Showing posts with label patimokkha rules. Show all posts
Showing posts with label patimokkha rules. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 22, 2026

The Seven (7) Levels of Buddhism


This silly looking cartoon of a video is profound, so much so that we are included to call its maker, Greg Knows All, "Añña GREGḍañña" or "Greg who knows" (after the Buddha's very first enlightened disciple, Añña Konḍañña, "Kaundinya who knows, who see").

When the wandering ascetic Siddhartha first thought to teach and make known the Path to Enlightenment (Bodhi) and Liberation (Nirvana), what today the ancient Theravada tradition calls "Buddhism" or Buddha-Dhamma (The Doctrine of the Awakened One), he had no one to teach, no one at least whom he thought would understand. There were his wise albeit unenlightened teachers, but they were passed away and reborn in worlds where they could not be reached for a very long time. Some planes of existence are so long lasting, it's staggering. So he realized his five former companions on his spiritual quest might get it. When he taught them, one did. And that was Kondanna (Kaudinya)

He may be reading this from somewhere, possibly What the Buddha Taught or a scholarly rundown of the historical Buddha's path by Bhikkhu Bodhi or Ven. Professor Analayo. Wow, Greg.

Sunday, May 17, 2026

Buddhism and Dalai Lama on meat eating


Can Buddhists eat meat?
  • What have we said time and again? Buddhists can do whatever they want. However, killing (or violating any of the other precepts) is not keeping in line with what the Buddha taught.
  • "Pig's Delight" (sukaramaddava): truffles, but in the case of the final meal offering, inadvertently poisonous/toxic mushrooms picked in error thinking them truffles, which pigs love
  • Rule: A Buddhist monastic is not allowed to eat three kinds of "meat" (slaughtered flesh) -- that of a living being that is seen, heard, or suspected of having been killed for one's sake
Did the Buddha pass away from eating meat or mushrooms or by choice?

The precise contents of the Buddha's final meal are not clear, due to variant scriptural traditions and ambiguity over the translation of certain significant terms like sukara-maddava.

The Theravada tradition generally believes that the Buddha was offered "pig's delight" (sukaramaddava) which could be slaughtered pork or some kind of mushroom/food pigs delight in that was offered by the blacksmith Cunda, while the Mahayana tradition believes that the Buddha consumed a truffle or other mushroom [mistaken to be edible].

These differing translations may reflect the different traditional views on Buddhist vegetarianism and the precepts for monastics (monks and nuns) [265] as well as laypersons.

Modern scholars disagree on this topic, arguing both for pig's delight, pig's flesh, or some kind of plant or mushroom that pigs delight in eating [z].

Whatever the case, none of the sources that mention the last meal attribute the Buddha's sickness to the meal itself [266]. But it is widely thought that he suffered severe illness from being unable to safely digest to toxic food, which he directed Cunda to dig a hole and bury rather than offering to any other monastic present at the meal.

As per the "Great Final Nirvana Discourse" (Mahaparinibbana Sutta), after the meal with Cunda the blacksmith, the Buddha and his monastic companions continued to walk until he was too weak to continue.

They stopped at Kushinagar (near modern Gorakphur, India), where Ānanda was directed by the Buddha to prepare a resting place of folded robes between two sala trees in a delightful grove [267, 268].

After announcing to the Monastic Sangha (spiritual community) that he would soon be passing away, reclining into final nirvana, the Buddha personally ordained one last novice into the Monastic Order. His name was Subhadda [267].

He then repeated his final exhortations to the Sangha, which was that when he was no longer present to guide them, the Dhamma and Vinaya (Doctrine and Discipline, Teaching and Training) was to be their guide.

Then he asked if anyone had any doubts about the Teachings, but nobody did [269]. The Buddha waited, satisfied that anyone who would have like to speak or ask any final question had the opportunity to do so.

His final words are reported to have been: "All formations (saṅkhāras, fabrications) are hurtling towards destruction. Strive for the goal with diligence (appamāda)." In Pali this is, "vayadhammā saṅkhārā appamādena sampādethā" [270, 271].

He then entered the eight jhanas as his final meditation forward and then reversing, as verified by a psychic monk near him, reaching what is known as parinirvana ("final nirvana"). He did not "die," for if he had, he would be reborn as all ordinary being are reborn in accordance with their karma.

Rather than being reborn, "the Five Aggregates of physical and mental phenomena clung to as self that constitute a being cease to occur" [272] just as a fire, having exhausted its substrate of fuel goes out. But what is it that really goes out, a being? No, what goes out completely is ignorance.

