of Calcutta have one last guardian
Sam Dolnick (AP, 9/20/08)

CALCUTTA, India -- The stooped man in the yarmulke fights his way through this chaotic city, the weight of generations heavy upon his shoulders. He squeezes past tea stalls and sidewalk electricians, past idle rickshaws, and honking cars. He edges through rows of vendors selling sparkly hair clips and, finally, pushes open a rusty gate hidden from the street.

Today is the Sabbath, and Shalom Israel, one of the last Jews of Calcutta, has reached a cobwebbed synagogue, a once-grand building with imposing doors that nearly always stay shuttered, and spires that soar up toward the monsoon clouds. Israel comes every Friday to light a candle, say a prayer, and check on the three synagogues still standing, however precariously, as relics of a passed era of plenty. Most weeks, he is the only visitor.

There were once 5,000 Jews living in this teeming port city, but today, as the Jewish New Year approaches, there are fewer than 35. Israel, 38 with a thin beard, is the youngest by nearly 25 years. Israel lives inside the only place left where Jews aren't a minority — the Jewish cemetery. He cares for the graves of his father, his great-grandparents, his uncles and his aunts, along with more than 2,000 other Jewish tombs. He also tends to the two dozen Jewish elders still living, handles the last rites when they die, and, to stay kosher, butchers his own meat.

It's not easy being the last of your people.

"It's only a matter of time before people die or leave," said Israel. "There is no future...The inevitable, I can't fight." Indeed, repopulating the community would be tough. There aren't many unmarried Jewish women in Calcutta — Israel is single and doesn't know any women younger than 60. His sister married a Hindu, for which the elders shunned her. The last Jewish wedding anyone can remember was in 1982.

He is weary from Calcutta's midsummer heat, and from the responsibility of caring for his ancestors' legacy. He's well aware that a centuries-old community will likely die with him, but he sees nothing to do but tend to its remnants and blow on the fading embers.

"I've seen what the community was. To see the way it is now..." He trails off mid-sentence.

Israel survives on a combination of odd jobs, but his health is poor, his nerves frayed by his multiple responsibilities. He usually keeps his skullcap in his pocket because he tires of explaining its significance, but at the end of the day, when he's in a taxi heading back to his solitary shed inside the cemetery, he takes it out and puts it on, exhaling for what seems like the first time all day.

In this country of 1.1 billion people, there are believed to be roughly 5,000 Jews — not enough to be counted as a distinct group in the Indian census. Jews first came to India as traders some 250 years ago, and today their largest community is in Mumbai [Bombay], the country's most cosmopolitan city.

Calcutta's first Jews are thought to have come in the late 18th century, descendants of the Baghdad Jews who came from Syria, Iran and Iraq. They thrived as diamond traders, real estate dealers, exporters, spice wholesalers, and bakers — one Jewish bakery famous for its plum cakes still stands, run by the founder's octogenarian grandson. Rickshaws and taxis still ply Synagogue Street and other roads named for prominent Jews.

The Jewish community built at least five synagogues and two schools. Today, there are 700 students at the Elias Meyer Free School and Talmud Torah. Not one is Jewish, and nothing particularly Jewish is taught there. In the 1930s and 1940s, Calcutta was a bustling, raucous hub, and Jews formed a solid minority, their wedding parties and religious feasts flowing down the temple steps. Jews were players at the popular horse track — Israel remembers his father's racehorses, Onslaught, War Dance and Black Toy — and they were regulars at the fashionable restaurants. Jews rarely faced discrimination, mainly because "no one knew who we were," said Ian Zackariah, 64.

As a community, "We were too small to bully," he said. "There were so many other people to beat up — Hindus vs. Muslims, high castes vs. lower castes. Who's going to pick on us?"

The birth of independent India in 1947, and the creation of Israel the following year, marked the beginning of the end for Calcutta's Jews. Many left for the new Jewish state; others moved to Europe or the United States in search of better business opportunities.

Some stayed behind, but life was different. During services, women left the temple balcony, where they used to sit in keeping with Jewish custom, and sat with the men in the main hall — the synagogue felt too empty otherwise. Slowly, the Jewish butchers put away their knives, the bakers turned off their ovens, the teachers boxed up their Hebrew books.

The stalwarts stayed to care for their aging parents, to raise their children or simply because Calcutta was home.

Aline Cohen, 62 was born after the community's heyday, but she still remembers rowdy festivals and packed synagogues. Now, there aren't enough absle-bodied men to form a minyan, the quorum necessary for services, and no one but Israel regularly visits the temples. The Jews rarely get together except at funerals, and sometimes not even then.

"It is lonely," said Cohen, whose three children were raised in Calcutta but have since left. "We all have non-Jewish friends, but ... there's a spiritual loneliness. You miss Sabbath services... You miss the feeling of community."
.
Shalom Israel, one of the last Jews of Calcutta, India, lights candles and prays in three existing Synagogues every Friday, shown 8/8/08. In the 1930's and 1940's, Calcutta was a bustling, raucous hub, and Jews formed a solid minority, their wedding parties and religious feasts flowing down the temple steps. There were once 5,000 Jews living in this teeming port city, but now there are fewer than 35 (AP Photo/Bikas Das).

Shalom Israel never really knew what it was to be part of a community. His only Jewish peers are his younger brother, who is preparing to move to Israel, and his younger sister. Israel lives in a small, cluttered shed inside the Jewish cemetery, just steps from his father's grave. Visitors may find the arrangement macabre, but he says it offers him peace inside a frenzied city.

"I find the living more dangerous to deal with than the dead," he jokes. "I have very easy neighbors." Cohen worries about Shalom Israel and what will happen to him after the elders are gone. She says he should move to Israel, but he won't.

"If I go to Israel when I'm 40 or 50, what's the point?" he said.

Besides, he says, the Jews of Calcutta need him. He ticks off his to-do list: take several elders to the doctor, take others to the dentist, take another to a hearing test; check on the temples, trim the overgrown cemetery foliage, visit the infirm living alone. He gets paid by the community for all this, but he says the work is important not because of the money but because "it gives me meaning, a matter of belonging."

"The community is dwindling to almost nothing," he said. "I am trying to keep it surviving as much as I can."