Thursday, April 2, 2020
Heaven's Gate and Glass Skywalk (video)
Saturday, July 28, 2018
The Story of "Merchant Great-Wealth"
![]() |
| Greed is not good if happiness born of karma is one's goal (Minerva Studio/Shutterstock) |
The merchant thought to himself, "I have come a long distance, and if I go back again, I shall be delayed. Here shall I dwell during the rainy season, during the winter, and during the summer, working, selling these cloths."
- Note 7: These verses (found in full in MN 131) are a combination of the renderings of Ven. Ñanamoli Thera and Ven. Ñanananda Bhikkhu. See The Wheel No. 188, Ideal Solitude: An Exposition of The Bhaddekaratta Sutta, by Ven. Ñanananda Bhikkhu.
— "By all means go, Ananda."
Here the winter, here the summer,"
This is the speculation of the fool
Monday, March 26, 2012
Area 51 is real: museum exhibit (video)
Click to go YouTube for full documentary
- Happiness is Firefox (mozilla.org)
- The only real "free speech" radio in the USA
- Free Grief Relief workshop
- VIDEO: NASA sticks to its Moon story
- The weighty work of gnome called Kern Physicists looking at anomalies in Earth's gravity have turned to a garden gnome named Kern, which has been shipped around the globe to have himself weighed at locations ranging from Lima, Mumbai and Mexico to Sydney, New Caledonia and the South Pole.
- Shock Therapy's mystery closer to being solved While "shock therapy" has been used in psychiatry for more than 70 years, researchers had little idea how the controversial treatment worked to treat depression. It may now be solved.
- PHOTOS: Future art made of sand
- How US is tearing down Iran's electronic curtain
Friday, January 8, 2010
The Akashic Records and Buddhism
Buddhist Correspondence (Wisdom Quarterly)
How Cayce's mystical information corresponds to Buddhism is amazing and worthy of note. First of all, the name akashic is Buddhist. In Pali and Sanskrit akasa/akasha refers to space and sky. The beings that inhabit that region are akasa-loka devas, that is, luminous beings of the lower celestial spheres.
The "records" they keep in the akasha or astral world may in some way be related to the working out of karma. This is not carried out in the simplistic way popular Christianity uses to communicate complicated ideas. St. Peter does not open a literal paper book in front of a pearly gate and make decisions of great import on the spot. But that's as easy a way of saying what happens via complex psychological processes as most people are willing to grasp; we go wrong when we take it literally then carry it to its logical conclusions.
Older details have fallen out of favor. But devas have various functions and can be understood in terms of many mythologies. Most familiar to Americans will be the array of angels in early Christianity and demigods in Greco-Roman/Pagan pantheons. [After all, what is thought to be "Christian" today is in fact simply derivative of Sumerian, Zoroastrian, Pagan lore. Edgar Cayce (1877-1945), although thought of as "New Age," was a devout Christian who was thoroughly convinced of the Buddhist doctrine of karma.]
Karma may work as an impersonal mental process (former and present intentions ripening) bringing forth its results as opportunity allows. Nevertheless, devas are actual beings as real as humans. These "angelic beings" are, variously, guardians, watchers, aides, messengers, protectors, hearers, and so on. They are taken to be symbolic because they are not part of ordinary human experience. Yet, they are discernible through jhana-meditation (samadhi), mystical experiences, and aided altered states. Ascetics in India and shamans throughout the world have long known and spoken of their existence. Cayce, extraordinary in how ordinary he was, managed to be aware of these realities.
The vast majority of devas, like the majority of humans, probably tend to their own affairs. But legend speaks most prominently of how they intervene (or intercede) in human affairs. Famously Sakka, the "lord of lords" (Tavatimsa devas) and "king of kings" (Catumaharajika devas), keeps an eye on the world, holds back inimical forces, and attempts to keep the world moral (sila) so that the rebirth of humans will take place in the "heavens" rather than unfortunate destinations collectively known as the Downfall, which are less-than-human abodes.
It is possible that just as humans keep records on lesser creatures (animals, insects, microbes, etc.) using means incomprehensible to those creatures, some manner of more intelligent life has access to data storage that would stagger the human imagination. Karmic information is said to be carried around in one's center, aura, and mind or more holographically than any single geographic location. We are not beings limited to this visible body, although many moderns can see nothing beyond it.