The Mahaparinibbana Sutta reports that as his final act, the Buddha performed a final meditation of entering the first four material meditative absorptions (jhanas) consecutively, then the four immaterial absorptions, and finally a meditative dwelling known as "the extinction of feeling and perception" (nirodha-samāpatti), which should not be thought of as a permanent "extinction" since many Buddhist meditation practitioners are able to reach this attainment even now throughout life. It is said that only noble ones (those who have attained the stages of enlightenment) are able to reach it and can do so as often as they like as many times as they like. If it were a permanent extinction, no one would be able to do it a second, third, or thousandth time.

Before returning to the fourth absorption (jhana) right at the moment of passing into final nirvana without remainder [273, 268].

Having traveled and taught, the Buddha took his last meal, a sincere offering from a blacksmith named Cunda. But having eaten it, he fell violently ill. Not wishing that Cunda have remorse or misgivings about his offering, the Buddha instructed his personal attendant Ānanda to tell Cunda something.

The meal offering eaten at his place had nothing to do with his passing. Moreover, such an offering was an extraordinary source of merit because it was provided as a last meal for a buddha [262] tantamount to an offering of food to a bodhisatta before his attainment of supreme awakening (buddhahood, arahantship, great-enlightenment).

Bhikkhu Mettanando and Oskar von Hinüber argue that the Buddha passed away due to mesenteric infarction, a symptom of old age, rather than mushroom food poisoning [263, 264]. More

Monday, May 11, 2026

Eight added rules for nuns are untrue


Ayya Tathālokā: Venerable Bhikkhunī Tathālokā Mahātherī is an American-born Theravada Buddhist nun (bhikkhunī), scholar, and teacher.

She is the co-founder of the Dhammadharini monastic community in California, which includes Dhammadharini Monastery [Nunnery, Abbey, Hermitage] (formerly Dhammadharini Vihara), and Aranya Bodhi Hermitage [1].

She was the recipient of the 2006 Outstanding Women in Buddhism Award, a presenting scholar at the 2007 International Congress on Buddhist Women's Role in the Sangha, and was appointed preceptor for the historically-significant 2009 Bhikkhuni Ordination held in Perth, Australia [2, 3].

Early life
Born Heather Buske in Washington, D.C., in 1968, Ven. Tathālokā’s parents encouraged her to develop the skills necessary to look for what is true. She had early exposure to the texts of the Pali canon and was inspired by reading about the bhikkhunīs at the time of the historical Buddha. At the age of 19, she left college to pursue monastic life in Europe then in India... More:

Saturday, July 26, 2025

Thai monks have sex, get extorted (BBC)


Thai police have arrested a woman who allegedly had sexual relations with monks and then used photos and videos of the acts to extort money from them.
  • Buddhist monks have vowed to give up sex while in robes (while ordained) and such a transgression is called a "defeat" offense or parajika, for which there is no remedy. They are disgraced and immediately excommunicated from the Monastic Sangha and can never become monks again in this lifetime. To continue pretending to be a monk is a drastic error -- incredibly bad karma, stealing from donors and shortening the life of the Order on Earth. Having been defeating may be embarrassing or nothing to be proud of, but so long as one immediately disrobes and confesses the offense, one simply returns to lay life. It is because one lingers on in robes, fails to confess, and receives the benefits of monkhood that makes it grave and heavy karma causing one trouble for a long, long time.
The woman, who police are calling "Ms. Golf," had sex with at least nine monks, police said at a press conference on Tuesday. They believe she received around 385 million baht ($11.9m or £8.8m) over the past three years.

Investigators who searched her house found more than 80,000 photos and videos used to blackmail the monks, the police spokesman said.

This scandal is the latest to rock Thailand's much revered Buddhist institution, which in recent years has been plagued with allegations of monks engaging in sex offences and drug trafficking. More:

Wednesday, July 23, 2025

Temporary ordination for one Rains Retreat


.
(Nick Keomahavong) Many people are looking for the opportunity to become Buddhist monastics, especially Buddhist monks at Thailand's Wat Phra Dhammakaya.

Temporary ordination
All ordination is temp up to enlightenment
There is a specific program for international practitioners who want to become monastics for a few days or weeks is called IDOP, which is short for the International Dhammadayadas Ordination Program.

This program gives Westerners the opportunity to live and train as Theravada monastics. The program is in English and welcomes males from all over the world, not limiting itself to Buddhists.

Once the temporary 30-45 day ordination program is completed, the temporary monks enter the three months Rains Retreat or Phansa or Vassa at Prachinburi Province.