In countless sutras, the Buddha does not seem to be speaking of devas and karma (information in the akashic record) in a figurative sense but as actual experience. Some say he was only employing "skillful means" (upaya) to relate to his audience: Indian culture is replete with talk of avatars, heavenly visitors, and countless "gods" (devas). For example, the Thirty-three gods were already a fixture in ancient Indian lore. Whereas meditative details are reserved almost exclusively for dense Buddhist discussions in the Abhidharma and commentaries, particularly The Path of Purification, talk of such things runs throughout the discourses. Wisdom Quarterly has access to individuals who have experienced these beings -- through meditative skill -- and can thus verify that such beings are not simply figurative. Karma really comes to fruit: actions really bear results with volition (intention) as the determining factor.
What devas (angels) and Maha Brahma (God) may look like when not in human guise
Note that the cogent argument against a belief in or literal interpretation of such beings, namely that they are described differently over time and across cultures when they should be consistent if they were true, does not hold up: These beings can manifest as humans expect to see them rather than as they usually are. Remarkably beautiful, they will adopt dense human form or more subtle, translucent form. And they have access to the karmic record recorded in individuals and in a mainframe database accessible somewhere in the sky, space, or heavens (all valid definitions of the akashic world or dimension).
Friday, June 5, 2009
Millionaire Enlightened Daughters
The millionaire Buddhist Anathapindika ("one who feeds the needy") was married and had daughters. He was very devoted to the Buddha -- his chief patron -- and would often visit him to discuss the Dharma.Before passing away, he attained stream-entry (the first of four progressive stages of enlightenment). Three of his daughters, while living at home, attained this distinction in purification earlier. Here is the astounding story of the millionaire's family.
Three Daughters
Adapted from Hellmuth Hecker (BPS, accesstoinsight.org)
Anathapindika was happily married. His wife, Puññalakkhana ("one who has the mark of merit") lived up to her name. As the good spirit of the house, she took care of the servants and of the monastics who came for alms at midday. She was devoted to the Dharma ("Teaching"). Through her brother, who had been one of the first lay disciples of the Buddha, she had become familiar with it.
Anathapindika had four children, three daughters and a son. Two of the daughters, Little Subhadda and Big Subhadda, were steeped in the Dharma like their father and had attained stream-entry. And just as they took after their father in spiritual matters, so too in worldly affairs: They were both happily married. But the youngest daughter, Sumana, surpassed the rest of her family in deep wisdom. Upon hearing the Buddha teach, she had quickly attained the second stage of enlightenment and thus was a once-returner.She did not marry -- but not because she renounced marriage. In fact, when she saw the happiness of her two [stream-enterer] sisters, she became sad and lonely. Her spiritual strength did not suffice to overcome her depression. To the deep sorrow of her family, she wasted away, eating nothing, eventually starving to death. She was reborn in the Tusita heaven, the highest form of existence in the sensual realm. There she had to purge herself of the residue of dependence on other people, her last outwardly directed desire (Dhammapada Commentary).
The Wayward Son
The only son of Anathapindika, Kala the Dark One, was at first a strain on his father's house. He did not want to know anything of the Teaching, immersing himself completely in his business affairs.Then one day his father urged him to observe a holy day, offering him one thousand pieces of gold if he would keep the Uposatha day. Kala consented, and soon found it relaxing to take one day of the week off from business to enjoy himself in the company of his family. Because of this, the fasting of the Uposatha day did not weigh too heavily on him. Then his father made a second request and offered him another thousand if he would come to the monastery with him one holiday afternoon in order to listen to the Dharma.
Kala was married to Sujata, a sister of the famous lay-devotee Visakha, mother of Migara. She was very proud of her family background and her wealth on both sides. Because her thoughts revolved around nothing but these trifles, she could not arouse noble thoughts. She was unfulfilled, dissatisfied, and peevish. And she vented her unhappiness on others. This was seen in the hostile and angry way in which she treated everyone. She beat her servants, and whenever she appeared she spread fear and terror. Nor did she follow the rules of propriety in her relationships with in-laws and husband. Thus, she increasingly made herself an object of scorn. ...

The "Prodigal" Nephew
Finally, mention is made of a nephew of Anathapindika. He had inherited a great fortune of forty million but lived a wild life, squandering, drinking, and gambling everything away. He paid thousands to various entertainers, women, and obliging friends. When he had exhausted his inheritance, he asked his wealthy uncle for support. His uncle gave him a thousand gold pieces and told him that he should use it to start a business.