The Rains Retreat is a time for them to continue their monastic training, living a life of Dhamma and meditation.

Life for them slows down as they experience what it is like to truly live the life of a monk. This video was created to give an exclusive inside look and education into what is the annual three months Rains Retreat is like for all Theravada Buddhist monks.

American nun Ven. Tathtaaloka
Thailand also has maechis, or "Eight or Ten Precept Nuns," for females motivated to become monastics. These options are rarer than the traditional male samaneras and bhikkhus. But recent developments have restored even FULL ordination for women in Theravada Buddhist countries so that they can live out the life the Buddha made possible by establishing the Dhamma (Dharma) for their benefit just as well as that of males.

Friday, May 16, 2025

Monks behaving badly: Phuket, Thailand


Monks arrested, drunken Chalong shooting, Phuket beach vendors tossed || Thailand News
(The Phuket News) Premiered May 16, 2025: PHUKET [pronounced POOH-khet, not FOOK-k...] XTRA brought to you by @PVC Phuket Hosted by: JP Mestanza || #Phuket #PhuketNews #Thailand

Two years ago in Thailand
Embezzlement isn't new in bad Bangkok, half cremated corpse dumped

(The Thaiger) July 1, 2022: A head monk is accused of embezzling 95 million baht (~40 baht to the US dollar) and dumping half-cremated corpses into the river, Thailand’s major banks crash on pay day, and Thai fighter jets respond to MIGs from Burma (Myanmar). Sponsor: 5-star marine: 5starmarinephuket.com. #Thailandnightlife #Bangkok #ThailandNews
  • 00:00 Intro
  • 00:32 Monk accused of embezzling 95m
  • 02:37 Banking apps crashed
  • 04:19 Burmese jet flies in Thailand
  • 06:09 Thai PM against drug
  • 07:13 Thai COVID update
Subscribe: bit.ly/2Ch3iJp. Check out JP Mestanza’s channel: bit.ly/2XIxRUQ. SPONSOR: PSD Windows and Doors: bit.ly/2O0ngQy

ABOUT: The Phuket News TV is the video arm of The Phuket News, an English-language newspaper in Phuket, part of the Class Act Media family. Phuket Xtra is a daily news show covering Phuket Island and the latest news from Thailand. This show intends to cover the everyday aspects of life in Southern Thailand and the rest of the Theravada Buddhist Kingdom of Thailand. Stay classy! (VIDEO) Phuket News TV: https://www.thephuketnews.com/tv/ (NEWSPAPER) The Phuket News: http://th.thephuketnews.com/ (RADIO) Live 89.5: https://www.thephuketnews.com/radio/

ABOUT: Founded in 2009, Class Act Media is Southern Thailand's most comprehensive media company, incorporating newspapers and magazines (English, Russian, and Thai), radio, TV, numerous websites, and an online ticketing service. Class Act Media prides itself on its ability to deliver high quality media services to residents and tourists in Phuket and all across Southern Thailand. It sincerely believes in accountability towards its clients and ensuring that each member of its team subscribes to its motto: "The client is always right." Read more at ThePhuketNews.com
  • Eds. Wisdom Quarterly

Wednesday, November 20, 2024

Ajahn Chah - Struggles - Sexual Desire


(dhammatube) Feb. 12, 2008: Battles to overcome sexual desire. All videos of this series are available at: ajahnchah.org/videos.htm

How to stop sexual thoughts in the mind | Buddhist story on how to control lust
(Words of Wisdom) April 13, 2024: Buddha Life Stories. If we keep thinking about sex all the time then we can become victims of hypersexuality. Hypersexuality can make us addicted to pornography and masturbation. But if we want to overcome excess sexual thoughts in our mind then here is advice.

This Buddhist story of a Zen master and a young boy can teach us how to overcome sexual thoughts in the mind. These wise tips of the Buddha can help us rid our minds and bodies of sexual addiction and masturbation.

#sexuality #lust #overcomeaddiction #howtocontrolmind #desire #controlemotions #buddhastory Twitter: wordsofwisdom_5 WOW Instagram: wordsofwisdom.motivation. Personal Instagram: shaill03 Facebook: words-of-wisdom-quotes-stories-11062425731... Explore the podcast 86 episodes Buddha Life Stories Words of Wisdom

Friday, September 20, 2024

Mysteries of monastic practice (video)



Mysterious monks around the Himalayas – practicing since the Ice Age?
The Buddha was an Indo-Scythian living close to the Himalayan range his whole life.
.
Siddhartha failing at asceticism
(FactFile) Sept. 20, 2024: Just as every culture holds its religion dear and follows unique practices, monks and nuns dedicate their lives to a spiritual practice. These monastics are deeply committed to their Doctrine (dharma), their belief system or faith, immersing themselves in meditation and rituals.
  • The Buddha ("Awakened One") finds success
    The Buddha avoided extremes of hedonism and self-mortification, teaching the Middle Way that avoids extremes. He did, however, teach 13 sane ascetic practices (dhutangas) for the overcoming of certain defilements, hindrances, and obstacles to practice to be able to breakthrough to calm and insight (samadhi and vipassana, where samadhi is shamatha and defined as the first four meditative absorptions and insight-practice takes these temporarily purified states and applies them to systematic practice of the satipatthanas or foundations of mindfulness to breakthrough to liberating wisdom, enlightenment, and release from samsara).
Their devotion is a profound expression of their beliefs and play a crucial role in preserving and passing on their spiritual traditions. Through their disciplined practice, they seek to connect with higher truths and guide others on their spiritual journeys.

Let's take a detailed look at some of the world's most mysterious and oldest-known monks. #factfile [This sensationalistic video was originally published under the very misleading clickbait title "Mysterious Monks Found in the Himalayas – And They’ve Been Living Since the Last Ice Age"]
  • FactFile, Sept. 20, 2024; Dhr. Seven, Amber Larson, Pat Macpherson (eds.), Wisdom Quarterly

Thursday, September 5, 2024

At the Nude Beach, Robes for Ascetics


Independence Beach: Celebrating our American freedom from swimsuits

You only live many times (Ariana Viera)
(Wonderhussy Adventures) Welcome to Wonderhussy Adventure #809. Date: July 2, 2024, pre-Independence Day, spending the Fourth of July at Wonderhussy's favorite clothing optional beach, celebrating our independence from bathing suits. Website: Wonderhussy.com. Support: wonderhussy. Help fuel next trip: paypal.me/wonderhussy, cash.app/$Wonderhussy.


They've taken away parking to keep crowds out!
Buy her dinner: https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls... Bitcoin link: 3H4kzyPxMEwNGNgntSpCQGDEj6xMADUUYC Merch: https://wonderhussy-merchandise.myspr... 
Recommended gear: https://www.amazon.com/shop/wonderhus... Calendars: https://www.createphotocalendars.com/...

CREDITS: Theme song by Michael Saint-Leon switchyardstudios.com. Fluffing a Duck by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/... Cattails - Thatched Villagers by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/...
Why didn't Buddhist ascetics go naked like Jains and yogis?
Jainism has two sects, white-clad and sky-clad, whereas Buddhism has saffron robes for all.
.
Ah, nudity is great. - What about white robes?
It was hot in proto-India in the Buddha's time. Pointing the way to freedom and final liberation or moksha was as free as the deer, wandering where they list in search of (alms) food. But there were obstacles. The Awakened One, the Buddha, had freed himself. Now it was time to make known the Path to Freedom, the Dharma. But how long would that knowledge last in the world? It had gone out before and was sure to dim again.

We shramanas existed long before the Buddha
He realized he needed a spiritual community of successful practitioners, a Noble Sangha, where "noble" means "enlightened" (Ayran) and Sangha means "spiritual community." There are various stages of enlightenment, from four kinds of stream entry to arhatship. They are detailed in the Path to Freedom and condensed in the Path of Purification. This Sangha would have them all.

To keep it going and to preserve the Teachings, the Buddha laid down rules in a Disciplinary Code (Vinaya Pitaka), with explanations for why each rule was instituted. The monastics recited about 227 core rules, the Patimokkha ("Path to Liberation"), each fortnight. If followed, they would ensure the long life of Buddhism (the Dharma), enlightened beings on earth (a Noble Sangha), and inspire confidence in new practitioners.

The Guru is naked (Jainism)
How was it going to look if monks and nuns went around naked? It was not unheard of. The Jains led by contemporary teacher Mahavira ("Great Hero"), the Nigantha Nattaputta, had already accepted females into the monastic community. That was a first. The Buddha always intended to, as he knew that his Sangha would not be complete until there were the four kinds of people (male and female monastics and laypersons).
  • This whole business about extra rules for nuns or not wanting to accept women is very suspect and seems more a conspiracy by male monastics to keep their all-boys club or wrest control of it from any kind of actual democracy. The Buddha had set up the first democratic rules, pre-Greece for its governance. See the scholarship of Ayya Tathaloka for evidence in the Bhikkhuni Vinaya of the later appearance of the garudhammas or "eight additional rules" and their unlikely back story.
Naked Mahavira: We don't need Five Requisites
The Buddha explained exactly why he allowed Five Requisites for Buddhist wandering ascetics -- robes of stitched cast-off garments, ceramic bowl, allowable medicines, shaving razor, needle and thread -- and the kinds of accommodations they were permitted. Rather than hairy, disheveled, wild men and women wandering around the hillsides naked and covered in ashes, he foresaw a better way, the perfection of the "pure life" of blamelessness for intensive practitioners wishing to make a quick end of all suffering.