He instead wasted it and appeared once more at the palace of Anathapindika, who this time gave him five times as much as before, without a single condition, but as a severance. Even the warning that this was the last of the money did not keep the nephew from his wasteful ways. For the third time he begged his uncle for money. Anathapindika gave the young man two pieces of clothing. But he wasted these as well and was shameless enough to call on his uncle for a fourth time. However, this time he was told to leave. If he had come as one of the many beggars and not as a demanding nephew, he certainly would have received sustenance from the house of Anathapindika. But this he did not do, not wanting almsfood but only money to squander.
Because he was too lazy and stubborn to earn his own living, while unwilling to beg, he died wretchedly. His body was found at the city wall and was thrown onto the refuse pile. When Anathapindika heard of this, he asked himself whether he could have prevented this sad ending. He then asked the Buddha if he should have acted differently. The Buddha resolved his misgivings, explaining how the nephew belonged to the fortunately small number of insatiable people who were like bottomless vats. He had perished because of real external needs, as had occurred in previous lives (Jataka 291).
- IMAGES: Daughters (bollyvista.com); Buddha with Anathapindika (goldenpages.com); The Return of the Prodigal Son by Edward John Poynter; The-Prodigal-Son.
Wednesday, April 8, 2009
What is Buddhism?
Buddha on Mandalay Hill, Burma (allmyanmar.com)
Samsara: Realms of Rebirth
In all Buddhist traditions, these realm are divided into three main levels: celestial, terrestrial, and infernal. The human world is the lowest of the those world considered "fortunate" rebirths. The heavens and hells have many levels.
- divinities (brahmas) and deities (devas)
- humans
- titans or ogres (asuras)
- animals
- hungry ghosts (pretas)
- demons (yakkhas)
Beings in the first three states are there as the result of their store of good karma coming to fruition. Beings in the other three states are there as the result of their store of bad karma coming to fruition. All beings have both fortunate and unfortunate karma. Celestials exist in the higher heavens, titans in the lower heavens, and ordinary humans in between. Humans co-exist with animals and hungry ghosts (so called because they are wretched and face many privations), somewhat closer to infernal worlds. Demons reside still further down but still mix with the human world.
Samsara (operating by karma) ceaselessly rotates individuals through the different states of existence according to their actions.
The Human Problem and Solution
The Buddha pointed out the human problem and its solution together. Four connected statements -- the Four Noble Truths -- form the foundation of Buddhism, differentiating it from other religions.
The first two Noble Truths describe the problem:
- First Noble Truth: All conditioned existence is unsatisfactory (dukkha).
- Second Noble Truth: Dissatisfaction arises based on desire.
Note that there are two kinds of existence, conditioned and unconditioned, otherwise known as samsara and nirvana. It is important to understand these two statements together. What we wish for but do not get is dukkha. What we do not want but get anyway is dukkha. Pain, misery, suffering, grief...birth, old age, sickness, and death, all of these are forms of dukkha -- an all encompassing word for unpleasant feelings.
Like a doctor the Buddha only points out this distressing condition because there is a cure for it. No patient is interested until the illness is apparent. The Buddha goes on to point out the reason for the illness. We are suffering, and there's a reason for our suffering.
Once the problem is understood, the solution becomes apparent.
- Third Noble Truth: Then end of craving means the end of all dukkha.
- Fourth Noble Truth: Craving can be cured by following the Noble Eightfold Path.
The third truth is a logical deduction from the first two. Given the link between dukkha and craving, the way to cure the distressful situation is to uproot the cause. How to accomplish this?
The Buddha saw the liberating truth directly when he became enlightened: He thoroughly understood the Four Noble Truths, including the fourth truth -- that of the Path to nirvana.
The Noble Eightfold Path to Freedom
The ultimate goal of the Path is nirvana, a word that means the complete end of all dukkha. The Path's eight factors can be put into three groups. The factors co-arise, that is, they are developed together not one by one.
A person possesses "right view" -- by hearing the Dharma (the enlightened teachings) and reflecting on it. This gives rise to "right intention" or ennobling thoughts: thoughts of non-harming, renunciation, and non-cruelty.
Nirvana: the Goal of the Path
Nirvana is liberation from samsara and dukkha (unsatisfactoriness and suffering). In some ways, the Buddhist goal of nirvana is similar to the Brahminical/"Hindu" goal of moksha (temporary "release" by rebirth into a high heavenly world, the World of Brahma).
The cycle of rebirth-and-redeath comes to a complete and final end with the attainment of nirvana. Moksha is temporary in the sense that rebirth into heavenly worlds is still birth. It is still within samsara. One eventually falls from that world when the karma that led to rebirth there is exhausted.
How does one attain liberation? It is through self-development and mental cultivation. This is sometimes called meditation. But it is much more than quieting and purifying the mind. Insight into the Four Noble Truths is usually accomplished by removing oneself from the regular distractions of life.
However, there is one undeniable difference between Buddhism and every philosophy/religion that has ever existed. This is the doctrine of anatta (no-self). Hinduism, for example, describes moksha as the realization of the unity of the individual (atta) and the universal essence (Brahman). Other religions try to get at the same idea. Buddhism, however, probes reality to the end. With the stilling of craving there arises a vision of nirvana (spoken of as a literal "light," a dawning of knowledge and understanding). As craving and other defilements (hatred, delusion, and subtle "fetters" binding one to samsara) are extinguished, nirvana arises.
Theravada (the teaching of the historical Buddha's ancient enlightened disciples) is the earliest form of Buddhism. It holds nirvana up as the ultimate goal, as the reason for the Buddha's teachings.
The Buddha taught the way to celestial rebirths and also made known how to be reborn in the human world, how to be rich, beautiful, influential, smart, happy, and so on. But the highest teaching is to be free of all ignorance and dukkha. A person who reaches liberation is called an arhat. The highest aim of Theravada Buddhism is liberation.
The human world is said to be the most conducive to liberation. One explanation for this is that those born in more fortunate worlds enjoy such bliss that they cannot see dukkha. Thus, they do not see the danger, the hook hiding beneath the bait. They therefore do not strive to remove themselves from the distractions of life to quiet and purify their minds. They are steeped in craving, and a mind/heart ensnared by craving does not perceive the Four Noble Truths.
So being die and are reborn in ignorance, and with ignorance come craving and aversion. These three principle defilements give rise to a great deal of suffering. There is no satisfaction in samsara, so being perpetually continue "wandering on" chasing pleasure and running from pain.
Impersonality and Impermanence
The foundational idea of dukkha in Buddhism has two components that need to be discussed. All states of conditioned existence have three characteristic marks or seals. That is, they are unsatisfactory, impermanent, and impersonal.
Anatta literally means "no self." It refers to the Buddhist belief that an individual, a "self," is the interplay of five impermanent, impersonal, and unsatisfactory "heaps." They are called the Five Aggregates (skandhas). These groups of physical and psychological factors come together at birth, dissolve and rebuild each living moment, and fall apart at death. They are not reborn again. In fact, they do not pass on from moment to moment.
The Five Aggregates are
- form (a dense or subtle light body)
- sensations
- perceptions
- formations (e.g., intentions) and
- consciousness
This understanding of a "living-being" is that everything that is reborn is transient. It is in flux even as it undergoes rebirth. This actually happens moment to moment in a discrete causal chain. Therefore, Buddhism speaks of rebirth as a process, not of a "thing" that is reborn again and again. Reincarnation is an Eastern philosophical idea. Anatta is a unique teaching, and it is associated with rebirth. Rebirth has a root cause, namely, craving-ignorance-aversion. These three, which are always in combination, lead to karma.
Confusion arises when people attempt to simplify or philosophize rather than practicing the Path and directly seeing these Noble Truths. The Buddha's goal in making this known was not to satisfy speculators, but to encourage individuals to grow in compassion and wisdom toward the attainment of complete liberation from dukkha. Not everyone chooses this goal of nirvana; many are satisfied to cultivate karma towards rebirth in celestial worlds. And that's a legitimate choice. When one chooses, the teaching one hears will differ. The great distinction is between conventional and ultimate reality, between a transient self that strives for happiness and rebirth and a choice to make a final end of suffering.
Whatever one chooses, Buddhism is certain on one point: the Truth is directly observable if the mind/heart is calmed, purified, and turned towards insight. And therefore liberation is attainable -- in this very life. The Truth sets one free ignorance-craving-aversion and thereby one finds release from samsara.