Nude is not all it's cracked up to be, but the view
at night in the Sierra Nevada, it's awe inspiring!
Nirvana was here. And now a means of enlightenment and attainment of the bliss of nirvana had arrived with the Buddha. Many made use of it and so, even today, the world has arhats and those on the path to full enlightenment. And Buddhism became the first universal missionary religion spreading far and wide, outside the subcontinent into neighboring countries and lands. The rules made that possible. Hooray for the Monastic Disciplinary Code (Vinaya). And people, if they want, they can go about naked.
  • Wonderhussy Adventure #809, Summer 2024, Ananda (Dharma Buddhist Meditation); Dhr. Seven, Amber Larson, Pat Macpherson (eds.), Wisdom Quarterly

Friday, August 9, 2024

Sex, drugs, money, murder: Thai monks


Sex, drugs, money, and murder in Thailand’s monkhood | Foreign Correspondent
(ABC News In-depth) ABC is an Australian public broadcast service. Aug. 8, 2024: THAILAND In Thailand, Theravada Buddhism and the monks that lead the religion are deeply revered and hold a special place in Thai society.

But a series of scandals involving corruption, adultery, drug use, and even murder have undermined the religion’s moral authority.

If only Cartman were a Monk Cop
This week on Foreign Correspondent the ABC’s South-East Asia Correspondent Lauren Day reports on the ever-growing number of scandals engulfing the religion.

She talks to the Thai police who are going undercover to hunt down badly behaving monks and she heads out on patrol with the MONK POLICE whose aim is to catch wayward monks and drag them into line.

Why would Wisdom Quarterly cover this scandal, which could make Buddhism look bad?
  • Be like the Pope and hide corrupt clerical crimes.
    Wouldn't it be better to hide our dirty laundry like Mahayana Buddhism makes members vow to do?
  • The best disinfection method is moonlight?
  • We should only expose Christian corruption?
  • The good news is that Thai Theravada Buddhism is NOT a monolith. There are two schools, the Maha Nikaya ("Great Order") is 90%, and the renewal back-to-basics movement is 10%. The smaller one known as the Thai Forest Tradition, which is the tradition famous meditating monks like Ajahn Chah (who kept a foot in both schools) come from (since they are not in the cities or large monasteries) as well as their many successful Western students (Ajahn Brahm, Sumedho, Jack Kornfield, Ajahn Sucitto, and others).
  • All of these broken rules, long before they would rise to the attention of the legal system (violations of the Monastic Disciplinary Code, the 227 basic rules, laid down by the Buddha with meticulous descriptions and correctives), have remedies.
  • Fortunately or unfortunately, the democratic court (monastic legal system) set up by the Buddha is the responsibility of the Monastic Sangha "Spiritual Community") to administer.
  • The rules, court procedures, and consequences are all in place; that they are not pulled out to do their job of purifying the Sangha of corruption is the fault of the Sangha itself.
  • It is charged to police itself, and it does not police itself, so this happens.
  • One school does not set up administrative control of another, so the "purer" and much smaller Thai Forest Tradition Sangha cannot go tell the more corrupt and much larger Maha Nikaya to clean up its act.
  • In fact, the Thai Sangha has generally been a corrupt "religious" institution (rather than an avenue for authentic spirituality) for a long time, so long that in following the custom of every Thai male spending some time temporarily ordaining before being deemed fit to marry and become a Buddhist adult, a royal wanted to ordain but could not stomach the idea of entering a corrupt sect.
  • The solution was for the royal house to set up a new sect, a purer, back-to-basics monastic institution fit for a king.
  • That he was a king or prince or from the royal family made it possible to institute and fund, but it did not make it a legitimate vehicle according to monastic rules. One cannot simply set up a new Buddhist tradition.
  • The Buddha instituted the Sangha and laid down the rules for how that is done, so without him or without following the procedures set forth in the beginning of the Sangha, other institutions calling themselves "Buddhist" (such as the new Nuns Sangha) cannot be viewed as real except that they meet the rules previously laid down, which can be done by working with a preexisting school or sect, such as a Mahayana school.
  • There are many kinds of Buddhism, some unrecognizable to one another, but they are divided into just two traditions, Theravada (10%) and Mahayana (90%).
  • Thai Buddhism is Theravada (with a tiny Mahayana monastic presence), and as has already been stated, it also divides into two separate monastic institutions.
  • The Thai Forest Tradition is very much about the Monastic Disciplinary Code (Vinaya) and its strict implementation, for this the Buddha said is what will preserve Buddhism for a long time in the world.
  • In fact, there are three main Theravada Buddhist countries, and each took one third of the "Three Baskets" (Tipitaka) to focus on: Sri Lanka takes special care of preserving the sutras (suttas). Burma is focused on the Abhidhamma ("Higher Doctrine"). And Thailand is in charge of preserving the collection of vinaya texts (Collection of Monastic Rules). If the country in charge of the rules lets them lapse to this degree, what hope is there?
  • Of course, each country has its own Sangha (as do other Theravada nations like Cambodia and Laos, which were severely damaged by covert illegal U.S. mass bombings, CIA destabilization, and other war crimes during the US War on Vietnam).
  • Moreover, each monastery conducts its own business, so one monastery or abbot within a Sangha may be corrupt while the others are not or vice versa.
  • As the Sanghas do not interfere with one another, things can get pretty bad for a long time before anything is done.
  • Amazingly, Buddhist laypeople tend to stay completely out of the affairs of their monks and priests, which has been to the detriment of the tradition because if Buddhist laypeople knew WHAT THE RULES ARE, they would know when they were being broken. And by not supporting monks who violate the rules the Buddha set down, that would chasten them into behaving and having their Sangha implement the procedures of disciplinary correction that preserves the Dharma.
  • The standard texts on the Rules for Monks were translated by American monk Thanissaro Bhikkhu (aka Geoffrey DeGraff, Ajaan Geoff, Tan Jeff), abbot of Metta Forest Monastery (watmetta.org) in San Diego. Get a free volume of the full Vinaya translation.
  • Without pressure from supporters -- afraid to speak out against revered monks (viewed as a holy institution or "monkhood" rather than as flawed individuals among well-behaved monks), ignorant of the rules and remedies governing the lives of monastics, unable to exert influence on temples or access any recourse other than the civilian police (who are made up of many Buddhists also afraid and ignorant of monastic affairs) to find relief.
  • If a monk is engaging in sex, stealing, killing, or falsely claiming supernormal attainments, these are "defeat" (parajika) offenses, which instantaneously make that person not a monk and never again (in this lifetime) able to become a monk.
  • In addition, to these four defeat offenses, there are more than 1,000 other major and minor rules, many of them concerned with etiquette and appearances. But a core set of the rules governs every aspect of the life of an aspirant (anagarika), novice (samanera), nun (bhikkhuni), and monk (bhikkhu or samana, wandering ascetic).
  • The rules are for self-restraint as well as imposed restraint by the Sangha (Community) one enters, so it should not be viewed as a hopeless situation, for any monk, abbot, monastery, or governing board of a monastery board can start implementing the rules and procedures they previously ignored to set things straight if they wish to.
  • Sunlight is the best disinfectant, not moonlight and not darkness, so bringing it out into the open -- even if it is painful for the Buddhist community in general or embarrassing for the Thai Buddhist community in particular -- is the best thing. If, for example, there is child molestation in your household, should you (A) ignore it, (B) hide it at all costs, (C) confront it, or (D) call it out so that it can be confronted? The answer is C or D, and confronting it is very unlikely and not likely to be successful even if attempted. What does that leave us? Looking away or doing something effective. And that means bringing it out into the open, no matter how painful or embarrassing. If Catholic/Protestant Christianity did this, imagine how many rapes, violations, and molestations could be avoided. But it's just too easy to see no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil, and give cover and delight to the corrupt heads of the Church collecting dues and engaging in all the evil the world has to offer with an extra big helping of hypocrisy on top.
ABOUT: Foreign Correspondent is the prime-time international public affairs program on Australia's national broadcaster, ABC-TV. It produces half-hour in-depth reports for broadcast across ABC's television channels and digital platforms. Since 1992, its teams have journeyed to more than 170 countries to report on war, natural calamity, and social and political upheaval – through the eyes of the people at the heart of it all. Watch more ABC News content ad-free on ABC iView: ab.co/2OB7Mk1 For more from ABC News: ab.co/2kxYCZY. Get breaking news and livestreams from ABC News channel: newsonabc, Facebook: abcnews.au, Instagram: abcnews_au, Twitter: abcnews. Contributions may be removed if they violate ABC’s Online Terms of Use abc.net.au/conditions.htm (Section 3). This is an official Australian Broadcasting Corporation YouTube channel
  • Foreign Correspondent, ABC News, Australia, Aug. 8, 2024; Eds., Wisdom Quarterly