There is a useful metaphor for those who have not directly seen and directly known these liberating Truths. If a flame moves from candle to candle -- is it the same flame passing or a different flame? Conventionally we say it is the same. But ultimately we may notice it is not even the same flame from moment to moment. New wick, wax, and oxygen are being consumed. The root processes of combustion (with its heat and light) itself is impersonal. It belongs to no one. So long as new fuel is consumed, the process goes on. So long as karma has not exhausted itself, rebirth takes place.
New karma is made, and the process continues: the Wheel of Life and Death (the continued wandering on of samsara) rolls on. The Five Aggregates roll on. And with a new birth come aging, sickness, death, grief, lamentation, unsatisfactoriness, and suffering. These accompany the process in spite of where one is born, in spite of the length of life, in spite of taking heavenly form. There is always impermanence, unsatisfactoriness, and impersonality. To be sure there is happiness, joy, attachment, pleasure, and so on -- this is why beings are in no hurry to make an end of suffering.
The Solution: Enlightenment
Elated or miserable, this unsatisfactory state of affairs is rooted in ignorance of the Four Noble Truths. Until one directly sees and knows the Truth, there is no breaking free of the process. Craving arises from ignorance -- particularly ignorance of the impermanent, unsatisfactory, and ultimately impersonal nature of the process.
The answer to ignorance is wisdom. And liberating-wisdom finds completion at enlightenment (bodhi). The word means "awakening." Buddha is a title that simply means the "awakened one." He is fully enlightened because he teaches the way to enlightenment, unlike arhats who although they attain liberation may not be able to teach or explain the Path to others.
Enlightenment, waking up, realizing the true nature of existence opens to a vision of nirvana. That state is fully attained with the passing of all residual aggregates. It is the end of every form of suffering.
Theravada Cosmic Views
What is described here in brief are the earliest Buddhist teachings. Theravada Buddhism has remained faithful to these teachings and has attempted to keep them undiluted. They are personally verifiable. Therefore no perfecting of them is necessary since the assumptions and false conclusion would necessarily veer from the truth seen and taught by the historical Buddha.
That has not kept individuals and entire schools from veering however. Mahayana Buddhism has made changes, adding and changing doctrines, simplifying and condensing information (e.g., reducing 31 Planes of Existence to Six Realms), expanding and speculating on matters not crucial to the goal of enlightenment, in all building up a "better" philosophy. Mahayana describes the same problem while concluding that there is a different solution than the one proposed by the historical Shakyamuni Buddha (the former prince Siddhartha Gautama).
Buddhism continues to be a vibrant tradition, the subject of many lectures (such as this one at UCLA)
- Text corrects common errors from the University of Wyoming: uwacadweb.uwyo.edu
Sunday, July 6, 2008
31 Planes of Existence (Theravada)

But the Buddha also taught that our actions have effects that extend far beyond our present life, determining the quality of rebirth we can expect after death: act in wholesome, skillful ways and you are destined for a favorable rebirth; act in unwholesome, unskillful ways and an unpleasant rebirth awaits. Thus we coast for aeons through Samsara, propelled from one birth to the next by the quality of our choices and our actions.
It is pointless to debate whether these realms are real or simply fanciful metaphors that describe the various mind-states we might experience in this lifetime. The real message of this cosmology is this: unless we take steps to break free of the iron grip of kamma, we are doomed to wander aimlessly from one state to another, with true peace and satisfaction forever out of reach. The Buddha's revolutionary discovery came in finding that there is a way to break free: the Noble Eightfold Path, which equips us with precisely the tools we need to escape from this wearisome wandering, once and for all, to a true and unshakeable freedom.
(31) Neither-perception-nor-non-perception. The inhabitants of these realms are possessed entirely of mind. Having no physical body, they are unable to hear Dharma teachings. Attained by the cultivating the Fourth formless jhana
(30) Nothingness, the Void, attained through the Third formless jhana
(29) Infinite Consciousness, attained through the Second formless jhana
(28) Infinite Space, attained through the First formless jhana
II. The Fine-Material World(27) Peerless devas. These are the five Pure Abodes, which are accessible only to non-returners (anagami) and arahants. Beings who become non-returners in other planes are reborn here, where they attain enlightenment. Among its inhabitants is Brahma Sahampati, who requested the Buddha to teach Dharma to the world (SN 6.1). Attained by Fourth form jhana. See, for example, AN 4.123.