Sunday, August 13, 2023

The Masturbation Sutras (Theravada Vinaya)

"My gun went off! My gun went off! Are we not supposed to play with our guns?"
.
What we are here calling "sutras" (Pali suttas) are actually origin stories for monastic rules. They are found in the Theravada Buddhist Monastic Disciplinary Code (Vinaya), where the Buddha established a rule only after an incident. The backstory was recorded along with the new rule. The Great Analysis (Mahāvibhaṅga) covers these offenses, one entailing suspension (saṅghādisesakaṇḍa) for monks [and another entailing confession, pācittiyakaṇḍa, for nuns].

1. The training rule on the emission of semen. Venerables [monks, nuns, novices, initiates, trainees, white clad ten precept holders], these 13 rules on suspension come up for recitation.

Origin story: First sub-story
You're not looking so good, Venerable. Have you been discontented with the monastic life?
.
At one time the Buddha was staying at Sāvatthī at Jeta's Grove, in the Multimillionaire’s Monastery. At that time Ven. Seyyasaka was dissatisfied with the spiritual life.

He looked pale, thin, and haggard with veins protruding all over his body. Ven. Udāyī saw him in this condition and said to him:

“Seyyasaka, you’re not looking well. You’re not by any chance dissatisfied with the spiritual life, are you?”

“I am,” Seyyasaka said.
  • Seyyasaka: A Buddhist monk from Sāvatthi who was found guilty of various Vinaya offences, who was therefore subjected to the Nissayakamma ("giving dependence"). Udāyī (Lāludāyi) was his friend and his evil genius. Vin.iii.110 f. (Dicionary of Pali Proper Names)
Just grab it just like this with my bare hand?
“Well, then, eat, sleep, and bathe as much as you like. And whenever you become discontent [inasmuch] as lust overwhelms you, just masturbate with your hand.”

“But is that allowable [within the Buddhist monastic rules]?”

“Yes. I do it myself.”

Then Seyyasaka ate, slept, and bathed as much as he liked, and whenever he became discontent and lust overwhelmed him, he masturbated with his hand.

After some time Seyyasaka [regained his glowing complexion and] had a good color, a bright face, clear skin, and sharp senses.

The monks who were his friends said to him: “Seyyasaka, you used to be pale, thin, and haggard with veins protruding all over your body. But now you have a good color, a bright face, clear skin, and sharp senses. Have you been taking medicine?”

The Theravada monks' life is a hard one...until one attains the meditative absorptions.
.
“No. I just eat, sleep, and bathe as much as I like, and whenever I become discontent [inasmuch] as lust overwhelms me, I masturbate with my hand.”

“Do you eat the food given in confidence (faith, conviction) with the same hand you use to masturbate?”

“Yes.”

The [contented] monks of few desires complained and criticized him: “How can Venerable Seyyasaka masturbate with his hand?” They rebuked Ven. Seyyasaka in many ways and then told the Buddha.


He didn't overdo it. He's a saint in samadhi.
The Buddha then had the Monastic Community (Sangha) gather and questioned Seyyasaka: “Is it true, Seyyasaka, that you do this?”

“Yes, venerable sir.”

The Buddha rebuked him: “Foolish person, it’s unsuitable. It’s improper. It’s unworthy of a monastic. It is not allowable. It is not to be done. How can you do this? Haven’t I given many teachings
  • for the sake of dispassion rather than passion,
  • for freedom from bondage rather than bondage,
  • for the sake of non-grasping rather than grasping?
That's not why I wear glasses. I'm innocent!
“When I have taught like this, how can you choose passion, bondage, and grasping? Have I not given many teachings for the fading away of lust, for the clearing away of [passionate] intoxication, for the removal of craving (lit. thirst), for the uprooting of clinging (attachment), for the cutting off of the round of rebirth (samsara), for the stopping of craving, for fading away, for ending, for extinguishment?

“Have I not given many teachings for the abandoning of sensual pleasures, for the full understanding of the perceptions of sensual pleasure, for the removal of thirst for sensual pleasure, for the elimination of thoughts of sensual pleasure, for the stilling of the fevers of sensual pleasure?

David Bowie wanted to be a Buddhist monk.
“Foolish person, this will affect people’s confidence (faith) and cause some to lose it.” Then, after rebuking Seyyasaka in many ways, the Buddha spoke in dispraise of [a monastic] being difficult to support…

“And, monastics, this training rule should be recited like this. Preliminary ruling: ‘Intentional emission of semen is an offense entailing suspension.’” (Variant: sukkavissaṭṭhi → sukkavisaṭṭhi).

In this way the Buddha laid down this training rule for male monastics.

[Wet dreams] Second sub-story
There was no conscious intention of emission.
Soon afterwards some monks ate fine foods, fell asleep absentmindedly and heedless, and emitted semen while dreaming [wet dream].

They became anxious, thinking: “The Buddha has laid down a training rule [not an arbitrary rule] that intentional emission of semen is an offense entailing suspension. We had an emission while dreaming, which is not without intention. Could it be that we’ve committed an offense entailing suspension?”

They told the Buddha. [He responded:] “It’s true, monastics, that a dream is not without intention, but it’s negligible. And so, monastics, this training rule should be recited in this way:

[Final ruling]
“‘Intentional emission of semen, except while dreaming, is an offense entailing suspension.’” Source

Definitions
  • Intentional: sañcetanikāti, knowing, perceiving, having intended, having decided, one transgresses.
  • Semen: Sukkanti. There are ten kinds of semen: (1) blue, (2) yellow, (3) red, (4) white, (5) the color of buttermilk (6) the color of water, the color of oil, the color of milk, the color of curd, the color of ghee.
  • Emission: Vissaṭṭhīti making it move from is what is meant by “emission.”
  • Except while dreaming: apart from that which occurs while dreaming.
  • An offense entailing suspension: Saṅghādisesoti only the Sangha gives probation for that offense, sends back to the beginning, gives the trial period, and rehabilitates — not several monks, not an individual. Therefore, it is called “an offense entailing suspension.”
  • “Gives the trial period” renders mānattaṁ deti. For the meaning of mānatta, see A Translation and Analysis of the Pātimokkha, by Bhikkhu Ñāṇatusita, p. 123.
  • The point here, which can only be understood from the Pali, is that the word saṅghādisesa (saṅgha + ādisesa) is derived from the fact that only the sangha can do the legal procedures required when a monastic commits this offense. This is the name and designation of this class of offense. Therefore, too, it is called “an offense entailing suspension.”
3. [This is] the training rule on stimulating [slapping, rubbing, hitting, massaging, pressing] with the palm of the hand (talaghātakasikkhāpada*).

Rule for nuns
They may be monastics but are not "nuns," only Eight or Ten Precept novices (samaneris).
.
Origin story
It wasn't my palm like men do. I used a lotus leaf.
At one time when the Buddha was staying at Sāvatthī in the Multimillionaire’s Monastery, two nuns plagued by lust entered their room and stimulated their genitals with the palm of their hands.
  • [Their? Whose room, whose genitals? It does not say "their own." The careful reader cannot help but notice that it may be mutual masturbation being denoted, connoted, or suggested here, as it is plural and simultaneous, along with their questioning and rebuke, as if they were not alone and separate in the act.]
Hearing the sound, other nuns rushed up and asked them: “Venerables, are you having sex with a man?”

“No, we’re not,” and they told them what had happened. The [contented] nuns of few desires complained and criticized them:

“How can nuns stimulate their genitals with their hands?”…

“Is it true, monks, that nuns did that?”

“It’s true, venerable sir.”

“How could nuns do that? This will affect people’s confidence [faith]…”

“And, monks, the nuns should recite this training rule in this way:

[Final ruling]
“‘If a nun stimulates her genitals with the palm of her hand, she commits an offense entailing confession.’” Source
Definitions
  • Slaps her genitals with the palm of her hand: Talaghātakaṁ nāma if, consenting to the contact, she hits [stimulates] her genitals, even with a lotus leaf, she commits an offense entailing confession.
*Pali is a very euphemistic language. Talaghātaka is translated as “slaps her genitals with the palm of her hand,” literally, “hits with the palm.” However, it seems from the origin story that this was a euphemism, an indirect and therefore more polite expression, referring to [stimulation of] the genitals. Sp.2.803 supports this interpretation: Talaghātaketi muttakaraṇatalaghātane, “Talaghātake: hitting the genitals with the palm of the hand.” “Talaghātake pācittiyan'ti.]
  • Bhikkhu Brahmali (trans), suttacentral.net; Ashley Wells, Dhr. Seven (eds.), Wisdom Quarterly