(26) Clear-sighted devas.
(25) Beautiful devas.
(24) Untroubled devas.
(23) Devas not Falling Away.
(22) Unconscious beings, only body is present; no mind.
(21) Very Fruitful devas. Beings in these planes enjoy varying degrees of jhanic bliss.
(20) Devas of Refulgent Glory. Attained through Third form jhana (highest degree). See, for example, AN 4.123.
(19) Devas of Unbounded Glory. Attained through Third form jhana (medium degree)
(18) Devas of Limited Glory. Attained through Third form jhana (minor degree)
(17) Devas of Streaming Radiance. Attained through Second form jhana (highest degree). See, for example, AN 4.123.
(16) Devas of Unbounded Radiance. Attained through Second form jhana (medium degree).
(15) Devas of Limited Radiance. Second form jhana (minor degree)
(14) Great Brahmas [gods]. One of this realm's most famous inhabitants is the Maha Brahma, a deity whose delusion leads him to regard himself as the all-powerful, all-seeing creator of the universe (DN 11). Attained through the First form jhana (highest degree).
(13) Ministers of Brahma. Beings in these planes enjoy varying degrees of jhanic bliss. Attained through First form jhana (medium degree).
(12) Retinue of Brahma. Attained through First form jhana (minor degree). See, for example, AN 4.123.
III. The Sensuous World(11) Devas Wielding Power over the Creation of Others. These devas enjoy sense pleasures created by others for them. Mara, the personification of delusion and desire, lives here. Rebirth here is attained through:
° Ten wholesome actions (MN 41)
° Generosity
° The development of virtue and wisdom (AN 10.177)
(9) Contented devas (Tusita deva world). A realm of pure delight and gaiety. Bodhisattas abide here prior to their final human birth. This is where the bodhisatta Maitreya (Metteya), the next buddha, is said to dwell.
(8) Yama devas. These devas live in the air, free of all difficulties.
(7) The Thirty-three Gods (Tavatimsa deva world). Sakka, a devotee of the Buddha, presides over this realm. Many devas dwelling here live in "mansions" in the air.
(6) Devas of the Four Great Kings [corresponding to the four cardinal directions]. Home of the gandhabbas, or celestial musicians, and [bhumi-devas, "earthbound devas," and] yakkhas. These are tree spirits of varying degrees of ethical purity, whereas the latter are analogous to the goblins, trolls, and fairies of Western fairy tales.

Bhumi-devas, yakkhas, gandhabbas (note Fly agaric mushrooms) by H.D. Johnson.
-
° The attainment of stream-entry (sotapatti) guarantees that all future rebirths will be in human or higher realms.
States of Deprivation(4) Asuras. The demons — literally, "titans" — that dwell here are engaged in relentless conflict with each other.
° Ten unwholesome actions (MN 10)
(3) Hungry Ghosts (peta loka). Ghosts and unhappy spirits wander about this realm, searching in vain for sensual fulfillment. Read Ajaan Lee's colorful description of this realm.
° Ten unwholesome actions (MN 10)
° Lack of virtue, holding to wrong views (AN 10.177)
(2) Animals. This realm includes all the non-human forms of life that are visible to us under ordinary circumstances: animals, insects, fish, birds, worms, etc.° Ten unwholesome actions (MN 10)
° Lack of virtue, holding to wrong views. If one is generous to monks and nuns, however, one may be reborn as an "ornamented" animal (i.e., a bird with bright plumage; a horse with attractive markings, etc.; AN 10.177).
° Behaving like an animal (MN 57)
(1) Hells (niraya). These are realms of unimaginable suffering and anguish (described in graphic detail in MN 129 and 130). They should not, however, be confused with the "eternal" hell proposed by other religions, since one's time here is — as it is in every realm — temporary. They are correct in saying that the lifespans here are seeming eternities. They can last aeons. Rebirth here is attained through:° Ten unwholesome actions (MN 10)
° Lack of virtue, holding to wrong views (AN 10.177)
° Murdering your parents, murdering an arahant, injuring a Buddha, or creating a schism in the Sangha (AN 5.129)
° Being quarrelsome and annoying to others (Snp II.6)







